Sections

Gamestop: ‘Pre-owned good for the industry, doesn’t harm developers’

Monday, 6 August 2012 17:15 GMT By Dave Cook

Gamestop has revealed new figures regarding its American pre-owned sales, stating that they are worth $1.8 billion a year, but remains adamant that used sales don’t impact new, and that developers simply don’t understand how pre-owned works. Set phasers to angry.

In a Gamasutra interview, Gamestop president Paul Raines said, “We are not ashamed of the pre-owned business and in fact we believe that it’s good for the industry.”

Raines’ statement comes despite many game developers slamming the used sale methods of retailers, and the way they eat into new sales. With used sales, none of the profit made goes back to developers, and only the initial new sales makes them money.

Regardless, Raines stands his ground on the subject, “We have not been successful in communicating to developers how this business really helps. Now, if I’m a developer, I know that [used games] give me heartburn, to see a game…”

It’s here Gamasutra reports that Raines tailed off before he continued:

“We’re really not cannibalizing new game sales,” Raines proceeded, “That’s a common misconception. So my answer to developers is that we are driving growth in a category that needs to grow.”

Raines concluded, “We think there’s a real lack of awareness as far as how it’s good for the industry. The transparency you’re seeing from us is because we want people to know about it, helping people understand what we’re trying to do for the industry.”

What do you think of pre-owned’s impact on game developers? Speak you brains below.

Latest

  • Splatoon lacks voice chat to promote a positive online experience

    Nintendo’s multiplayer game Splatoon will not contain a voice chat option in order to “focus on the positive aspects” of online gaming. Speaking in the latest issue of Edge magazine (thanks, GamesRadar), Splatoon co-director Yusuke Amano said personal experience with negativity in online voice chat was one of the main reasons for excluding the feature. […]

  • D4 on PC: differences from Xbox One version, system specs announced

    D4: Dark Dreams Don’t Die – Season 1 is coming to PC, and Access Games has provided a list of features different from the Xbox One version. We’ve pulled most of the changes off the game’s website and posted them below, along with the PC specs. D4 on PC Kinect gesture input controls replaced with […]

  • The Megalodon returns to Battlefield 4 with the latest CTE patch

    The Megalodon Easter Egg in Battlefield 4 may have been removed earlier this year from Naval Strike, but it has since resurfaced on the CTE with the latest patch. I’d make a Jaws reference, but it’s been done to death. The shark is shown in the video on the Paracel Storm map which was where […]

  • Survival horror game Kodoku has a new work-in-progress trailer

    Kodoku, the survival horror title from Carnivore Studio, has a new work-in-progress video available, showing you how the game is coming along. Announced for PlayStation 4 and Vita back in 2013, the game is slated for release sometime this year, and tasks the player with avoiding mythical Japanese ghosts using only magic and stealth. Thanks, […]

  • Current HoloLens prototype has noticeably “tighter” FoV compared to January build

    Microsoft’s augmented reality headset HoloLens is still very much in the prototype stage, according to various reports out of the Build Conference. Microsoft hasn’t discussed technical specs with the press yet as nothing is set in stone, but during a hands-on at Build, Ars Technica noticed the prototypes had a “x86 processor, 2GB RAM, 802.11ac […]

  • Silent Hills petition asking Konami to continue development has over 50,000 signatures

    A petition to save the Silent Hills game has been formed by fans in the hopes Konami will change its mind and bring the collaboration with Guillermo del Toro back from the dead. Konami confirmed on Monday the Silent Hill remake from film director Del Toro and Metal Gear’s Hideo Kojima had been cancelled, but […]

  • Attack on Titan has a US release date, title changed in EU over copyright claim

    Attack on Titan: Humanity in Chains will be released under a different title in Europe, according to the publisher, and while a release date has been set for North America, the same cannot be said for fans across the pond. According to Atlus, a copyright claim in Europe has forced the company to publish the […]

  • Yooka-Laylee meets final Kickstarter Stretch Goal in less than 24 hours

    The Kickstarter for Playtonic’s Yooka-Laylee sailed beyond its final £1 million ($1.5 million) Stretch Goal overnight, which will allow for a simultaneous release on all announced platforms. Once funded, Yooka-Laylee was slated for release on Linux, Mac, PC, PlayStation 4, Wii U, and Xbox One; however, a simultaneous release on all platforms wasn’t guaranteed unless […]

  • Not a Hero will miss its May 7 release date, but not by much

    Not a Hero will miss its May 7 release date, according to an announcement from Roll7. Not to worry though, it’s only by a week. According to the developer, the delay is due to “having undergone super-secret upgrades to crank shit up to 60fps.” The extra week will provide the additional time needed for tweaking […]

  • Assassin’s Creed, The Crew, Far Cry 4, other Ubisoft titles on sale through the Humble Store

    Ubisoft has put a number of its games on sale through the Humble Store. Franchises Assassin’s Creed and Far Cry are on discount as are single release titles. The list of games on sale are below. For pricing in your region, head over to the Humble Store. Anno 2070 Complete Edition Assassin’s Creed 3 Assassin’s […]

  • Payday 2: Repeater rifle, Peacemaker pistol introduced with The Butcher’s Western Pack

    Overkill Software released the 21st DLC pack for Payday 2 yesterday, titled The Butcher’s Western Pack. The pack will run you $4.99/€4.99 and other digital distribution channels. “For our 21st DLC we go back in time to visit the Wild West and the arsenal it was known for,” said the developers. “With it we’re introducing […]

  • The Yooka-Laylee Kickstarter just launched and has already met its funding goal

    Playtonic Games launched the Kickstarter campaign for Yooka-Laylee at 5pm UK, and in just over 30 minutes it already hit its $270,000 funding goal. You can watch the funding counter continue to roll over through the link. Yooka-Laylee is a 3D platformer where the characters use special moves such as Yooka’s tongue grapple and Laylee’s […]

  • Batch of hi-res Persona 5 screenshots released by PlayStation Japan

    A set of screenshots have been released for Persona 5, and while you’ve seen these before in magazines and on the official website, these are high-res versions. Some will even look familiar to those who watched the first gameplay trailer back in February. The shots were posted over on the PlayStation Japan Persona 5 game […]

  • Is Alien: Isolation getting HTC Vive support?

    Placeholder images for SteamVR icons have been found and it looks like there may be support for Alien: Isolation, so if you enjoy soiling yourself, get psyched! NeoGAF members found a thread on Reddit, where a little rooting around in a Steam directory unearthed the images. The list includes both games and apps, and as […]

  • Xbox Live multiplayer is free this weekend on Xbox 360

    Xbox 360 players in all Xbox Live regions can play multiplayer online for free this weekend. If you are a Silver member, this means you are Golden from May 1-3 and can play multiple games online with your buddies. All you have to do is log-in to Xbox Live.

  • Assassin’s Creed actor Michael Fassbender confirms film production starts September

    The Assassin’s Creed movie will start production this fall, actor Michael Fassbender (Prometheus, 300, X-Men:First Class) as confirmed. Speaking with ComingSoon.net, Fassbender said filming will start in September, which is inline with Ubisoft’s announcement in February. The actor will star in the film alongside Oscar-winning actress Marion Cotillard, both reuniting with their MacBeth director Justin […]

  • Eve Online boss states VR won’t be as big as we think next year

    I don’t think I’m the only one who wants VR to hurry up and manifest into a Sword Art Online-esque reality. Unfortunately, the chief executive officer at the studio behind Eve Online doesn’t think that will be happening any time soon. Talking to Venture Beat, Hilmar Veigar Pétursson touched on his excitement at the prospects […]

  • The Last of Us: Left Behind goes standalone in May on PS3, PS4

    Naughty Dog has announced that The Last of US DLC Left Behind will be released as a standalone experience next month. It can be purchased for both PlayStation 3 and PS4 through the PS Store and a two-hour demo of the Factions multiplayer will also be made available. “The Left Behind standalone game will have […]

  • EA’s annual E3 press conference takes place on June 15

    Electronic Arts has announced its annual E3 2015 press conference will take place the day before the show kicks off on June 15. EA, Microsoft, Sony and Ubisoft always hold press events the day before E3 officially starts, so this isn’t any surprise, really. The presser, dubbed “Live to Play”, will last one hour and […]

  • Steam exchange rate mix-up closes down community market

    The Steam community market was buggered up big time today after a mix-up with currency conversion had items selling from practically nothing, to millions of dollars. PC Gamer picked up on the news after a thread on Reddit appeared with screenshots depicting just how silly things were getting over there. The currency exchange rate data […]

  • Britney Spears signs five-year deal with Glu for new mobile game

    Pop star Britney Spears has signed a five-year deal with Glu mobile for a new, untitled game. The mobile game will feature her “voice, likeness, and creative influence,” and is due for release sometime next year. Glu also signed a deal with Katy Perry in February, so expect a game revolving around her to hit […]

  • Large Activision publisher sale on Steam discounts Call of Duty, Prototype, more

    Activision has put the majority of its library on sale through Steam this weekend, and if other titles weren’t included, it could be referred to as a Call of Duty sale. Below are a few standouts. Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare – Gold Edition 25% off Call of Duty: Ghosts 67% off Call of Duty: […]

  • The Dota 2 International Compendium is out, second Stretch Goal almost complete

    The International Compendium has been released for Dota 2 with the prize pool sitting at a lovely $1,917,155 as of press time. Valve said over the weekend to expect the International Compendium to drop sometime this week. As with previous years, those who purchase the Compendium can earn rewards by completing challenges, making predictions and by […]

  • If permadeath RTS games are up your alley, check out indie project XO

    The Square Enix Collective showcases projects for a limited time to help drum up community support and potential backers, and RTS title XO from Jumpdrive Studios is worth taking a look at. The teaser trailer is fairly brief, but if you visit the page for XO over at the Square Enix Collective, it’s understandable – […]

  • GTA 5 PC patch disables mods. Here’s how to get them working again

    A new patch for the PC version of GTA 5 was released yesterday and, as it turns out, has wiped the ability to use mods with the game. The wasn’t great news for some players, but YouTuber taltigolt has already figured out how to play the PC version with mods after installing the patch. Matt […]

  • Xbox One ad stealth launches a mysterious Halo 5 competition

    A new Xbox One advert released today isn’t as straightforward as it appears. The trailer has a couple of pretty conspicuous ‘glitches’ throughout, and members of NeoGAF wasted no time in breaking it down. The first item of interest is the screen from the hunt the signal site, which displays an error message when accessed […]

  • Battlefield 4 Jungle map improved with latest update

    DICE LA has updated the Battlefield 4 Jungle map, adding more foliage and a new route. As demonstrated by Westie in the video above, the map now has the kind of foliage you’d expect in the jungle, helping to conceal infantry players. The update also tweaks positions of objective points and has added a concealed […]

  • Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate free DLC pack for May includes Metroid and Mega Man armour

    The May DLC pack for Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate boasts some big ticket items, including Metroid, Street Fighter, and Mega Man gear. This big fat chunk of free DLC, detailed on the capcom unity blog, includes Hunter equipment: Metroid’s Varia Suit Metroid’s Zero Suit Metroid’s Arm Cannon Taiko Drum Master Hunting Horn USJ’s Star Rook […]

  • Destiny: Xur location and inventory for May 1, 2 – Hard Light edition

    Here he comes with his weird face, dealing goods and gear for Guardians. It’s Friday. Xur: Agent of the Nine is back in the Tower. Of Course he is. Got your Strange Coins? Here’s what’s in his bag this week: Ruin Wings [Exotic Titan gauntlets] – 13SC Don’t Touch Me [Exotic Hunter gauntlets] – 13SC […]

  • Dragon Age: Inquisition Jaws of Hakkon DLC drops for PS4 on May 26

    Dragon Age: Inquisition DLC has now been announced for May 26 for PS3, PS4 and Xbox 360. The announcement was made on Twitter via the official Dragon Age account. Mark your calendars! #DAIJawsOfHakkon pic.twitter.com/mU1WfkSrQV — Dragon Age (@dragonage) May 1, 2015 The DLC was released for PC and Xbox One back in March thanks to […]

23 Comments

  1. WFMMK

    I’ll take your word for it company that profits the most from used sales.
    That doesn’t seem weird at all.

    #1 3 years ago
  2. viralshag

    People are willing to spend money on games. You see it in many of the titles that sell really well. I think most gamers will always buy new if they’re sold on a product as the difference is often quite low between a new game and pre-owned new game, something like £5 maybe?

    I don’t believe the pre-owned industry really does damage sales all that much. Especially as there is never any figures or facts to prove it. I mean, we never hear anything about pubs/devs $10 project figures and results, this just leads me to think it’s nothing worth writing home about.

    #2 3 years ago
  3. Ireland Michael

    Just a quick note Dave, you repeated a phrase in there twice.

    RE: the story, I think the funniest part is how he constantly keeps stating how used games don’t harm developers but never actually bothers to explain why…

    #3 3 years ago
  4. Gheritt White

    @ 3: “I think the funniest part is how he keeps stating how used games doesn’t harm developers but never actually bothers to explain why…”

    I agree.

    Also: DEV RAAAAAAAGE!

    #4 3 years ago
  5. OlderGamer

    The sad part is someone will believe them.

    #5 3 years ago
  6. viralshag

    But guys, seriously what facts are there to prove him wrong? If someone can show me some I will happily hold up my hands and say I was wrong…

    #6 3 years ago
  7. Fin

    @6

    It’s not facts, its common sense.

    Which would developers prefer.
    A) People buy games pre-owned from Gamestop, developer gets nothing.
    B) People buy game new from Gamestop, developer gets something.

    The existance of online passes and shoe-horned multiplayer are the outcome of the pre-owned market.

    #7 3 years ago
  8. Dave Cook

    @3 thanks mate, double paste there :)

    #8 3 years ago
  9. viralshag

    @7, it’s not as simple as that though. You can’t simply ignore factors such as when they’re buying the product, how much for, whether or not they would ever buy it new or if they buy any new games at full price.

    I don’t think there are enough facts or figures available for people to make an accurate assessment of the situation.

    #9 3 years ago
  10. OlderGamer

    Viral there is so much evidence to prove this tool wrong. Perhaps I will come back and drop some links. I don’t have time right now.

    Fin is right tho, just common sense. Two points, if it was no big deal, why do so many people complain, and why do Gamestop feel the need to defend it? And, the point he made: pubd make money when you buy a new game, they make nothing when the game is used.

    #10 3 years ago
  11. OlderGamer

    Sigh, Viral I gott go lol.

    Look there is another angle your not seeing. When GS have preorders for USED copies. They clearly have no intention of selling new copies, yet anticipate the game will sell. That is lost revenue for the people that actual make and publish the game.

    It is one of the reasons the prelaunch hype and preoder are such a big deal. because of GS used game sales, the tail for selling your game long term is greatly diminished. You have a very small window to make your money on the game. Hence DLC, online play passes, etc.

    Again just common sense. Used games sales = bad.

    #11 3 years ago
  12. ManuOtaku

    I dont know, but i think theres a need for a well trought out study about this subject, and intwertined this data with sales for the reduced first hand games at retail, steam, amazon,etc, just to see an overall picture, i got the feeling that the percentage of people that wait for a big discount like those found on steam or amazon are a little bit bigger than second hand sales, or at the very least they they are really close, but a study in this front is needed.

    Also i think this is a rather subjective issue, and for that blaming a sector like this is blind sided, what some people find value and for that are willing to pay full price for a game, lets say max payne 3 fans, doenst apply to others that maybe will wait for a big price drop before buying it first hand or go instead with used sales for a price tag that in their eyes is worht it, therefore as subjective as value is, i think is wrong labeling this things, at least the industry should ponder is the price of games too much or not, because of the success of second hand games, and the big sale numbers when the games are reduced in price, like steam or amazon, if they dont do that they can´t find the proper answer to counter this, instead the go with the route of more money making like DLC and the likes, which is again in itself another problem IMHO.

    p.s and i agree with Michael he didnt stated the reasons why he believes this type of business are good for developers and publishers.

    #12 3 years ago
  13. Gadzooks!

    If there wasn’t a used games market I, and many many other gamers I know would spend considerably less on games.

    Trade-ins have been an integral part of the game scene for at least a decade.

    It’s not a black and white issue.

    #13 3 years ago
  14. Sasha_Je

    The only thing GameStop and every other similar company does is exploiting the industry. Games lack content, end-game content and replay-ability. I will never go and try to sell a game that manages to bring me something “new” if I can put it this way. They don’t unpack new games and sell them as used, it’s the games sold by us, gamers that they are selling. If developers want to combat this market they have to come up with games that bring more content ( and DLC does not count ) or someway to “force” us not to sell them.

    Best regards,

    Sasha_

    #14 3 years ago
  15. OrbitMonkey

    Used games are bad for a dev, but good for the consumer. Do they damage the actual industry… Er no more than piracy I’d imagine… And look how that’s killed the pc market.

    Oh wait it hasn’t.

    #15 3 years ago
  16. viralshag

    @Manu, I totally agree with your idea that more people wait for the huge discount sales on Steam than people wait to purchase pre-owned.

    @OG, There really is more to this than just “using common sense”. This is a topic that essentially comes down to financials and the bottom line. And as people have said, the used game market and piracy have been a part of the industry for easily over a decade. If it truly was such a strain then they would do far more to counter it but my guess is the loss through used sales would be a lot less than what they are willing to spend to counter it. And is therefore considered an acceptable “loss”.

    All I’m saying is I want to see hard figures of how and why it affects the industry negatively. I don’t think we can really say it is harmful because of what we think, it has to be what we know. And as used games is (and I am guessing here) an unknown quantity to both devs and pubs, I don’t know how they can gauge what profit/sales they are realistically losing.

    #16 3 years ago
  17. majicship

    In order for a game to be considered used it must first be purchased by a consumer at the retail price. This gives the developer/distributor etc. their cut of the money. Nobody is going to complain about that.

    However, if the rightful owner of the copy of the game (who has already bought it new) decides to sell his lawfuly purchased copy on to somebody else, what on earth does this have to do with anybody other than the seller and the subsequent buyer?

    #17 3 years ago
  18. OlderGamer

    “Used games market

    Gamestop has frequently been criticized by game developers and publishers for the retailing of used game titles.[25] By reselling used copies at a small discount on the same shelf space as new copies of the game, it is argued that Gamestop is taking profits directly from organizations such as developers and publishers which are solely dependent on their intellectual property for revenue. The motion picture industry prohibits selling second-hand copies of films in the same retail space as new, full-priced copies of films,[citation needed] but for the game industry there are no such established protections. In effect, this means that companies such as GameStop can resell used copies of a game within days of the title’s release and keep all of the profit, thereby cutting directly into the critical initial sales which would otherwise go to publishers and developers. It has been suggested by industry insiders that this directly results in increases to the retail cost of new games.[26]”
    –http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GameStop#Used_games_market

    Right now a lot of milage is being had by an interview(PR stunt?) with GameStop CEO Paul Raines. In the interview Paul attempts to tackle critics head on. Headlines are reading that 70% of used game profits are spent on new games.

    Geez that sounds nice. Look OG, all they are doing is building new games sales. Well, no.

    First off I don’t trust that guys numbers at all. Go talk to your local Gamestop managers. I do, often. Secondly think about what he actualy said. 70% of people trading in games, buy new games. That mean that GS takes your old games and throughs them away, happy to sell you a new copy of a different game?

    http://www.ign.com/articles/2012/08/02/what-happens-to-your-used-games

    Of course not. It means that new games sell. But it also means that GS has a multi million dollor biz built around reselling your used games. What you do with your $17.38(for three games) is less important to GS then what they will do with the three games they took from you. Those games will go on the shelf and sell in place of new copies.

    “In dollar terms, that’s $250.2 million in profit, which is a lot more than the company made from the sale of new games, which “only” brought in $182.4 million.” And consider that the bulk of the games they are selling as used, facter into the sales numbers for the new games sold.

    http://kotaku.com/5694038/why-gamestop-wants-your-used-games-so-bad

    Used games make GS far more profit then new ones. Easy to understand why they would want to sell them so much.

    “We don’t make any money when someone rents it, and we don’t make any money when someone buys it used – way more than twice as many people played Gears than bought it.”
    —Epics Capps, on used games.

    I thought about not responding at all to this thread. I really REALLY can not believe that anyone could look at used game sales and think they could be a good thing for anyone other then the people making money off of them. Used game sales are bad. Period.

    It might be nice to take a few games your done with and get 1/3rd off of a new game(or new to you game). But everytime you trade a copy of a game in at GS, a vender just lost a sale on a copy of a game. And that means the publisher lost a sale. As did the dev. Studios close and people lose jobs.

    As the dev costs rise, it will be more important for companies to be able to gaurentee profit on each sold copy of a game. That is why we read talk of anti used game consoles next gen. It is why we have a digital push.

    And I understand that not all used copies sold directly equals lost new sales. After all, w/o used trade in said customer may not be able to purchase a game. But I would rather have that, then have smaller studios/pubs not be able to survive because there due payments are undermined by GS leeching sales away from them.

    I think the solution is pretty simple. Your not selling games. Your selling DVDs with a liscence to use a game contained within. So, everytime a retail establishment sells a game, they should pay a liscencing fee to whomever owns the rights to the game. In other words, if I buy Darksiders one used for 18usd at GS instead of 20usd, I think THQ should recieve 15% of the price I paid GS for the copy.

    I think that solves most of the trouble. What about person to person sales? Ebay? Valid questions, but I don’t think they are bulk of the problem.

    Like I said I almost skipped a response. And I know I could have done better here. But if people aren’t interested, why bother? Not like I am going to change your minds. Really it boils down to simple common sense. You either see it, or you don’t.

    But, if used games are so harmless … why do they cause so many industry folks to lose sleep at nite? Surly they wouldn’t care if what GS CEO Paul Raines was true…would they?

    #18 3 years ago
  19. viralshag

    @OG, I appreciate the response but it still doesn’t answer the question of how much money devs and publishers are really losing. You say you can’t trust what a GS CEO will say but then what evidence is there to make me believe the other side is telling the truth about how much they are losing. Should I believe them just because they are the guys making the game over the guys that are selling it to me?

    A lot about your post reinforces why GS have such a golden business with used games. It simply makes them more money. But just because one company can capitalise on re-selling games doesn’t automatically mean that the creator of said game is losing money. There are so many unknown factors to take into consideration such as whether or not that *new game* would have actually ever been purchased new.

    I’m not denying that retailers do shady business, I just don’t think that is what’s being questioned.

    And we see studios that make popular well sold games close, have staff cuts and the like. My only point that I’m trying to make is this seems to be an argument of one word against another, without any real proof or evidence to substantiate one or the others claims. If a full report with facts and figures can be produced I will happily accept whatever the outcome is.

    #19 3 years ago
  20. OlderGamer

    I don’t think we can have a solid debate on hard sales figures. Only GS has those kinds of numbers. And basicly they are going say “Trust us”.

    On the basic surface level, you can see that in one year GS sold 250ish Million in used games, same year 181ish million on new games. many in the idustry will see that as lost revenue. And really, it is. Not every single penny of course, but enough for companies that are strugling to ask a few questions and raise a few eyebrows.

    “But just because one company can capitalise on re-selling games doesn’t automatically mean that the creator of said game is losing money”

    And that is fundamnetaly where we would disagree. If a gamer walks into a store, and has a choice between new or used, there is a problem. If the gamer spends money on used GS gets paid. If the gamer spends money on new GS still gets paid, but so do the people that actualy made the game to begin with(the devs/the pubs). On some basic level, if you stop paying the people making the games, it stands to reason that less people will be around to make the games.

    It is what has led to countless sequels and me toos. I mean there is all kins of bad resulting from a massive used games bizz. the only winners are GS(or resellers) and to a lesser extent the customer(but w/o realizing it, he/she is creating a losing scenerio in the long run).

    What GS is basicly doing is biting the hand that feeds it(the game industry). It is no suprise to me that PC has grown, consoles have decreased, and industry insider after industry insider have spoken out against used game sales.

    I think if used game were removed from the market, a slight dip might be seen in new games sales. But I doubt it. What sales would be lost because of used trade ins would be gained by the shift in purchases from used to new games.

    Or like I said a certian % of used games sales(that closly mirrors the porfits from new game sales for Pubs). I think that would be workable. Maybe not.

    I guess it will be a mute point when everything is a digital service that we subscribe to.

    #20 3 years ago
  21. viralshag

    But that’s the point. If GS are the only people with the figures, then how can publishers and developers know what money they are losing out on? Just because they made 250 million doesn’t mean that’s on new-used games. That could be on games six months old or more. Let me put it this way:

    In order for a publisher to keep selling only new games they will have to either create over stock of the game – disc, packaging and then either shipping costs or storage costs for said stock.

    Or have your disc and packaging manufacturer available to create top up stock orders every time there may be a demand for your game. Which would most likely be small orders and cost ineffective after the main launch of the game.

    Both of these options run the publisher the risk of creating stock that potentially could never get sold. And unsold stock is lost money. And why would a consumer be willing to pay for a full price game months after release? So the option to counter that is to lower the RRP of that game, which makes the overheads look even more daunting as you have the same costs as a new game with a lot lower return for both publisher and retailer.

    It’s really like applying the digital strategy to the retail industry and it just wouldn’t work. But really, with the business models in place today, this is really the only way you an keep a market free of used games. When gaming goes fully digital, will no doubt be the end of retailers like GS.

    #21 3 years ago
  22. OlderGamer

    “But that’s the point. If GS are the only people with the figures, then how can publishers and developers know what money they are losing out on?”

    Well here we would have to use Epics Gears example, where they said that they saw over twice as many people playing the game then they sold copies. I have read several other companies say the same type of thing. A game will have 5 million users(non concerent) and yet the game only sells 1.75million copies new. We would have to pressume that most of the players were playing copies that they didn’t purchase.

    Now in all honestly, they could have rented the game. Or borrowed it from a friend. Almost all numbers can be manipulated. So alot of it should be, I think seen while looking for presenters slant.

    But the one time use codes, are a direct result of teh example I used with Epics situation. Because other companies have experienced the same type of thing. If you drink GS Kool-aid, there would be no need for one time use codes, play passes or other such incentives for buying new or not trading in. But sadly alot of companies feel very threatend of second hand sales.

    “In order for a publisher to keep selling only new games they will have to either create over stock of the game – disc, packaging and then either shipping costs or storage costs for said stock.”

    I think because of used game sales, you have been mislead. Into thinking that games only sell during this magical launch window:

    “Or have your disc and packaging manufacturer available to create top up stock orders every time there may be a demand for your game. Which would most likely be small orders and cost ineffective after the main launch of the game.”

    What I mean is that your assuming that games are only capable of selling during that short window. And the reason that this is true now days is because once your game gets into circulation, your sales will drop. This is due to new copies being replaced and sold instead of new ones. I know from talking to a friend of mine that GS stocks/orders far less copies of new games because they anticipate used game sales. Instead of buying a large suply of a game from a vender they buy a smaller number and resell it several times. One of the links I found said that 80% of trade ins are resold in the same store they were traded in at.

    I have seen GS taking preorders on used games that weren’t even launched yet. Used games, good for GS(or other such retailers), bad for everyone else. And at some basic level I feel GS and its used games policy is one of the things leading the push for digital distribution.

    #22 3 years ago
  23. viralshag

    There is still nothing to prove that publishers are essentially losing money which is they key to all this. Like I said before, it’s the retailers word against publishers and devs.

    At the end of the day I want to see facts. Not what we think is the situation. Pre-owned games have been a part of the industry for well over a decade. If it was truly as big a problem as you say it is, so much more would have been done to counter it. What have they come up with in all that time? The $10 project…

    If you think publishers have run the numbers through and said “hey guys, we’re really losing a ton of money here. We really need to sort that out!” and then just sat on it for all these years, I think that’s being a little naive. They run a business, they have analysts and accountants, they will not be sitting around just moping about “lost sales” to used games.

    If there was truly a way for these companies to increase their profit from countering used game sales, you really think EA and Activision wouldn’t have been more active about it other than their $10 project which I’m assuming has resulted in no great win as we don’t hear about it.

    #23 3 years ago

Comments are now closed on this article.

  • Half-life episode from Junction Point would have featured a magnet gun

    Half-life seems to be on near permanent hold, but at least we can glean some insight into what might once have been. Junction Point’s cancelled Half-life game came up in Warren Spector’s Reddit AMA overnight. Commenting that he isn’t sure whether he’ll get into legal trouble for discussing the project, Spector gave a few comments […]

  • Destiny: exclusive shader, emblem on offer with Nepal benefit shirt

    Destiny developer Bungie has asked Guardians to offer their aid, and they’ve already responded in troves. A new Destiny shirt added to the Bungie Store is the object of a fundraising drive to provide aid in Nepal following a devastating earthquake this week. Bungie popped the pretty stylish shirt on sale earlier today, offering an […]

  • What does the creator of Deus Ex think of Human Revolution and Mankind Divided?

    Deus Ex creator Warren Spector seems pretty positive about the direction the sci-fi series has followed under Square Enix’s hand. Deus Ex was created by Spector and his team at Ion Storm, and remained with Eidos after the developer shuttered. When Square Enix purchased the British publisher, it put new studio Eidos Montreal to work […]

  • Protest Goat secures future for Elite Dangerous destruction derbies

    One of the stranger and more beautiful stories to manifest in the gaming world this week, I think. Elite: Dangerous has given birth to an unintended, emergent style of gameplay; a destruction derby like affair where players gather in no combat areas to both race and gleefully smash into each other until a victor limps […]

  • Destiny’s stunning landscapes captured in panoramas

    Destiny has some beautiful environments, which screenshots don’t necessarily do justice to. Walking around Destiny exclaiming over the lighting effects and the tiny animated details is the best way to experience Bungie’s tremendous achievements, but these panorama images stitched together from in-game screenshots are a good second. Click to see them fullsize. Redditor CenturyEagle made […]

  • Star Wars Disney Infinity re-release on the cards – rumour

    Star Wars is a no-brainer for Disney Infinity, and at long last it looks like it’s happening. A Star Wars re-release called Disney Infinity 3.0 has reportedly leaked from German retailers. We have to lable this one a rumour as we haven’t seen the original source, but the story was originally reported by DisKingdom, which […]

  • Award-winning mobile indie Monument Valley out now on Windows Phone

    Windows Phone’s game selection can be a bit restrictive, but has expanded delightfully today: Monument Valley is now available. Monument Valley is one of those gorgeous, mind-bending puzzlers the indie scene produces on the regular, winning awards and consuming everyone’s lives for weeks on end. Developed by Ustwo Games, with beautiful, understated art from Ken […]

  • Old-school EverQuest servers safe from legal troubles thanks to Daybreak agreement

    EverQuest rights holder Daybreak Game Company given its blessing to the wonderful Project 1999. EverQuest: Project 1999 is one of those lovely ideas that it are all too often crushed by the realities of the games industry. An entirely fan-managed affair, it provides an emulated version of the classic EverQuest experience, which is no longer […]

  • Free Dragon Age short stories fill us in on Corypheus’s followers

    Dragon Age: Inquisition developer BioWare invites you to learn more about the lore and characters that make up its beautiful role-playing setting. Dragon Age is set in Thedas, a world still only partially revealed by the three core games to date. BioWare puts a heck of a lot of work into its worldbuilding, employing a […]

  • Remember that gorgeous Luminous Engine tech demo? It now utilizes DirectX 12

    Remember the gorgeous Luminous Engine tech demo Square Enix showed off three years ago? The firm showed it again at Microsoft’s Build Conference, this time utilizing DirectX 12. The Witch Chapter 0 [cry] real-time tech demo was created from research Square conducted using real-time CG technology and DX12 in collaboration with Microsoft and Nvidia. The […]

  • Stealth Inc 2: A Game of Clones sneaks onto GOG and Steam services

    Stealth Inc 2: A Game of Clones can now be purchased through GOG and Steam. On both services it will run you £12.99/€14.99/$14.99. Links here and here. The game features: Fully explorable ‘Metroidvania’ style overworld, laying siege to a diabolical cloning facility with varied and detailed environments. A variety of special equipment to unlock new […]

  • Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare DLC Ascendance has arrived on PC, PlayStation consoles

    Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare players on PC and PlayStation consoles can now download the Ascendance DLC. The second content pack contains the OHM weapon, the OHM Werewolf custom variant, and the second entry in the Exo Zombies saga, Infection. Four new maps are also included: Perplex, Site 244, Climate, and Chop Shop. Ascendance was […]

  • Latest Xbox 360 system update is live, now supports 2TB hard drives

    Xbox 360 now supports 2TB hard drives via the latest system update for the console. Support for the drives was announced earlier this month and has been available for preview members. “In addition we will also no longer reserve space in advance on your hard drive,” said the firm. “If you are using 16GB of […]

  • Kickstarter for Banjo-Kazooie spiritual successor Yooka-Laylee launches tomorrow

    Playtonic Games has announced the Kickstarter campaign for its spiritual successor to the Banjo Kazooie series, Yooka-Laylee, will launch tomorrow. The title of the game was announced today along with the Kickstarter date. Formerly known as Project Ukulele, the 3D platformer is said to be “between the size of Banjo-Kazooie and Banjo-Tooie,” and stars Yooka […]

  • Console version of Mistwalker’s Terra Battle is in development

    Now that Mistwalker’s Terra Battle has surpassed 2 million downloads on mobile, the developer is now working on a console version of the tactical RPG. As part of the original Download Starter campaign, the 2 million milestone means the company will begin development on Terra Battle’s console version with details to be announced at a […]

  • Prison break game The Escapists is heading to PlayStation 4 from May 29

    The Escapists, Mouldy Toof’s prison break game originally released as a timed console exclusive Xbox One, has a release date for PlayStation 4. For those unfamiliar with the title, which is also a PC release, it tasks players’ time management skills as they do a bit of digging and crafting, and other prison-type stuff as […]

  • Dead Island 2 delayed into 2016 to ensure series is “taken to the next level”

    Dead Island 2 has been delayed into 2016 by Yager in order to ensure the sequel “takes Dead Island to the next level.” According to a tweet from the developer, it set “big goal” for the game, and in order to deliver what fans expect, the team needs more time to reach development goals. “We […]

  • Project Cars: here’s a list of all available cars at launch

    Project Cars will contain many, many cars and if we are counting correctly, there will be 74 total at launch. The standard edition contains 65 total, and when factoring the free car as well as the Modified and Limited Edition cars packs, you can add an additional nine cars to the mix. Comb through the […]

  • Competitive matchmaking support is coming to Team Fortress 2

    Team Fortress 2 will soon feature support for competitive matchmaking, which Valve says is a “high priority” project for it at the moment. According to a report from TeamFortress.tv, which visited Valve headquarters recently, Valve is looking into the possibility of 6v6 or 9v9 matches 9v9, a possible quick play option and it is also […]

  • GTA 5 PC patch fixes garage, Job crashes – full notes here

    Rockstar has pushed out a 353 MB patch for GTA 5 on PC The patch fixes a number of annoying bugs related to vehicles and garages, some deathmatch issues and purchase errors. It should also fix various freezing and crashing bugs, as well as a little issue with Steam. Time will tell if the patch […]

  • Fire Emblem If will come in White Kingdom and Black Kingdom versions with amiibo support

    We’ve finally got some juicy details on the next Fire Emblem game, but the most interesting aspect is that there will be two versions of the game. According to Siliconera, who translated an interview between Intelligent Systems and 4Gamer, there will a White Kingdom and a Black Kingdom version that offer different aspects of the […]

  • Deception 4: The Nightmare Princess heads west with “Golden Toilet” pre-order bonus

    Deception 4: The Nightmare Princess will debut on western PlayStation 4 systems this summer, Koei Tecmo has announced. It is also coming to PS3 and Vita. The game was produced by Keisuke Kikuchi of Fatal Frame fame and takes up where Deception 4: Blood Ties left off allowing players to relive Laegrinna’s pursuit to free […]

  • Nintendo US eShop update: Puzzle & Dragons Super Mario demo, Paper Mario, more

    Nintendo has updated the North American end of the eShop with a demo of Puzzle & Dragons Super Mario Bros. Edition, Paper Mario on Virtual Console, and amiibo Tap. The full update is below. eShop update amiibo Tap – free – Wii U Star Wars Pinball DLC – Wii U Paper Mario – Wii U […]

  • Deus Ex: Mankind Divided PC port handed off to Nixxes

    The PC port of the new Deus Ex has been handed over to Netherlands based studio, Nixxes software. After the initial reveal trailer at the beginning of April, we’ve only had a few morsels in the way of additional news. The most intriguing tidbit to date has got to be the fact that you’ll be […]

  • First-ever PC Gaming Show to take place at E3 2015 in June

    PC gaming will finally have its very own E3 press conference this year, thanks to PC Gamer and AMD. The PC Gaming Show will take place on June 16 at the Belasco Theater in Los Angeles and it will be livestreamed on Twitch. PC Gamer said speakers at the presentation will include representatives from Blizzard, […]

  • Majora’s Mask light available now on Club Nintendo for 6000 stars

    Club Nintendo shuts up shop on September 30 and members are being encouraged to spend accumulated stars before then. And what better to spend them on, than this adorable Majora’s Mask light? If you’re a member based in Europe you can nab it for 6000 stars. If you’re in Australia or New Zealand, it’ll only […]

  • Unity support announced for HoloLens, will work with Windows universal apps

    Microsoft is partnering with game engine developers Unity in order to make HoloLens compatible with apps and games which use the cross-platform engine. The partnership was announced yesterday during its Build Developer Conference. Universal apps for Windows 10 systems will also be available on Xbox One later this year, suggesting possible HoloLens functionality with the […]

  • Splatoon Nintendo Direct airs Thursday, May 7

    A Nintendo Direct focused on Splatoon, the Wii U multiplayer title, on May 7. It will kick off at 7am PDT/10am EDT/3pm UK and it can be watched via the Nintendo Direct website. You can also have a look at the game through Nintendo’s Twitch channel. The last game-specific presentation took place last week and […]

  • GTA 5 PC: clean up the streets as a member of the San Andreas PD with this new mod

    Remember the awesome mods for GTA 4 and San Andreas that let you run amok online as a member of the po-po? Well, dust off your taser and load up your gun, because it’s coming to GTA 5. The new mod for GTA 5 is currently in alpha and can be downloaded at palmbeachgames.com. You […]

  • Indie shoot ‘em up Project Root comes to Xbox One, PS4 and PSVita

    Project Root is a self-proclaimed rejig of the shoot ‘em up genre that was released on PC last year, and it’s finally coming to consoles. Combining free-roaming elements with the usual business of shooting things, Project Root was released this week for Xbox One, PS4 and the PSVita.

  • You can now bet on eSports online, starting with League of Legends

    If you’re getting bored with sticking a pony on the races, you can expand your gambling horizons at Unikrn where you can watch esports streams and get a little action on the side. The new platform was set up by Rahul Sood – previously the general manager of Microsoft Ventures. At the moment, customers are […]

  • Has Watch Dogs 2 been leaked?

    Ubisoft employee, Julien Risse, may have inadvertently confirmed Watch Dogs 2, thanks to his online CV over at LinkedIn. Videogamer.com spotted the slip up, in which Risse lists Watch Dogs, the DLC Bad Blood, and Watch Dogs 2 on his profile. Creative Director Jonathan Morin has already talked about his ideas for improvements for the […]

  • GTA 5′s Trevor makes his Jackass debut, complete with leopard-print knickers

    YouTuber Abstract Mode has shared his vision of what Trevor Philips’ life might have been like, had he not been completely batshit crazy. Watch Trevor get mauled, run over, and hit by a train, before taking a majestic swan-dive into someone else’s pool at the climax. Thanks, Kotaku.

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 season pass will cost you £35

    Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 isn’t released until November 6, but you can already hand over your cash for the Season Pass. The Season Pass is available for pre-purchase on Steam for £34.99, and will cover four DLC packs – although the details we have on the content are limited to ‘exciting’ at this […]

  • GTA Online’s cheating assholes are no match for this player’s vengeance

    Think you’re smart for using invisibility and infinite ammo glitches? You need to be taught a lesson, sucker. You can have all the hacks you want but if your GTA Online game is weak, you’ll still get your ass handed to you. As this fool discovered when attempting to hassle another player. There’s a fair […]

  • PS4 sales help Sony’s games division swing to profit

    Sony’s PlayStation business has made an operating profit of 48.1 billion yen ($404m / £261.5m) in the past 12 months. That’s thanks to stellar sales of the PlayStation 4 and PS Plus, even as sales of the PS3 have stalled and the company wrote off costs for the PSTV and PS Vita. The profit puts […]

  • New patch for Dirt Rally gives co-driver’s attitude a tune-up

    Dirt Rally gets a new patch three days after release on Steam. On Monday, we reported that the newest Dirt game has popped up on Steam’s Early Access and is available to pick up for £24.99, as well as giving you an eyeful of tasty screenshots. The patch – released yesterday – fixes some issues […]

  • New The Witcher 3 screenshots show combat, exploration and general carousing

    New screenshots released on the official facebook page for The Witcher 3 show Geralt annihilating a winged beast, out and about in the world exploring, and living the life of Reily amidst a bustling feast. We were already treated to some glorious screenshots a few days ago, but these new ones are in-game and give […]

  • Destiny: 14 things you might have missed during House of Wolves intel drops

    Destiny: House of Wolves does a great deal more than just slap some new content on the existing game structure. House of Wolves changes Destiny in a lot of interesting and very welcome ways. Bungie showed off many of these changes in its livestream, and let both me and Arekkz come and have a look […]

  • Scratch that cyberpunk itch with Technobabylon on May 21 – new trailer

    Technobabylon more like Wrecked-yo-babbling with my smooth flow about how good Wadjet Eye games are. I don’t know y’all, it’s clock off time and everything feels like a reach. Wadjet Eye makes pretty good adventure games – award winning, in fact. The latest project to spring forth from the benevolent, sheltering hand of the label […]

  • Skullgirls 2nd Encore brings exclusive new features to PS4, Vita in northern summer

    Skullgirls, the little indie fighter that could, is getting another crack at it. Skullgirls 2nd Encore is the second re-release of the one-time troubled 2D versus fighter from lab Zero Games. Having survived the shut down of its developer and collapse of its publishing contrast, Skullgirls re-emerged as Skullgirls: Encore, adding in a ton of […]

  • Danganronpa series generates “impressive” sales for Vita exclusive

    Danganronpa is selling quite nicely, thank you, says NIS America. Danganronpa is a series of murder mystery visual novel puzzlers in a similar vein to games like 999. Two of these have been released for Vita in the west – Trigger Happy Havoc and Goodbye Despair. Speaking to MCV, NIS America CEO and president Takuro […]

  • I have no idea what is going on in J-Stars Victory VS+ but I kind of like it

    In this J-Stars Victory VS+ trailer, we see – uhh. Well. We certainly see some things. Look y’all, I was a massive weaboo in high school, but that was back in the dark ages when we had to take out Manga Entertainment VHS tapes from dingy little specialist rental joints that were literally underground, and […]

  • Please just watch this terrific trailer for Toren

    Toren is the kind of game I dream about when I drift off to sleep at night. This indie puzzle adventure strikes a spark in my little soul in the same way as Ico and Tequila Works’ Rime do. Mysterious, almost ethereal fantasy setting – check. Chance to actually walk around in that setting – […]

  • Play classic MS-DOS games on your own tweets

    In today’s episode of “what will they think of next”, someone’s figured out how to post playable versions of classic games in tweets. For some time now, Twitter has allowed you to embed various forms of media in tweets, most noticeably YouTube videos, simply by pasting a URL into the compose field. Turns out this […]

  • VR: Unreal Engine to add HTC Vive support

    The biggest digital PC game distributor and the most popular game development engine have both backed VR. It’s going to happen. An upcoming Unreal Engine 4 update will expand the development suite’s support to the HTC Vive, Valve’s VR headset. In this glorious new future where work on one of the most important engines in […]

  • WWE 2K15 PC supports modding

    WWE 2K15 may be the series’ PC debut, but it’s already getting into the spirit of the platform. WWE 2K15 does indeed support mods on PC, 2K’s Marcus Stephenson has confirmed. @ElementGamesTV you can. Now buy. — Marcus Stephenson (@stephensonmc) April 28, 2015 As Destructoid points out, this opens the door to all sorts of […]

  • Overkill’s The Walking Dead coming to PC, PS4 and Xbox One in 2016

    Overkill’s The Walking Dead is one step closer to your grasping little paws. Overkill’s The Walking Dead will be published by 505 Games, Overkill parent Starbreeze has announced. 505 also published Payday 2, Overkill’s previous title, so the two companies have established a working relationship. In a press release, the publisher said the co-op title […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 pre-orders net Advanced Warfare DLC

    Buy Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 for later, enjoy bonus Advanced Warfare content now. Blacks Ops 3 is being supported by a rather cunning pre-order incentive even more likely to get you to lay your cash down sooner than you might otherwise. Gamespot reports a Black Ops 3 pre-order will receive a couple of […]

  • Steam Game Ban system lets developers determine who to block

    Steam users can now be blocked from individual games by their developers. Steam has always supported multiplayer bans for disruptive users, but a newly-implemented system allows developers to ban users from individual games using their own anti-cheat systems. Game Bans are enforced by Valve, but are enacted at the developer’s request and discretion. This change […]

  • Far Cry 4 devs matching Red Cross donations up to $100K to aid Nepal earthquake victims

    Far Cry 4 developer Ubisoft Montreal will match any pledges made to The Red Cross up to $100,000 to aid Nepal after the 7.8 earthquake struck the area in and around Kathmandu in Nepal. According to Ubisoft: “Having spent the last few years working on Far Cry 4, a game heavily inspired by Nepal and […]

  • Tales of Zestiria retail listing notes September release date, PS4 version

    Tales of Zestiria is coming west in northern autumn, and while it’s confirmed as a PlayStation 3 release, a Dutch retailer has it listed as coming to PS4 as well. Of course, listing it for PS4 could also be a typo, not that I would personally know about that sort of thing, really. However, according […]

  • Official mod tools for Total War: Attila are now available

    Official mod tools for Total War: Attila are now available and you can grab the new Assembly Kit as a beta through the tools menu via your Steam library. The Creative Assembly said the tools will be “immediately familiar” to modders of Rome 2 and Shogun 2, but the new version is the most “extensive” […]

  • How to get level 34 Ascended Raid gear in Destiny: House of Wolves

    Watch: two videos showing you how to get level 34 raid gear and a shopping list of what you need. One of the big changes that House of Wolves is bringing to Destiny is the chance to upgrade your weapons and gear to level 34. In these videos Arekkz Gaming shows you how to use […]

  • Destiny: House of Wolves puts PvP back in the spotlight

    Destiny PvP players, your time has come to shine. New Crucible maps. New Crucible rewards. And the glorious wonder of Elimination mode. Destiny: House of Wolves puts PvP front and centre. When Destiny was first detailed, one of the things Bungie stressed was that there’d be something for everyone. If you wanted to play solo […]

  • Destiny: Trials of Osiris – everything you need to know in one video

    The Destiny: House of Wolves embargo has lifted, and with so much information floating around pertaining to Trials of Osiris, it can be overwhelming. Thankfully, Arekkz Gaming tells you everything you need to know in one video. In the video above you will be informed of how the 3v3 Team Deathmatch event works, how you […]

  • Destiny: House of Wolves – watch a Trials of Osiris match from start to finish

    With the release of Destiny: House of Wolves looming, players will soon be able to participate in the new 3v3 Team Deathmatch event in The Crucible, Trials of Osiris. Below is a video featuring an uncut, complete match from start to finish. In the video, Arekkz Gaming gives you a breakdown of the mode and […]

  • Wolfenstein: The Old Blood – here’s what your PC needs in order to run it

    Wolfenstein: The Old Blood is out next week, and Bethesda has today released the PC specs for the standalone title. MachineGames has made some tweaks to the system requirements and have included both minimum and recommended specifications. Minimum OS: 64-bit Windows 7/Windows 8 Processor: Intel Core i5-2500 @ 3.3 GHz / AMD FX-8320 @ 3.5 […]

  • Destiny: Trials of Osiris – watch the livestream reveal right here

    Bungie will be showing off Destiny’s new 3v3 Team Deatmatch Trials of Osiris today, and you can watch the Twitch stream right here if you like. It kicks off at 11am PDT/2pm EDT and will feature community manager Deej and design leads Lars Bakken and Derek Carroll. More will be revealed on House of Wolves […]

  • May Xbox Games with Gold: Mafia 2, CastleStorm: Definitive Edition, F1 2013

    Microsoft has announced the free games Gold members will be able to pick up through Xbox Live. On Xbox One, Gold users can download CastleStorm: Definitive Edition for the month,and Pool Nation FX is being offered for an additional month. Starting May 1, Xbox 360 Gold members can download Mafia 2 through May 15, and […]