Fri, Jan 07, 2011 | 01:34 GMT
Report: Kinect accused of causing RROD in older Xbox 360 models

The BBC is reporting that numerous Xbox 360 users are having issues with their consoles when connecting their brand-new Kinect devices to the system.
Apparently, it is causing some consoles to flash the dreaded RROD.
“It’s very disappointing,” said one ten year old’s father, whose 360 died shortly after using Kinect. “We were planning to have a big New Year’s Day party with karaoke microphones and a Take That competition.
“But now the Xbox is just sitting idle.”
That’s what they get for planning a Take That-themed evening, we reckon.
Over on the official Xbox.com forums, a four-page thread has emerged on the matter, and it is though the RROD problem only occurs with doriginal Xbox 360 units using Kinect and not the newer, slimmer model.
Microsoft, however, doesn’t believe it is an issue with Kinect, just older hardware models failing. Kinect, according to a MS spokesperson, was “designed to work with every Xbox 360 sold to date.”
“There is no correlation between the three flashing red lights error and Kinect,” the spokesperson told the BBC. “Any new instances of the three flashing red lights error are merely coincidental.”
Thanks, Eurogamer.


31 comments
#1
Dralen
05/01/11, 6:59 pm
So either way, it’s still a fail.
#2
theevilaires
05/01/11, 7:02 pm
….and the LEGACY continues
#3
Erthazus
05/01/11, 7:02 pm
Speechless…
Great device.
#4
OlderGamer
05/01/11, 7:06 pm
I know quality when I smell it … oh wait, no, thats just my xbox360.
The RRoD is one of those things that I will not forgive MS for. it will go down in the books and be remember long after I am gone.
#5
Quiiick
05/01/11, 7:13 pm
… will this ever end?
#6
reask
05/01/11, 7:15 pm
Thank F**k I didn’t get Kinnect.
This could be costly for them methinks.
#7
anuekr
05/01/11, 7:24 pm
Got only one word to say about that:
Trololololololololol
#8
Dr.Ghettoblaster
05/01/11, 7:27 pm
Wow. Only the future stats will prove whether there is a corelation or this is in fact “coincidence”.
#9
f1r3storm
05/01/11, 7:28 pm
“We were planning to have a big New Year’s Day party with karaoke microphones and a Take That competition.”
I call that self protection by the console.
#10
theevilaires
05/01/11, 7:35 pm
I just want to know one thing….Is M$ still suing that guy who came out and told the truth about the 360 production flaws and M$ knew it right from the beginning but chose to still release the hardware?
(Thats a serious question btw)
#11
ashers2ashers
05/01/11, 7:39 pm
I don’t know much about the DLC in lips (or any music games other than Rock Band for that matter), but I’m pretty certain that there is a Take That edition of Singstar, which is a Playstation exclusive IP? So if they were planning on playing that on their 360 then I think I’d've prefered the story “Family blames Sony for causing 360′s RRoD when playing Take That: Singstar”
#12
OrbitMonkey
05/01/11, 7:41 pm
@9 +1
When I started reading this I wondered if this was just another BBC. hatchet job, like they did on the ps3 ylod, guess not. Gutted, was hoping to pick up a cheap older console & Kinnect for the kids.
Suppose I’ll hafta fork out the extra cash
#13
Dr.Ghettoblaster
05/01/11, 7:46 pm
LOL @ #9!
#14
Michael O’Connor
05/01/11, 7:59 pm
In other news, my uncle’s brother’s granddaughter’s best friend’s cousin said that jumping up and down on the floor while playing Kinect causes scratched discs!
More at 11!
Christ, I remember when the BBC was a credible news source. In the last year, they’ve just become the same kind of bullshit propaganda cesspit as the rest of the internet.
#15
theevilaires
05/01/11, 8:13 pm
^ want some cheese with your whine
#16
Seraphemz
05/01/11, 8:21 pm
Not even the box wants to play kinect games…
#17
theevilaires
05/01/11, 8:25 pm
…..hmmm no Hunam, no psychotext, no Mike in these comments yet huh….someone check eurogamer they must be doing damage control over there
#18
Psychotext
05/01/11, 8:31 pm
Saw my name… what exactly do you want me to say? 360s get RRoD? D’uh.
You’ll see the same story with 360s dying every time a big new release comes out too. I don’t think anyone is surprised that actually using older 360s tends to kill them… and just about all that can be said on that billion dollar fuckup has been said.
Nice to see you’re still obsessed with me though.
#19
Michael O’Connor
05/01/11, 8:32 pm
@15 Sure. Want some shit with your bull?
#20
Hunam
05/01/11, 8:49 pm
I resent the fact that you think I’m a 360 fan boy. I mean I only used to work for Micro…. erm. Nothing to see here.
#21
albo88
05/01/11, 8:56 pm
lol they thing they will influence sells with this propaganda
ah media is evil can be used for everything
#22
lexph3re
05/01/11, 9:03 pm
@hunam +10 lol
#23
Mike Honcho
05/01/11, 10:10 pm
RROD rears it’s ugly head again …. M$ should just do a trade-in program, old box for the slim box.
No one deserves the RROD …. even Take That fanboys.
#24
earlyrock
06/01/11, 12:28 am
Oh Snap!
#25
LOLshock94
06/01/11, 12:46 am
the xbox obviesly made it self have the RROD due to the fact they were gonna have a take that party
#26
Khanivor
06/01/11, 1:27 am
112 posts in a forum thread in seven weeks and this is news? WTF?
#27
mojo
06/01/11, 7:30 am
this is shocking news.
a take that party? Seriously?
/passes away
#28
NeoSquall
06/01/11, 11:24 am
So is M$ trying to coerce gamers to buy newer consoles with less features?
… no wait, wrong console.
#29
Robo_1
06/01/11, 12:17 pm
I’ve a hard time believing that a usb add on can cause the solder between the gpu and motherboard to suddenly melt. If anything, Kinect could be pushing 360 pretty hard, and that is causing an overheat.
#30
Gadzooks!
06/01/11, 12:56 pm
It’s the same old story any time there is a spike in console use. More use = more chance of failure.
I can’t remember the titles off the top of my head, but several big hitters on the 360 have been accused of RRODing consoles. They didnt, obviously, but sensationalism and obvious facts just dont get along.
I suspect a study could be made to find exactly the same spike in YLOD’s over the Christmas period.
#31
theevilaires
07/01/11, 1:25 am
^ still in denial….what a shame.