SCOTUS rules against violent California games law

By Staff, Monday, 27 June 2011 15:35 GMT

The Supreme Court of the United States has sided with the videogames industry, declaring it the winner in the EMA (Entertainment Merchants Association) vs Brown case that has gone on for six years.

The vote in the case, which argued over the constitutional rights of a law which would have have governed the sale of videogames to minors, came in at a 7-2 ruling against California.

It was written by California senator Leland Yee and was passed into law by then-California governor Arnold Schwarzenegger back in 2005. Schwarzenegger’s name was removed from the case name after Jerry Brown took over as governor.

The games industry, obviously, was vehemently opposed to the bill.

Justice Antonin Scalia said that the bill “does not comport with the 1st Amendment.”

Videogame stocks showed a mixed reaction to the result.

There’s more on the victory at GamePolitics and at the links below.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.




  • Report - US boxed game sales dropping sharply

    A new study claims 2010 brought a major dip in physical sales of video games within the US.

  • EMA report: Gaming is a life-long hobby

    Gaming isn’t just some one-and-done deal, according to a report by the Entertainment Merchants Association. It’s a life-long commitment. “Consumer turnover in the video game market is exceedingly low. Older gamers continue to be engaged by video games, rather than dropping out and being replaced by a new generation. Once a consumer decides to play […]

Entertainment Merchants Association

  • Retailers could save $6 billion annually with new disc-based security device

    Entertainment retailers are expected to start using a new radio-activated lock on games, DVDs and other disc-based merchandise by Q4 2010 to help curb the three-figured discount some patrons give themselves. The device is expected to save the retail industry $6 billion annually, according to a report from the Entertainment Merchants Association titled “Project Lazarus: […]

  • PS3 "driving force" behind Blu-ray sales

    According to this TG Daily piece, Blu-ray’s fortunes are being propped up heavily by PS3, as if that were in any doubt. From the piece: The Entertainment Merchants Association (EMA) released its 2008 annual report with a wealth of data revealing the most trends in TV, home video and video gaming segments. The flood of […]