Sections

The Xbox Story, Part 2: Gunning for Greenlight

Wednesday, 3 August 2011 07:11 GMT By Patrick Garratt

In the second part of the story of the original Xbox’s launch, Patrick Garratt charts the terrific obstacles facing the console’s team as it pushed towards a final greenlight from Microsoft boss Bill Gates.

As the fantasy of the Xbox situation turned
to reality, Steve Ballmer and Bill Gates
were forced to decide whether or not
Microsoft should risk losing $5-6 billion on
console gaming over five years.

Hit this for the previous installment, “The Xbox Story, Part 1: The Birth of a Console”.

The Xbox project had beaten off a rival console bid from Microsoft’s WebTV group, but the team’s real troubles in getting Xbox to market were only just beginning. It was time for some hard questions.

After the final stand-off with WebTV in front of Gates and Ballmer in June, 1999, there followed a meeting in Ballmer’s “tiny” private conference room with Bachus, Blackley and Bill Veghte, the head of the consumer Windows division.

“He started off by ridiculing us,” said Bachus. “He’s a very large personality. Bill sat down and said very quietly, ‘Now, Steve, I don’t know how much you know about what the DirectX guys are doing with the Xbox project,’ and Steve puts on this screaming voice and goes, ‘It’s going to be the biggest thing ever, it’s going to sell billions of units,’ basically taunting us about this hype he’s hearing within the company.

“But then he turns. He says, ‘Listen. You guys have some serious problems that you have to work out. What’s your cost? What’s your retail mark-up? What’s your reserve for returns?’ He’s a salesman. He understands that part of the world really well. He’s a very smart guy.”

Ballmer asked them what the retail price was going to be. They told him.

“OK,” said the Microsoft head. “Your cost is going to be $200 more than that. I think you guys need to go back and think about this a little more.”

“He really shamed us,” said Bachus. “There were a lot of uphill battles.”

At this point, the struggle to seat the Xbox project within Microsoft was intense. Bachus suffered a constant stream of executives through his office grilling him on the console’s USP.

“Microsoft was a spreadsheet company, with blue-screens and crashes and installations. Nintendo hadn’t done much that generation and Saturn had been demolished by PlayStation, so how was anybody able to hold up against Sony?”

Many of them could not grasp its function, and demanded to know if its “silver bullet” was that it ran IE, or did photo editing, or was a consumer Office device.

Bachus had to constantly explain to people that Xbox was a games console: it ran games. It was an unending conversation that ultimately hoisted the the DX team on its own petard.

“When we finally saw what the industrial designers had done with the original Xbox, we weren’t particularly blown away,” said Bachus.

“It was disappointing compared to what we had in our heads. But the product was so relatively expensive to build that they economised a bit on the plastic on the outside.

“They were like, ‘Well, you told us it was all about the games; it shouldn’t matter what it looks like.’”

Extreme prejudice

It wasn’t just within the company that the team faced serious perception problems. Bachus ran into immediate prejudice to Microsoft entering the console space when he ventured into the outside world with the group’s idea.

“I had to go out and meet with all these developers and publishers and they said we were going to be crushed by Sony,” he said.

“Microsoft was a spreadsheet company, with blue-screens and crashes and installations. Nintendo hadn’t done much that generation and Saturn had been demolished by PlayStation, so how was anybody able to hold up against Sony?”

Fries, the man in charge of creating Xbox’s first-party launch line-up, faced the same views over whether or not Microsoft stood any real chance in the console game, but was world weary in that respect.

“Let’s just say I was used to it,” he laughed. “Microsoft had been in the games business, really, from the very beginning, putting out versions of Flight Simulator a long time ago, and releasing games like Decathlon. But it had never really been a serious player in games.

“When I took over the games group at the end of ‘95, beginning of ‘96, it was my intention to try to change that, and there were a set of people there who were already in the process of trying to change that.

“I have a shirt in my closet I was laughing about the other day. It was from our first E3, and our marketing guy came up with this self-conscious slogan: ‘Microsoft gets games.’

The original leak about the existence of the
Xbox project, according to Kevin Bachus,
was down to Konami: “Konami went and
told Next Gen about the fact we were going
to do a games console. That’s how it
started leaking out, as we found out several
years later.”

“It sort of showed how much we didn’t get it; we felt we had to say it on our shirts.”

At the time Fries first took on Microsoft’s games division, some of the company’s first true “gamer” titles were being created, including Ensemble’s original Age of Empires, which released in 1997.

“I think that was our first true hit in the hardcore gaming business on the PC, and it let us establish some credibility and gave us the resources to grow,” said Fries.

“We did things like acquiring FASA Interactive and bring in Jordan Weisman, and that added Mech Warrior and Crimson Skies and his other properties, and more people from the hardcore games business into our world.

“By the time Xbox rolled around, I felt that we were reasonably well-established in the PC gaming space. We didn’t have to run around wearing shirts telling people that we ‘got games’.”

Not far enough

Microsoft first started talking about Xbox with third-party developers at ECTS in 1999. Jez San and other well-trusted figures were briefed on the project.

At the point third-parties became involved the inevitable happened: Xbox sprang a leak.

Said Bachus: “We had this deal with Konami. Konami had the rights to do special PlayStation versions of Microsoft’s PC games, things like Age of Empires. We had the rights to do PC versions of things like Metal Gear Solid.

“Konami went and told Next Gen about the fact we were going to do a games console. That’s how it started leaking out, as we found out several years later.

“But we were mostly able to do it very quietly, much more quietly than I expected us to be able to, and we gathered a huge amount of feedback.”

Away from London, Bachus and the team targeted the likes of Tim Sweeney and John Carmack for consultancy. The team started to process the data it had acquired from meetings with various publishers and developers, and the concensus was that Microsoft hadn’t gone far enough: those conversations were instrumental in forcing Xbox away from being simply a rebranded PC.

Bachus and Blackley took their prototype hardware to Vancouver to show it to EA and Microsoft Game Studios and, again, were told that their concept was too great a departure from the current console business. They liked the idea of being able to program games in Windows, but they were sceptical about the machine looking or feeling anything like a PC.

“At one point I remember Bill saying, ‘If we don’t have something like Xbox in the marketplace, we don’t have a comprehensive consumer strategy. Either we do Xbox, or we sell the games division to Electronic Arts, we ditch MSN and we just focus on servers and Internet Explorer.’”

While the team spoke to third-parties about software, the hardware side of the project was being pushed towards a self-built box. Dell, specifically, made the decision that it couldn’t make the machine as it didn’t have a slice of the software business involved, meaning hardware price-cutting would never be off-set by an increase in software sales.

Nvidia, too, became a problem. The GPU-builder’s initial estimates for supplying Xbox’s graphics centre became “a lot more expensive,” according to Bachus, when Microsoft finally came to placing an order. Nvidia eventually did build the console’s GPU, but it was a custom design created with Microsoft: the two companies ended up in court over their partnership when Microsoft tried to push the chip’s price down in 2002.

“There was a lot of challenge and a lot of struggle with that, and it felt very contentious. Bill, I think, was a huge propellant of what we were trying to do. Steve was a huge opponent. But ultimately, I don’t know, those two guys must have got together in a room: ‘Steve, I’ll let you raise the price of Windows in Afghanistan if you let me do Xbox,’ or something like that,” Bachus joked.

Real progress

The team continued to grow. Bachus and the rest searched Microsoft for staffers who’d already worked in the console world, finding people in the hardware division with first-hand experience of Nintendo and PlayStation. The project was moved onto the consumer side of the company under Robbie Bach, and J Allard took over as project manager.

“He was brought in mostly to be our adult supervision,” said Bachus. “The guys running the Microsoft hardware group felt they needed more Microsoft veterans on the project, so that J could go into Ballmer and say, ‘Remember how I told you the internet was going to be a big deal and it was? Well, now I’m telling you that Xbox applications need to run in kernel mode.’”

As the obstacles to launch began to fall, Bachus and the rest of the team were given permission to quit their DirectX day-jobs and move onto Xbox as a full-time project. As insane as it seems now, everything accomplished up to this point had been a sideline. This was in September, 1999, six months after the project was initially born.

At this point, the original DirectX group split. Otto Berkes and Ted Hase decided to stay within their original roles: they were long-time Microsoft staff, and had strong ties to their divisions. Bachus, however, had only been at the company for two years, and Blackley had been there for an even shorter time. They both moved onto the Xbox project as a priority.

“We were very passionate about Xbox, and when we had the opportunity to follow it we did,” said Bachus.

Gameplay from Ensemble’s original Age of
Empires. It released on PC in 1997, giving
Ed Fries his first core gaming hit for Microsoft
and part of the traction he needed to move
forward into the console space.

Even now, there was no final greenlight on Xbox. It could easily have been cancelled.

“Our task was really to try to prove out every outrageous assertion that we’d made: that we could get publishers on board, that we could build this thing, that it could be done, that it could be successful. There was definitely risk there.”

Bachus and Blackley started serious talks with hardware manufacturers, including a trip up to Canada to see ATI in a rented Bug.

“We were quite the couple in our bright yellow VW Beetle,” Bachus recalled.

This period lasted for around six months. Publishers and developers were rounded on again, and decisions were made on ATI versus AMD, 3dfx versus Nvidia, and so on. Bachus’s role shifted, with him moving from finance to hardware planning, making decisions on how many connectors the final box would have and which cables would be included in the pack.

When full-time engineers joined the team, it changed again, and he was given the responsibility of looking after third-party software relations while Fries readied the first-party line-up.

Blackley eventually moved onto developer support, but Bachus and Blackley both found this period of escalation difficult.

“We struggled to find our identity,” said Bachus. “When J was brought on board it was like, ‘You have to look after Kevin and Seamus,’ but he wanted to bring in his own people. We were trying to sort out the organisational structure as well as talking to all these people outside of the company, trying to figure out how to do it and be clever about it.”

Ultimately, though, the team coped with its growing pains and succeeded in creating a solid plan. Six months after moving onto the project full-time, the Xbox unit sought final approval to release Microsoft’s first videogames console.

The key meeting with Ballmer and Gates took place on February 14, 2000, just before the first, legendary Xbox tech demos were shown at GDC in San Jose, California. This was a tough call: Fries calls it the “Valentine’s Day Massacre,” and it decided not only the shape of Xbox’s future, but that of the overall direction of Microsoft, the world’s largest company.

My Bloody Valentine

A positive outcome for this meeting meant Xbox would exist. A thumbs down would send the console team back to developing Windows.

Rick Thompson moved from Microsoft’s
hardware division to become general
manager of the Xbox group in July,
1999. He resigned just after the
console was greenlit.

As Rick Thompson told Dean Takahashi in an interview for Opening the Xbox: “We looked around at each other around the table and asked if we really wanted to lose billions of dollars over eight years.”

Bachus told VG247: “We got together on February 14. This is Valentine’s Day, right? Everyone’s supposed to go home and be with their wives; this thing drags on for hours.

“It was very contentious. At one point I remember Bill saying, ‘If we don’t have something like Xbox in the marketplace, we don’t have a comprehensive consumer strategy. If we’re not going to do Xbox, I see that the decision is that we’re either an enterprise software company like Oracle, or we are a more comprehensive software company that encompasses consumer issues as well. So, either we do Xbox, or we sell the games division to Electronic Arts, we ditch MSN, we get out of all this other stuff, and we just focus on servers, Internet Explorer, and so on.’

“And no one really wanted to do that. I think that was what ultimately broke the loggerheads. Up to that point, and I’m sure beyond that, but certainly up to that point, there were a lot of things that could have caused the project to be terminated.

“We really didn’t make it easy for ourselves in that things changed from the original concept. Now we wanted Microsoft to build the hardware, and the components were more expensive than we thought. We didn’t want it to run Windows software, but instead something that was API-similar, in the same way that iPhone apps are similar to MacOS apps.

“You can’t run a Mac app on an iPhone, and you can’t run a PC game on an Xbox. That’s why the homebrew scene was so active on Xbox when it first came out: it’s similar to Windows, but it’s not running Windows.

“There was a lot of brain damage with that. But we were still able to go through with it.”

Said Fries: “It started at four o’clock. Bill and Balmer yelled at us for hours and hours, until seven or eight at night. In the last five minutes of the meeting they changed their minds. They decided to approve the project.

“A big part of why they were mad was because we were telling them that we were dropping Windows, and that we were doing this custom OS for it.”

The team had been told time and again that Xbox needed to be a “true console,” as Fries described it.

“It started at four o’clock. Bill and Balmer yelled at us for hours and hours, until seven or eight at night. In the last five minutes of the meeting they changed their minds. They decided to approve the project.”

“It needed to have a very thin, light operating system that we had a ton of control over, and that meant dropping Windows,” he said.

“And that was a very difficult discussion when we brought it up with Bill Gates.”

Changing the Xbox OS was a huge deal for Gates, although it’s not easy to see why looking back from so far away.

“You have to put yourself in their shoes,” said Fries. “They run this big company, and they’re trying to coordinate the actions of lots and lots of different groups, and every group wants to go off in its own direction. They all have their own reasons for why they should reinvent everything – developers love to do that – and why they shouldn’t share, or work together, or coordinate, because they don’t trust the other groups to get everything done on time. It’s always easier to go out on your own than to work together.

“They’re trying to wrangle all these groups to do what, in their view is the right thing: working on big, strategic initiatives for the company that are bigger than any one team, and in general that’s the right thing for them to do.

“But in the case of Xbox, what was really the right thing to do, and what they ultimately approved, was to separate us, to really say, ‘What you’re doing is completely different. Go off on your own and make it work.’”

They’d won. Microsoft would launch Xbox. The Valentine’s meeting was held just before GDC that year, and Gates himself was booked to speak, which was, in itself, previously unthinkable. There was great excitement in the western games world. The week before the GDC keynote on March 10, 2000, Bachus went to Gates’ office, showed him the Xbox tech demos and “got him ready”. They connected up one of the prototype machines to a monitor and showed him the presentation software.

This was the start of Xbox’s public push. We were about to see Bill Gates in a leather jacket.

Part 3 – GDC, CES and the rush to launch.

Latest

  • Star Wars Battlefront footage shown behind closed doors

    Star Wars Battlefront is being shown to retailers. Now we want EA to show it to us. Star Wars Battlefront is expected sometime this year, so it’s about time EA gave us a look at DICE’s latest. It turns out that while press and gamers have had to twiddle their thumbs, EA is showing it […]

  • Dragon Age lead creative moves onto mysterious new BioWare project

    Dragon Age creator David Gaider is leaving his baby behind. Dragon Age is a team effort, but Gaider was one of the key creatives behind the franchise, creating the setting of Thedas (which, I was recently amused to learn, is an acronym: “THE Dragon Age Setting”). He was lead writer on all three games and […]

  • Unity 5 available for free with “no fucking around”

    Unity 5 looks amazing, and you can download and faff about with it for free right now. “We’re not nickel-and-diming people. When we say it’s free, it’s free. We’re not charging a royalty, which I think is akin to looking for whales.” Unity Technologies announced the release of the fifth version of its popular, simple, […]

  • Five Nights at Freddy’s 3 may be the end of the series

    Five Nights at Freddy’s 3 released yesterday, and many fans theorise that it marks the end of the series. Five Nights at Freddy’s developer Scott Cawthon has released a new teaser image on his website, but rather than pointing to a new game, many fans believe the teaser signals the end of the series. The […]

  • Source 2 announced, will also be free

    Valve has formally unveiled Source Engine 2, the third major engine to go free to developers at GDC 2015. Source 2 is the successor to the engine Valve has been using since Counter-Strike: Source and Half-Life 2. Valve didn’t have much to say about the technicalities of this long-awaited release. It is apparently focused on […]

  • SteamVR: Valve’s Lighthouse tech allows you to walk around while playing

    SteamVR’s key differentiator is a piece of tech allowing headsets to connect with other devices for extra accurate, room-scale tracking. Valve has announced a new bit of technology called Lighthouse, which it is making freely available to any hardware manufacturer. Like the extra tracking LEDs on Sony’s updated Project Morpheus, Lighthouse improves the headset’s accuracy, […]

  • Steam Machines, Controller, streaming box to launch in November

    Steam Machines will finally become a reality before the end of the year. Valve’s living room PC systems will release in November, the company announced today. Well, I say Valve’s – the idea behind Steam Machines is that a number of manufacturers will offer variously priced systems. Alienware and Falcon Northwest are among the dozen […]

  • Telltale veterans form new team, announce teen thriller Oxenfree

    Oxenfree is a supernatural teen thriller from some of the team behind Telltale Games’ award-winning adventures. New indie Night School Studios unveiled Oxenfree at GDC 2015. It tells the story of a group of friends who accidentally open a “ghostly rift” at an overnight party on the coast. Night School, which is made up of […]

  • PS4 global sales now stand at over 20.2 million

    The PS4 has sold 20.2 million units worldwide. Sony announced the new PS4 sales milestone at GDC 2015 today. It’s a hell of an achievement and salt in the wounds for Microsoft, which hasn’t updated us on Xbox One sales since it shipped “almost” 10 million back in November last year, and has fallen back […]

  • PS4 VR headset Morpheus out in 2016, capable of 120 FPS

    Sony’s VR headset Project Morpheus has some impressive grunt. Virtual reality and Morpheus were the heart of Sony’s GDC 2015 presentation today, ahead of its newly announced first-half 2016 comemrcial launch. SCE Worldwide Studios boss Shuhei Yoshida detailed the headset’s impressive capabilities, notably the fact that it can handle 120 FPS VR games. The PS4 […]

  • Papo & Yo developer making a VR game about dinosaurs

    Some days you write a headline and it makes you so happy that that you have to do a little chair dance, you know what I mean? Papo & Yo developer Minority Media, whom I would personally go to the wall for after they cut out my heart and stomped on it via the medium […]

  • Wasteland 2, Shovel Knight and more in big ole bunch of indies coming to Xbox One

    Xbox One owners are about to receive a pile of great new indie games. At GDC 2015, Microsoft revealed a list of new indie games headed to Xbox One. Some of these titles have already released on other platforms, so it looks like Microsoft has really relaxed the parity clause of ID@Xbox – or perhaps […]

  • Here’s an indie VR game made with Unreal Engine 4

    GDC 2015 is blowing up with indie games, VR and Unreal Engine 4, so here’s a video combining all three. Loading Human is a virtual reality adventure from indie developer Untold Games. It’s in the works for Mac and PC, and Sony has given an early green light for Project Morpheus, too, so expect it […]

  • GTA Online: Daily Objectives and Adversary Mode coming next week

    Heists aren’t the only thing coming to GTA Online next week: players can also expect Adversary Modes, new Daily Objectives and other Freemode activities. GTA Online’s Adversary Modes are new PvP modes which feature a range of competitive challenges and will unlock as players progress through Heists. Here’s a rundown straight from Rockstar: Come Out […]

  • Syndicate is the latest free game download on Origin

    The latest free title to be added to EA’s Origin service is 1993′s Syndicate. For a limited time, you can download the game for free and keep it, much like previous titles such as Theme Hospital. The isometric, real-time, tactical-action game was developed by Bullfrog Productions and released in June 1993. It is a favorite […]

  • Ancient Labyrinth DLC for Lords of the Fallen now available

    The Ancient Labyrinth DLC for Lords of the Fallen is now available for PC, PlayStation 4, and Xbox One. It will run you $7.99 and builds upon the existing lore, characters, and storyline. Have a look at some new screenshots in the gallery below.

  • Shadowrun Online gets a name change and release date

    Shadowrun Online developer Cliffhanger Productions has announced the game’s name has been changed to Shadowrun Chronicles: Boston Lockdown and a release date for April has been set. The new title was formed via the developer and its Kickstarter backers, with the goal being to let those unfamiliar with the game know by the title alone […]

  • Amazon hosting Rockstar and 2K Games sale

    Amazon is hosting a Rockstar Games and 2K Games sale with discounts Max Payne titles, Bully and more. Here’s just some of the offerings listed: Manhunt 2 PC Download $3.00 Max Payne 3 PC Download $4.00 Bully: Scholarship Edition PC Download $3.00 LA Noire Xbox 360 $2.95 L.A. Noire: The Complete Edition PC Download $6.00 […]

  • Destiny weekly reset video shows off Inferno Crucible gameplay

    We have a gameplay video featuring Inferno Crucible gameplay featured in the Destiny weekly reset for you. In it, Arekkz Gaming gives you a look at Inferno Crucible and goes over the various intricacies. You can read up on the weekly reset through the links.

  • Resident Evil: Revelations 2 Episode 2 available from today

    Episode 2 for Resident Evil: Revelations 2 is now available. If you’ve purchased the Complete Season, you’ll be able to download Episode 2 on PS3, PS4 and Xbox One. Steam players should see the episode go live around 9-10pm PST, and Xbox 360 owners should be able to download very early tomorrow morning, per Capcom […]

  • Here’s a sneak peek video for Warhammer: End Times – Vermintide

    Fatshark Games has released a sneak peek video for its upcoming Games Workshop title, Warhammer: End Times – Vermintide. Vermintide is a FPS, co-op action title coming to PC, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One, and its set during the End Times of the Warhammer universe in the city of Ubersreik. Warhammer: End Times – Vermintide […]

  • Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare video shows Ascendance DLC early access weapon

    As you know, Xbox Season Pass holders now have early access to the Ascendance DLC Pack bonus weapons for Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare. Now you can watch a trailer for the weapon. The OHM directed energy hybrid weapon can switch between an LMG and Shotgun “on the fly,” and it also includes the OHM-Werewolf […]

  • March PS Plus games include OlliOlli 2, Oddworld: New ‘n’ Tasty, more

    March PlayStation Plus titles have popped up on the PS Plus page. Noticed by NeoGAF user skynidas, the titles include: OlliOlli2 (PS4/VITA) Valiant Hearts: The Great War (PS4) Oddworld: New ‘n’ Tasty (PS4) Counterspy (PS4/PS3) Papo & Yo (PS3) Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishment (PS3) A notice has also been posted on the EU PS […]

  • Sci-fi horror game Caffeine will release on Xbox One, PS4 alongside PC – new trailer

    Caffeine creator Dylan Browne has announced the Unreal Engine 4 game will be released on Xbox One. The game will be published through Microsoft’s Indie Program. As previously announced, it is also coming to PC and and now PlayStation 4. Caffeine is a sci-fi horror game which stars a young boy who has been abandoned […]

  • Xbox 360 Preview program invites going out this month

    Much like the Xbox One Preview program, starting early this month, invites for the Xbox 360 Preview program will start rolling out. Select invitees will be able to join program directly from their Xbox 360. A special Xbox Live message will be sent, directing users to head over to their Settings page. Further instructions are […]

  • Tron: Legacy director in negotiations for Gran Turismo film

    Tron: Legacy director Joseph Kosinski is said to be in early negotiations to direct the Gran Turismo film. This is according to the Hollywood Reporter, which states Michael De Luca is still slated as one of the producers alongside Matt Milam, Dana Brunetti, Josh Bratman, DeVon Franklin and Elizabeth Cantillon. Plot details are still unknown […]

  • Fifth add-on pack for Alien: Isolation is available for download

    The Trigger, which is is the fifth add-on pack for Alien: Isolation, is available to download from today. In it, players will “compete against the clock” across three new maps in Survivor Mode. Set before the events of the main game, players step into the shoes of Sevastopol Station’s Ricardo who will do what he […]

  • HBO Go app now available on PlayStation 4

    Sony has announced the HBO Go app will be made available for download later today for PlayStation 4. The app works just like the PS version. Now you can watch True Detective, Game of Thrones, Veep and more through your console. Information on installation is available through the PS Blog.

  • Skyrim mods no longer restricted to 100MB in size

    Bethesda has announced a beta for Creation Kit update 1.9.33, lifts the 100MB size restriction for Skyrim mod makers. The beta is for both Skyrim’s PC launcher and the Creation Kit which will allow for unlimited file sizes. Here are the notes: Creation Kit 1.9.33 Update Creation Kit now supports unlimited file sizes for mods […]

  • Mad Max release date set for September, PS3 and Xbox 360 versions canned

    Mad Max from Just Cause developer Avalanche Studios has been given a September release date, along with the new of a last-gen cancellation. The axing of the PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 versions were announced via Game Informer. Mad Max is the magazine’s featured game for the April issue. Avalanche, according GI, nixed development on […]

21 Comments

  1. mengyao0310

    Good Job

    #1 4 years ago
  2. manamana

    Superb read, just like yesterday, Pat. Looking forward to the next part. Thinking about it, it’s not that you will write on about the 360 and than at last reveal it’s newest successor, or is it? ;-)

    #2 4 years ago
  3. Lounds

    Thank god they dropped windwos from this system.

    #3 4 years ago
  4. Deacon

    Nice one Patrick !

    #4 4 years ago
  5. bpcgos

    Nice article,pat!
    just.. need .. it .. appear ..more.. often (dedicated feature once in a week will be great)!

    #5 4 years ago
  6. Blerk

    Really enjoyed this bit too. Marvellous stuff!

    #6 4 years ago
  7. Patrick Garratt

    Thanks, chaps!

    I will try to do this stuff more regularly. I’m hoping I will be able to from now on.

    #7 4 years ago
  8. Prof.Dr.Moertel

    A good read, indeed. I´m looking forward to part 3

    #8 4 years ago
  9. G1GAHURTZ

    Fascinating stuff!

    You should put it in a book and sell it, Mr Garratt.

    #9 4 years ago
  10. OlderGamer

    Yep yep, good reading once again. Well done!

    #10 4 years ago
  11. JonFE

    Great work Pat. The original Xbox was my first console (went straight from my Amstrad CPC to PC’s for my gaming needs) and this is a very interesting article for me. Keep it up!

    PS. Always wondered why MS has not tried to revive Flight Simulator on the x360…

    #11 4 years ago
  12. G1GAHURTZ

    No idea about Flight Simulator, but I heard that Microsoft Train Simulator is absolutely massive in Japan.

    Maybe they would do better in the Japanese market if they ported it, lol!

    #12 4 years ago
  13. JonFE

    Good call G1GA!

    #13 4 years ago
  14. Telepathic.Geometry

    Really interesting peek into the corporate world to see how these things get done. Cheers Pat.

    #14 4 years ago
  15. Ireland Michael

    This is the sort of thing that should be getting printed in professional industry magazines.

    Lots of unique details in this that adds a lot of substance beyond the history of the format that we already knew.

    #15 4 years ago
  16. Anders

    Very interesting read.

    #16 4 years ago
  17. Lacobus

    I love historical articles like this, especially when they are well written. Cheers dude.

    #17 4 years ago
  18. DSB

    @JonFE Have you ever played a flight simulator? Unless you’re flying like a 1970′s Soviet plane, there are so many individual keybindings that even a keyboard is too small :P

    There’s absolutely no way you could ever do that on a console. Even IL-2 Sturmovik had to be dumbed down considerably to work, and that’s 70 year old aircraft.

    I really miss the days when developers and publishers had a wider range, but with the limitations of consoles and the idea of PC gaming as being either “a huge risk” or “low return on investment” we could pretty much kiss those things goodbye.

    At least we still have Eagle Dynamics.

    #18 4 years ago
  19. JonFE

    @DSB, sorry for the late reply, just saw your comment.

    Sure, the huge number of keyboard bindings make it impossible to port to the consoles exactly as it was, but with so much data (geological, topographical and other) already available and a good graphics engine, maybe they could offer a less-simulating-but-equally-stimulating experience.

    As it stands, the once-popular franchise has been left to die…

    #19 4 years ago
  20. DSB

    True dat, far too many of those once-popular franchises have been left to die.

    I don’t see how watering them down and tossing them onto consoles would help that though, that’s how some of them died in the first place, whether strategy, tactical or sim. Franchises like Rainbow Six or Ghost Recon are pretty much living in undeath today, being tacked on to run of the mill shooters, and squeezed onto consoles.

    Looking at the growing number of flying games that do get tossed onto consoles, I think Microsoft would need to do something radical to make it work.

    Either they’re overly complicated and don’t work for that reason, or they’re overly simplified, and don’t work for that reason.

    It would be neat with a “zen” flying game though. I just don’t think that sort of thing is going be invested in outside of the indie sphere. Or to put it another way, there’s no way Microsoft is that daring and imaginative :P

    Either way, I’d happily settle for a properly done Crimson Skies reboot.

    #20 4 years ago
  21. JonFE

    Apparently, you’ve given this some serious thought :)

    A Crimson Skies reboot would be cool. They have even tasted the waters by releasing the Xbox original in XBL, alas at 1200 MSP and without multiplayer anymore.

    But truth be told, Microsoft’s first party strategy nowadays is nothing to write home about…

    #21 4 years ago

Comments are now closed on this article.

  • Heroes of the Storm playable at EGX Rezzed

    Heroes of the Storm will be playable at EGX Rezzed. This will be the first UK public hands-on with the online team brawler. Blizzard will also host giveaways and friendly tournaments at its stand. Tickets for all three days of Rezzed are still available, and you can purchase a pass through the official website. EGX […]

  • PES 2015 Data Pack 4 coming next week with Winter Transfers, new faces

    Data Pack 4 for Pro Evolution Soccer 2015 has been dated, and it updates the game with Winter Transfers, new player faces, and additional stadiums. The latest free update contains real-time player transfers made within the January window, and player ratings have also been updated. Additionally, a number of improved likenesses to key players will […]

  • Here’s the changelog for Dragon Age: Inquisition Patch 5

    Notes for upcoming Patch 5 for Dragon Age: Inquisition have been posted, noting improvements to gameplay and stability, and the new features outlined back in early February. Along with the new party storage system added to the Undercroft at Skyhold, players also have the ability to adjust the size of subtitles. Below you will find […]

  • Game of Thrones, Mortal Kombat X, Batman mobile games on the way

    Warner Bros. has announced free-to-play mobile titles spanning its DC Comics, Mortal Kombat and Game of Thrones properties. The following five new games under development are: Mortal Kombat X from NetherRealm Studios: The game blends fighting and card collection with cinematic gameplay and Fatalities. Play as both classic and fighters, and if you own the […]

  • Win! Beta access to new MMORPG Skyforge and DLC worth $70

    We have ten Wrath of the Gods Founders Packs to giveaway for new RPG Skyforge, worth over $70. All you need to do to win a Wrath of the Gods pack is enter your details in the form below and we’ll pick 10 winners at random on Thursday, March 5, after 3pm GMT. Skyforge is […]

  • PC gaming expected to be worth $35 billion by 2018

    PC gaming is alive and well. In fact, it’s expected to be worth $35 billion by 2018. According to game-business group Open Gaming Alliance, the PC gaming industry is expected to grow beyond its current $26 billion worth and to a massive $35 billion by the year 2018. The information is based on data collected […]

  • Advanced Warfare: new patch adds new weapon, Master Prestige ranks, more

    Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare has received a new patch that gives season pass holders early access to a new weapon and everyone else a myriad of fixes and additions. The patch went live today on Xbox 360 and Xbox One, without any official notes. CharlieIntel reports that among the new additions is the new […]

  • Destiny’s end game and raids explained

    Destiny’s end game can be a bit obtuse to those not used to MMO games. Fear not, we’ve got a few quick tips on how to crack it. Arekkz Gaming has a video for new players of Destiny or those who are looking to brush up on their knowledge of the game. Today’s theme is […]

  • Capcom adds local co-op to Resident Evil: Revelations 2 on PC

    Following fan outrage over lack of local co-op support for the PC version of Resident Evil: Revelations 2, Capcom has now added it. Resident Evil: Revelations 2 now officially supports split-screen local co-op in both campaign and raid mode. The update is currently in beta on Steam, but anyone can opt-in to try it. Capcom […]

  • New Destiny glitch spawns infinite Thralls on Earth

    Destiny’s latest glitch spawns infinite Thralls to help fuel your bounty hunting and loot lust. The glitch is simple to replicate. You’ll need to start The Dark Within mission on Earth, on any difficulty. Then follow the steps in the video below (Via DualShockers) to get to an area out of the map. You’ll then […]

  • Battlefield 4 Winter Patch is here with new game mode, netcode improvements and more

    DICE has released the Winter Patch for Battlefield 4. The patch brings an eSports focus with new game mode Squad Obliteration and plenty more. Battlefield 4 Winter Patch is now live on all platforms. It’s just over 400MB on PC and 1.34GB on consoles. The patch adds new game mode Squad Obliteration and more customisation […]

  • HTC hopes to see Half-Life on VR headset Vive

    Vive manufacturer HTC said that it hopes to see Valve games, including Half-Life, on the virtual reality headset. Speaking to the BBC, HTC chairwoman Cher Wang said that Valve is keen on having its games available on the VR headset. “I think Valve’s best game is Dota, right, and Portal and [Team Fortress] and I […]

  • Make money easily in Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate

    If you’re looking to buy a fell set of armour for your character in Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate but keep falling short on Zenny, this video will show you an easy way to make lots of it. Arekkz Gaming has a very handy tip for all Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate players: how to make Zenny […]

  • This is how you claim free Xbox One games from your Xbox 360

    Microsoft is giving everyone the ability to claim their free Xbox One Games with Gold titles from their Xbox 360 console, even without owning an Xbox One. If you don’t yet own an Xbox One and want to make sure you don’t miss out on all those free Games with Gold games, you’ll be pleased […]

  • Destiny weekly reset for March 3: Heroic and Nightfall detailed

    Bungie has reset the weekly cap of Crucible and Vanguard marks and added new Heroic and Nightfall strikes, now with burn. From now until next Tuesday, the weekly Heroic strike will be The Devil’s Lair with Heroic and Lightswitch modifiers. As for the Nightfall, you’ll be fighting Sepiks Prime with the help of Arc burn. […]

  • Few Mass Effect FemShep cosplays are as elaborate as this one

    The internet is full of Female Commander Shepard cosplay from Mass Effect, but very few are as terrific as this one. Visual artist Freya Willia has spent over two years painstakingly creating the perfect suit of armour and the best weapons to make her cosplay of Female Shepard as authentic as possible, Omni tool and […]

  • Deals with Gold: Assassin’s Creed Unity, Red Dead Redemption and more discounted

    This week’s Deals with Gold titles for Xbox Live subscribers is a good mix of modern games and old favourites. The list of discounted games through this week’s Deals with Gold is live with discounts on Assassin’s Creed Unity, Amazing Spider-Man 2, Red Dead Redemption, Max Payne 3, and more. The deals are live now […]

  • Destiny guide: how to maximise your Grimoire Points

    Destiny players regularly compare the size of their Grimoire Points. Learn how to make yours the biggest. Destiny guide: how to earn Grimoire Points In Destiny, earning most Grimoire cards is just a matter of playing the game, maybe a little more attentively than usual. You’ll either need to complete a certain number of actions […]

  • Shovel Knight: Plague of Shadows will let you play as a baddie

    Shovel Knight owners will benefit from the generosity of Kickstarter backers quite soon. Because Shovel Knight was overfunded during its Kickstarter campaign, developer Yacht Club Games committed to releasing free content updates. The first of these, Plague of Shadows, has now been detailed. The expansion stars baddy Plague Knight, who turns on his former allies, […]

  • GTA controversies, from Hot Coffee to PR manipulation

    GTA has a long history of controversy. The latest Did You Know Gaming tells the full stories behind the sensational headlines. Grand Theft Auto is such a byword for controversy that it’s easy to forget the full context of what actually happened to bring mainstream press, politicians and interest group awareness to the Rockstar series. […]

  • Infamous 2 one of five new PlayStation Now additions for March

    PlayStation Now will expand to the tune of five new games this month. The March PS Now additions are Infamous 2, Twisted Metal, R-Type Dimensions, Alone in the Dark: Inferno and Operation Flashpoint: Red River. PS Now will set you back $20 per month or $45 for a three month subscription. It offers all you […]

  • Final Fantasy 10/10-2 HD Remaster gets PS4 release date

    Final Fantasy 10/10-2 HD Remaster hits PS4 in May. The PS4 release date for Final Fantasy 10/10-2 HD Remaster is May 12 in North America and May 15 in Europe. Gematsu reports a special pre-order bonus calendar with art by Yoshitaka Amano is available through the Square Enix Store and participating retailers. In Europe, pre-ordering […]

  • Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare getting 15 new Prestige levels

    Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare players can now aspire to the ranks of Grand Master Prestige. Advanced Warfare developer Sledgehammer Games will add 15 more Prestige levels to the latest Call of Duty, giving players at max XP a chance to grow even further. According to the Sledgehammer Games blog, when you enter Master level […]

  • Destiny: Crota’s End recreated in Minecraft

    Destiny’s toughest challenge gets even nastier if you throw Creepers into the mix. The ultimate Destiny challenge – for now – is the Crota’s End raid. Taking place in an alternate dimension accessed through the Hellmouth on the Moon, the Raid takes Guardians through a pit of darkness to the resting place of Crota himself. […]

  • Xenoblade Chronicles 3D trailer introduces the Heir to the Monado

    Xenoblade Chronicles 3D protagonist Shulk is the Heir to the Monado, his distinctive red sword. Let this trailer fill you in on what that means. Xenoblade Chronicles 3D releases for New 3DS on April 2 in Europe and April 10 in North America. As well as all the content of the Wii original, it has […]

  • The Elder Scrolls: Total War mod covers Morrowind, Oblivion and more

    The Elder Scrolls: Total War is a terrific mod allowing you get get intimately involved with the history of Bethesda’s detailed fantasy universe. The first release of The Elder Scrolls: Total War dropped on the weekend, giving players their first chance to try out LoRdNazgu1‘s creation. This version runs from 3E 427 to 4E 45, […]

  • Five Nights at Freddy’s 3 out now on Steam

    Five Nights at Freddy’s 3 is out now. Yes, we’re surprised too. You can grab Five Nights at Freddy’s 3 on Steam for $8. Developer Scott Cawthon really doesn’t mess about; the game was only announced in early January. Here’s the blurb: Thirty years after Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza closed it’s doors, the events that took […]

  • EVE Online heister makes off with $13,000 worth of goods

    EVE Online is a hotbed of villainy, espionage and backstabbing, but one intrepid corporate thief has made waves even in this setting. The thing about EVE Online is that it’s a true sandbox: the game’s rules are very loose, and allow players to make careers out of theft, piracy, assassination and espionage in addition to […]

  • Marth Amiibo getting a stock refresh in North America

    Nintendo of America has announced a fresh supply of the difficult to find Marth Amiibo. The Marth Amiibo will be back in stock in the US in late April, the platform holder said on Twitter today. Planning to pick up Code Name: S.T.E.A.M. and don’t have a Marth amiibo? More are headed to stores in […]

  • Skyrim beta update upgrades creation kit file size

    Skyrim has been granted a new beta update – more than three years after launch! – to improve the experience for modders and those who use them. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim released in November 2011. I think that’s worth noting before we discuss the beta update that dropped today, even as Bethesda is working […]

  • Paradox’s next epic RPG is, uh, Knights of Pen & Paper 2

    Knights of Pen & Paper 2 is very serious business so please enjoy this very serious trailer. “Return to the dicey world of Knights of Pen & Paper for a new turn-based adventure, where players get to take on the role of players, and also of the game’s encounter-designing, rules-laywering GM in a fully customizable […]

  • Amplitude looks amazing in new gameplay trailer, has a team multiplayer mode

    Amplitude may have been delayed but we still get something this March: a fine new gameplay trailer. Amplitude is coming to PlayStation 3 and PS4 sometime in northern summer. It’s a reprisal of Harmonix’s classic rhythm action game, a forerunner to its later efforts with Guitar Hero and Rock Band, and was crowdfunded. Update: Turns […]

  • DayZ creator’s “crazy”, “esoteric” next game developed with Improbable

    DayZ creator Dean “Rocket” Hall has dropped the first vague details of his new game project. “I do not want to make safe games. I do not want to make games the way we have been making them. What if the most experienced video game staff in the world collaborated on the most esoteric and […]

  • Battlefield Hardline will support AMD’s Mantle

    AMD has confirmed what most Battlefield fans thought. Battlefield Hardline will indeed support Mantle. Battlefield Hardline will support Mantle, AMD has confirmed. Some players weren’t sure whether the retail version of the game will support AMD’s API, due to its absence from the recent PC beta. AMD did not say whether the feature will be […]

  • Unreal Engine 4 GDC 2015 sizzle reel shows what the tech can do

    Unreal Engine 4 is a pretty versatile bit of tech, as this new sizzle reel shows. As one of the more ubiquitous engines, Unreal will be on show at GDC this week. Developer Epic produced the following sizzle reel to quickly demonstrate what it can do – cutting edge graphics (there are very few games […]

  • Survarium’s latest patch removes limit on battle ammo, rebalances experience gain

    The latest Survarium patch has readjusted the value of experience and reputation points gained and removed the limit to the maximum amount of ammo you can use in combat. Survarium developer Vostok Games has released patch 0.27a to the public, having recently finished testing it. The patch is a major one and covers changes to […]

  • The Hunt Begins in new Bloodborne TV spot

    Bloodborne is so close you can almost smell its coppery tang on the wind – and also you can watch commercials for it. Bloodborne arrives on PS4 at the end of this month (March 24 North America, March 25 Europe, March 27 UK) so excitement is starting to build. Sony isn’t helping keep us calm […]

  • World of Warcraft: you’ll soon be able to buy game time with gold

    Blizzard will soon allow World of Warcraft players to exchange in-game gold for game time and vice versa. Blizzard has announced a new system that will launch soon for World of Warcraft. The system is called WoW Token. Using this system, players will be able to buy game time using in-game gold. Here’s how it […]

  • 3D Realms’ Bombshell returns with the first gameplay trailer

    Remember 3D Realms’ Bombshell? The isometric ARPG that was announced last year? Well, it’s back, and we get to see gameplay footage. The game stars Shelly “Bombshell” Harrison, a bomb technician turned mercenary with a mechanical arm. She will embark on a quest to rescue the president and save Earth, all while shooting aliens. The […]

  • Unreal Engine 4 is now free for everyone to use

    Epic Games has made Unreal Engine 4 available for anyone to download and use, for free. Unreal Engine 4 is now free. Anyone can download it and start using it, the developer announced today in a blog post. The download features the the full set of tools used by Epic, and includes 100% of the […]

  • Call of Duty European Championship winner announced

    The winner of the European round of the Call of Duty Championship has been announced. This past weekend, 28 teams representing UK, France, Germany, Spain, Italy, Netherlands, Sweden, Finland, the rest of Europe and Middle East attended the final of the European round of the Call of Duty Championship. UK team Epsilon eSports was crowned […]

  • GOG brings back Insomnia sale with discounts up to 90% off

    GOG.com is bringing back its Insomnia sale event with even more games. GOG’s Insomnia sale is back with double the amount of games. This year, there will be two sets of games available at once. The sets are seasoned classics and fresh new titles. Each set will feature games with discounts up to 90% off, […]

  • 2K is shutting down NBA 2K14 online servers, won’t affect career save files

    2K will be shutting down the servers for NBA 2K14 this month. The publisher revealed yesterday that online servers for NBA 2K14 will be turned offline on March 31. “You will no longer be able to play ranked games/online association,” reads the announcement. NBA 2K14 relied on online servers to store save files for MyCareer […]

  • One Dead or Alive tournament organiser is proposing ban of “over-sexualised” costumes

    A Dead or Alive tournament organiser has suggested a soft ban on some of the game’s “over-sexualised” costumes, and not everyone is happy. Tournament organiser “The HuBBs” took to the FreeStepDodge forums to suggest a list of rules that other offline tournaments can follow. The list goes over stages, characters, moves, which is certainly in […]

  • Destiny: all the news from Bungie’s open house Q&A

    Bungie hosted an open house Q&A session with the community last week and lots of exciting news have come out of it. Arekkz Gaming has gathered all the information that came out of Bungie’s open house Q&A in one handy video. The list is massive, going over Exotic weapon balance, upcoming events, PVE, Crucible rewards, […]

  • Elite: Dangerous and Star Citizen to honour Nimoy with in-game memorials

    Developers behind space exploration games Elite: Dangerous and Star Citizen will honour the memory of Leonard Nimoy through in-game memorials. The develops of both games have confirmed separately that in-game memorials will be established to honour the memory of the late Star Trek actor, Leonard Nimoy, famous for playing Spock. Elite: Dangerous executive producer Michael […]

  • Deal: get a PlayStation 4 + three exclusives for $399

    Amazon’s latest PlayStation 4 deal is not one to miss. With purchase of a PlayStation 4 console from Amazon in the US, the online retailer will throw in digital codes for Infamous Second Son, Killzone Shadow Fall and The Last of Us: Remastered, all for the same MSRP of $399. The Last of Us Remastered […]

  • Destiny: this is how one player predicted House of Wolves details and Xur’s inventory

    The method one Redditor possibly used to leak some details from Destiny’s House of Wolves was the same one he used to predict the inventory of Xur: Agent of the Nine. Last week, Reddit user Megamanexe4 leaked a few pieces of House of Wolves expansion content. The leaks included strikes, new Crucible mode, and a […]

  • Mortal Kombat X is coming to iOS… as a card-battler

    Mortal Kombat X will be releasing on mobile devices in some form, just not the one you except. Mortal Kombat X is coming to Android and iOS devices as an extension of the main game. It will launch in April alongside the console versions. The mobile game will be part card collecting and part fighting […]

  • Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain announcement coming this Wednesday

    Kojima Productions will unveil something about Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain this Wednesday. Metal Gear Solid fans should standby for a Phantom Pain-related announcement on Wednesday, March 4. According to developer Kojima Productions’ Twitter, there’s going to be an announcement at 2pm GMT on Wednesday. The developer posted the following image. The image […]

  • Reader survey: time to let us get to know you better!

    We’d really appreciate it if you could fill in this survey about the websites you read and the games you buy. It massively helps! You can fill out the survey right here and obviously all the information you supply is confidential. It helps us build a better picture of the people who read our site […]

  • Battlefield Hardline Premium: here’s everything you get for $50

    Battlefield Hardline’s Premium membership will give players access to 4 new features, early access to expansion packs and more. EA detailed the offer today – it costs $50 in total (£40 in the UK) and gives players a whole bundle of new gear and content. Check it all out in handy list form below: Masks […]

  • Hayter’s gonna hate: the voice of Solid Snake wouldn’t answer my Metal Gear question

    Voice actor and Hollywood writer David Hayter discusses the differences between movies and games. And politely declines my leading question. “It might be fun to do a crazy, over-the-top film version of Saint’s Row.” Yeah, that headline is a bit cheap but you’re reading the work of a man who once asked the maker of […]

  • Xbox One bundle gets £100 price cut in UK

    Microsoft has knocked up to £100 off Xbox One bundles in the UK. The Xbox One with Kinect Assassin’s Creed bundle is now £100 cheaper and comes with a free £20 voucher to be spent on the official Microsoft online store. Over on the Xbox online store there’s a £70 price cut on the white […]

  • Pokemon Shuffle downloaded 1m times, free stuff given out to celebrate

    Free-to-play 3DS title Pokemon Shuffle has been downloaded over 1 million times. As a reward for playing the match-3 puzzle game Nintendo has gifted players a Complexity -1 item for free. The item reduces the difficulty of a level, according to Eurogamer. By all accounts Pokemon Shuffle is a cynical game with poorly implemented microtransactions. […]

  • Trine 3: The Artifacts of Power sure is pretty

    FrozenByte Games has revealed Trine 3, due for release in 2015 And what better way to reveal a new side-scrolling adventure than with a very pretty trailer full of gameplay? The latest in a series that has already sold 7 million copies is earmarked for PC and “other” formats. Trine 2 released on PS3, PS3, […]

  • Dying Light takes UK number one

    A month since it was released on digital platforms, Dying Light’s physical release has topped the UK charts. Techland and Warner’s zombie survival game has proven to be one of the big hits of the year so far. It was released on digital formats a month ago but has only just been released on good-old […]

  • GTA 5: that’s some seriously accurate grenade throwing

    Think you can take down a jet plane with a grenade throw? This guy can. In fact, he can do it twice. This is in a variation on the player-created deathmatch “Stunters Versus Snipers” which seem to be all the rage in GTA Online at the moment. One team has a sniper rifle (and grenades) […]

  • Metal Gear Solid 5: Mother Base turns pink in the morning sun

    The Phantom Pain looks nice even when Kojima just takes a quick pic with his phone. Look at that beauty. We get nice reflection in pink at the first gray of dawn. pic.twitter.com/aERTBoZT9z — HIDEO_KOJIMA (@HIDEO_KOJIMA_EN) March 2, 2015 The game doesn’t have a release date yet, which makes us a bit nervous for it […]

  • Dying Light: Underpant Gnomes and 9 other secrets you missed

    Dying Light still has legs – maybe because it’s crammed full of secret things to discover. Ten of those have been highlighted by TerraMantis’ latest YouTube video, including reference to the Underpant Gnomes, guitar lessons, farting zombies and well, we don’t want to spoil it for you. Even if you think you’ve seen everything in […]