Sections

SCEA: Arc will have the goods to make Natal “PR barrage” go away

Tuesday, 23 February 2010 14:39 GMT By Johnny Cullen

Arc 2

SCEA SVP of PR Rob Dyer has said the way Microsoft is currently promoting Project Natal is all in your face.

The exec described the MS push as a “whole PR barrage”.

“From Sony’s perspective, rather than go out and do a whole PR barrage to give everybody the ‘happy, happy, joy, joy’ news,” said Dyer, “we’re going to show up and have a line-up of products to show people rather than having a lot of great statements to say, ‘This is what’s going to happen.’

Dyer then went onto say that beginning soon, you’ll see why PlayStation Arc, PS3′s own motion controller, will bring everything to the table.

“So whether it’s at GDC or DPS (Destination PlayStation), and definitely at E3, you’re going to see – and I’ve seen it from both first- and third-parties – some really awesome products to support this. And rather than us go there and pat ourselves on the back, and send out press releases talking about this, we’re going to be Missouri; it’s going to be ‘show me.’ And that’s the deal.”

He also said that so far, there’s no “trouble” in gaining third-party support for Arc.

“From a third-party perspective it’s easier to develop for, you can use the same code base that you currently use for PS3 or 360 or even the Wii in order to get a motion controller game out. You can’t do that with Natal.

“You have to have a completely separate code base and my feeling is that we’re going to have a lot more games, a lot more innovation – particularly with the camera and the precision – versus what you’ll have with Natal or the Wii.We can all sit around here and debate that… but the fact is I’m not having any trouble getting third-party support.”

Currently, Arc is a codename for the PS3 motion controller. It’s due out in fall.

Thanks, IG.

Latest

  • Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel gets Lady Hammerlock DLC tomorrow

    The Lady Hammerlock DLC for Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel will be released on PS3 and Xbox 360 tomorrow, January 27. The new playable character comes with three skill trees and the action skill Cold As Ice. If you haven’t bought the season pass for Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel you can download the DLC for $9.99, you lucky […]

  • A limited edition 20th Anniversary PS4 just sold for $128,000

    Sony has just auctioned one of its limited edition 20th Anniversary PS4 consoles for over $128,000. The model had the serial number 00001, according to the Wall Street Journal. “We appreciate all who participated in the auction and are surprised at the highest bid price, which was higher than our expectations,” said a rep for […]

  • Here’s Killer Instinct’s new Omen and Golem fighters in action

    Microsoft has revealed Killer Instinct Season 2′s fighter Omen in a new trailer. Stick around for the end of the video and you’ll also get a peek at another new fighter, Golem. Omen is a bonus character and as such isn’t available as part of the main season roster. He’s available for free to Ultra […]

  • Digital copies of Far Cry 4 are being deleted from Uplay

    Ubisoft appears to be deleting copies of Far Cry 4 bought through digital third-party retailers. According to the Ubisoft support forums, copies of the game acquired via G2Play and G2A are being removed from Uplay. Users had not been given any warning by publisher Ubisoft that the game will be removed, although it is now […]

  • Gearbox wants “badass” talent for the next Borderlands

    Borderlands 3 may not have been announced at PAX this weekend, but studio boss Randy Pitchford is currently recruiting for the next game in the series. We are recruiting for next Borderlands. This is the big one. Industry badass? E-mail me: heyrandy@gearboxsoftware.com pic.twitter.com/ZG9dLytX1B — Randy Pitchford (@DuvalMagic) January 26, 2015 A recruitment push would suggest […]

  • Destiny: less grind, fairer economy in House of Wolves DLC

    Destiny developer Bungie has said it aims to lessen the grind in House of Wolves, and it won’t repeat mistakes it made with rewards in The Dark Below. Gear rewards will be fairer, according to lead designer Luke Smith in a Neogaf thread. For example, buying from a vendor should not invalidate gear rewarded for […]

  • Halo: The Master Chief Disaster

    Over two months since release and Xbox One’s big Christmas game is still a turkey, says Rich Stanton. “The game has now been available for two-and-a-half months, including the blockbuster Christmas season, and by any reasonable standard it doesn’t work.” Halo: The Master Chief Collection launched worldwide on November 11, 2014. Intended as something of […]

  • Homeworld Remastered Collection dated, first gameplay footage released

    Homeworld Remastered Collection has a release date, and as promised, the gameplay footage of Gearbox Software’s remake has been released along with the news that Homeworld Shipbreaker development continues. The video was shown during the Inside Gearbox Software panel earlier this morning at PAX South. Last year, Gearbox had said hoped to release the title […]

  • Clock Tower spiritual successor Night Cry has landed on Kickstarter

    The Kickstarter for Clock Tower spiritual successor, Project Scissors, recently announced as Night Cry, has launched. A teaser directed by The Grudge director Takashi Shimizu was released for the game earlier this month, and the full short film can be viewed below. Shimizu is also creative director on the project and Silent Hill creative and environment […]

  • Toukiden Kiwami mission trailer released, pre-order bonuses detailed

    Pre-order bonuses for Toukiden Kiwami have been announced for PlayStation 4 and Vita. Here’s the pre-order bonus list for each participating retailer: North America GameStop – Armor inspired by new slayers Reki and Soma’s costumes and classic armor from Toukiden‘s six original NPC slayers. Amazon – 2 exclusive pieces of armor: a set of Tenko […]

  • More Final Fantasy Type-0 HD, Final Fantasy 15 info doled out by Tabata

    Final Fantasy Type-0 HD director Hajime Tabata took part in a Reddit AMA yesterday, and answered a variety of questions pertaining to the game and Final Fantasy 15. According to Tabata, the first playthrough of the game will last around 40 hours, but “the real fun” starts from the second playthrough which contains new events. […]

  • This video gives you an idea of what Borderlands Online is like

    A video for Borderlands Online, the China-exclusive title from 2K, Shanda Games and Gearbox, has been released. Posted on MMO Culture, the video was released to announce the “technical test” which started today. Borderlands Online is an instance-based online shooter, and will probably never reach western shores. Still, you can have a look anyway.

  • Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns is the MMO’s first expansion

    The first expansion for Guild Wars 2, Heart of Thorns, was announced today during PAX South, and ArenNet has posted a few content details for it on the official webiste. Heart of Thorns contains a reimagined progression with the new Mastery system, which provides new training opportunities for characters beyond level 80. Players will be […]

  • Turn-based action platformer Ronin has been polished up, nets a publisher

    Tomasz Waclawek has polished up his freeware title Ronin and will be releasing it through publisher Devolver Digital later this year. The turn-based action platformer stars a vengeful ninja who is determined to kill important memebers of a powerful corporation. Weapons at your disposal include razor wire and a katana, or you avoid combat by […]

  • Footage of cancelled Justice League brawler surfaces

    Footage of the cancelled Double Helix-developed Justice League brawler has surfaced online. The game was supposed to be a tie-in title for the also cancelled Justice League film directed by George Miller, according to leaked images and information from 2012. Jon Gwyn, the game’s artist and now Rockstar San Diego staffer, said at the time […]

  • Free Icona Vulcano DLC for DriveClub releases next week

    Sony has posted a video of the Icona Vulcano, which will be released as DLC next week for DriveClub. The video was posted on Facebook and we’ve embedded the video below courtesy of GamesHQMeida. It was announced earlier this week the Icona Vulcano would be released on the PS Store as a free download.

  • The Bard’s Tale 4 announced by inXile Entertainment at PAX South

    The Bard’s Tale 4 was announced today by inXile Entertainment CEO Brian Fargo during a panel at PAX South. inXile hinted around back in December that a sequel was in the works. Granted, The Bard’s Tale wasn’t mentioned. Still, everyone figured this was the game when Wasteland 2 project lead Chris Keenan stated the team […]

  • Here’s another Majora’s Mask 3DS vs N64 comparison video

    Last week, YouTube user Master0fHyrule uploaded a Majora’s Mask 3DS vs N64 comparison video, and we’ve embedded it for you below. The video shows 4.5 minutes of footage which appears before hitting the start button and the first meeting between Link and the Skull Kid. Another comparison video was released by another user back in […]

  • The Game Awards 2015 already in the planning stages

    The Game Awards 2015 are already in the planning stages, according to Geoff Keighley. The inaugural show took place on December 6, 2014. Keighley announced the 2015 show during his Storytime with Geoff Keighley panel at PAX South this weekend and through Twitter. He said more details will be announced in the spring. You can […]

  • Fahrenheit: Indigo Prophecy Remastered listed for January release

    It looks like Quantic Dream’s Indigo Prophecy is returning in remastered form next week, if an Amazon listing is any indication. According to the listing posted on NeoGAF, the uncut version of the game contains Steam DRM and will release January 29 at 12pm PST/3pm EST for a Linux, Mac and PC download. Titled Fahrenheit: […]

  • Indie Flash Sale kicks off on North American PS Store

    The North American end of the PlayStation Store is hosting a Flash Sale a beefy list of indie games and some films. The sales includes titles such as Resogun, Shadow Warrior, The Unfinished Swan, FEZ, Costume Quest 2, Joe Danger, Brothers: a Tale of Two Sons, and more for up to 80% off. The full […]

  • The Witcher 3 Twitch stream to show 15 minutes of new gameplay footage

    New The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt gameplay footage will be shown Monday, January 26 on GOG.com’s Twitch channel. Along with the footage, the developers will be answering questions from the community as well as providing commentary on the gameplay being shown. Live questions posted via Twitter chat will be answered by senior gameplay designer Damien […]

  • Borderlands 3 information teased for tomorrow’s Gearbox PAX South panel

    During PAX South this weekend, Gearbox Software is hosting a panel titled Inside Gearbox Software which will provide “the latest news and updates on Borderlands and upcoming Gearbox titles.” Yesterday during Gearbox’s panel called Question and Answer Time, CEO Rady Pitchford was asked “when or if” fans can expect Borderlands 3. “I’ll tell you what,” […]

  • Best Buy cancels multiple pre-order units of Limited Edition Majora’s Mask New 3DS XL

    Multiple sources reported overnight Best Buy has cancelled some pre-orders for the Limited Edition Majora’s Mask New 3DS XL. As of press time, it appears to only affect those who pre-ordered more than one system. Only one system was allotted per order, so the cancellation notices were sent out to comply with the restriction. Those […]

  • Rob Huebel is your KillCameraman in this CoD: Advanced Warfare video

    A live-action video for Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare – Havoc has been released by Activision. Subtitled: Randall Higgins: KillCameraman gives you a look at the action from a different perspective. In the video, Higgins is played by comedic actor and writer Rob Huebel (Children’s Hospital, Parks and Rec, The Mindy Project). The first DLC […]

  • Xbox App features included with Windows 10 January build outlined

    The January build of the Windows 10 Technical Preview includes a basic version of the Xbox App announced earlier this week. With the initial preview release, the team at Microsoft wanted to only include the basics such as high resolution monitor support along with keyboard and mouse input. Additional functionality will be released with each […]

  • Standalone version of DayZ has sold 3 million units

    The standalone version of DayZ sold 3 million units, Bohemia Interactive has announced. Release Just over a year ago on Steam Early Access, the milestone was hit yesterday. The standalone version was created by Dean Hall as a Arma 2 modification which has been updated 24 times since its initial release. In 2014, the development […]

  • The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt video shows gameplay clips, global hands-on events

    CD Projekt has released a video for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, giving a glimpse of gameplay and noting that hands-on impressions of the game will be bombarding the Internet next week. We’ll have extensive coverage of The Witcher 3 on Monday Jan 26 at 3pm GMT. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is coming to […]

  • Microsoft looking into possible HoloLens support for PC, Xbox One

    Microsoft’s HoloLens may be a dedicated device, but the company is obviously looking into how it could be used with PC and Xbox One. Speaking with Polygon, Xbox boss Phil Spencer said should the stand-alone product become a success, “specific scenarios” on how it could be used with Xbox One are already being brainstormed. “We […]

  • Final Fantasy Type-0 HD video compares PSP graphics to PS4, Xbox One

    A video for Final Fantasy Type-0 comparing the upcoming console version of the game to the original PSP version has been released by Square Enix. While comparing PSP graphics to those of PlayStation 4 and Xbox One seems rather unfair, it’s worth a watch anyway. Final Fantasy Type-0 HD releases March 17 in North America […]

  • Payday 2′s The Bomb Heists and Dragan Character Pack released

    In case you forgot, The Bomb Heists and Dragan Character content packs for Payday 2 were released yesterday. The new heist pack is available for $6.99/€6.99/£4.99 and the Dragan character will run you $4.99/€4.99/£3.99 through Steam and other digital distribution sites. Here’s the details: The Bomb Heists A new contact, called the Butcher, brought to […]

  • Rockstar offers tips on scaling GTA Online creations to support 30 players

    Rockstar has posted a tutorial of sorts on how to edit your GTA Online’s creations to support up to 30 players. According to the developer, when selecting Load Creation, users will be able to access any previously published Jobs and edit them in any way they wish. Users can also increase the Maximum Players races […]

  • Video for Life is Strange shows you how to rewind time

    If you could rewind time, would you change the events of your day or leave things be? In Life is Strange, you will make this choice. In the developer diary below, Dontnot Entertainment touches upon the main character’s ability to rewind time. How Max’s ability works and originated is also discussed. The first episode of […]

  • Take a look at one of the historical battles in Total War: Attila

    The Creative Assembly has revealed historical battles for Total War: Attila and shown off one of them. In the latest episode of Rally Point, developer Creative Assembly takes a look at one of the nine historical battles that will be included in Total War: Attila when it launches next month. But before you see the […]

  • ARMA 3 video lists 33 of its features, teases upcoming expansion

    ARMA 3 is an impressive military simulator, but that’s not the only thing impressive about it. In fact, this video lists 33 of the game’s most notable features. ARMA 3′s latest video gives you a tour of many of its strengths. It goes over the number of vehicles, weapons and playable area. But that’s not […]

77 Comments

  1. Razor

    Oh Dyer.

    See what I did there? I should get paid for thinking them up.

    #1 5 years ago
  2. The Hindle

    This is good on Sonys front as with the Ps3 they came out with a load of arrogant statements “the next generation doesnt start till we say it does” and then they got owned.

    Good to see they are taking a different approach.

    #2 5 years ago
  3. Goliath

    Doubt it. Natal is something entirely new, not just for gaming but for navigation. If it works, it could revolutionize not just gaming but entertainment interactivity. The Arc another motion controller. The casual gamer wont embrace it because it wont differentiate itself for Nintendo’s and the hardcore wont embrace it because it’s corny.

    #3 5 years ago
  4. Robo_1

    Interesting news about the code base being split for Natal! Does that mean you can’t simply create Natal enhanced games for 360 then?

    I always thought that Sony showing Resi 5 compatibility was a good sign of how easy it is to integrate Arc into current games. But then that does fit in with their strategy. MS are trying to do something entirely new with Natal, and that’s either going to make or break the platform.

    #4 5 years ago
  5. Erthazus

    As much as i love Sony, i hate them about one thing: P R

    thats the thing they seriously need to sell everything else.

    PR in Sony was always a problem and i can’t understand why.

    #5 5 years ago
  6. Gekidami

    @4
    Well according to MS its impossible to just patch a game to work with Natal so its no doubt true.

    #6 5 years ago
  7. Michael O’Connor

    Sony: “We can make stuff sell without advertising it.”

    Yes, that worked really well for the first few years of the PS3, didn’t it?

    “My feeling is that we’re going to have a lot more games, a lot more innovation.”

    You’re gonna have more innovation and more games by ripping off the WiiMote? Really? Funny, all I’ve seen is the deluge of company backing the Natal… not the Arc.

    #7 5 years ago
  8. itsucks

    How would just “Buff yourself the shit up” from a Crappy mii-too concept, and having a decent portofolio of games to backup a copy-cap concept that doesn’t really have those games on the Wii… would make the Natal Buzz go away?
    Its just going to prove that a Shitty idea like Arc is less shitty, nothing more MR Braindead PR Guy.

    #8 5 years ago
  9. tsubasaozora10

    honestly, i simply hate the hype surrounding Natal. when wii came out, all the people went “wow”, but all of us can see that the real worth-buying games are all 1st party ones and almost all the rest are poor games. ok, now we have wiimote plus that’s what the wiimote should have been from the beginning, but the hype is gone. with Natal, i don’t see people getting sweaty in front of the TV to play a game. have you ever think how many time we all see the stupid video of the ball game (the one vg247 added today, in his 1000th version) lol? came on! pads will rule videogaming for next 10 years.
    btw, PS Arc is a great strategy for PS3 to gain ports of Wii games. it is just biz, not quality

    #9 5 years ago
  10. Eregol

    I really can’t see Natal being used for Mainstream games at all.
    No haptic feedback, no peripheral to hold, meaning you’ll never be quite sure how much more effort you need to put into a movement to get it to reflect correctly.
    It’ll be impossible to do an FPS or anything with it, as if Natal tracks your head/body movement, to get your in game avatar to turn around you’d end up facing away from the tv!

    I’m not looking forward to either Arc or Natal. I believe they’re pointless exercises and should be left well alone until the next console generation.

    I would like to say though, that Eyetoy got there first, and Sony have demonstrated that they can patch Natal-like features into the PSEye.

    #10 5 years ago
  11. Blerk

    I think they’re both equally unappealing. Let’s see you make that go away, Sony! Or Microsoft. :-)

    #11 5 years ago
  12. Michael O’Connor

    Yes, it’s just a pity Sony have done barely anything with the EyeToy since 2006.

    The Natal *has* potential. It’ll be up to Microsoft and 3rd party developers to make use of it though.

    #12 5 years ago
  13. Zonejeu

    Well, the fight between Arc and Natal is the same fight than between the Wii and the Xbox. Arc is just an improvement of the system “invented” by the Wii, whereas Natal is totally different.

    In the end, we saw the result : by creating something new, selling it cheaper and marketing it right, the Wii sold 68 million consoles.

    I think that’s just it… Arc is not really new, it won’t be cheap, and Sony’s not the best at marketing its product (although the PSOne and PS2 marketing push were good).

    #13 5 years ago
  14. Michael O’Connor

    The fight between Arc and Natal is more like a little kid (Arc) getting pushed around the school yard by the vastly stronger bully (Natal), and the little kid refusing to stand up for himself thinking the problem will just “go away” if he waits long enough.

    #14 5 years ago
  15. Robo_1

    What?

    #15 5 years ago
  16. Razor

    “by creating something new…”

    What? The Wii was new technology? What the hell are you talking about? The Wii is not new technology at all.

    The extension of your analogy is that it’s actually Arc that stands more chance of being successful, because it’s existing technology, whereas Natal is more advanced and unproven.

    #16 5 years ago
  17. Michael O’Connor

    It was new to the mainstream public, that’s what he’s getting at.

    #17 5 years ago
  18. vincentw00t

    @9

    I think Nintendo and the big pile of money they made from Wii Fit would probably disagree with your point about people not wanting to get sweaty in front of their TVs playing games.

    #18 5 years ago
  19. Goliath

    The problem I see with Arc is two fold. Will it be bundles with the Eye toy or will it be sold as two separate peripherals, since you need the Eye toy for the Arc to work.

    #19 5 years ago
  20. The Hindle

    How do we Know Natal is better then Arc we know nothing about either. Microsofts attempts of anything casual have not done so well so if Natal is aimed at that audience it wont succeed.

    #20 5 years ago
  21. Erthazus

    Honestly… I can’t understand how people here saying that:

    Natal is great

    Natal is awesome

    Natal is something NEW

    Natal is the big tech and Ark is a Wii Rip Off.

    You guys never played PS Eye. Experience is horrible and how Anton said at E3: Without a trigger it is not a right experience.

    Thats why Sony promoting wands. Another thing is that NATAL have great support from PR and you all think that it is great… Its an old technology, go look at E3 Sony’s demos on what that thing can do. Its different tech from Wii and Natal and to prove this can pnly software and if Sony will have a good Software it can blow away some people.

    #21 5 years ago
  22. RoarrrUK

    The fight between Arc and Natal is more like a little kid (Arc) getting pushed around the school yard by the vastly stronger bully (Natal), and the little kid refusing to stand up for himself thinking the problem will just “go away” if he waits long enough.

    wth?

    #22 5 years ago
  23. Eregol

    Natal would be a big problem for someone like me who talks with their hands.
    We’d be watching a film and the misses would ask me to explain a plot point to her.
    After some gesticulating we’ll turn back to the tv to find we’ve fast forwarded to the last section of action before the credits.

    Bad times.

    #23 5 years ago
  24. The Hindle

    @23

    :) I find it funny people are already writing Arc off though how stupid of them.

    #24 5 years ago
  25. Michael O’Connor

    “You guys never played PS Eye.”

    This is a comparison I have constantly heard, and constantly debunked. Please tell me how a motion capturing device that can implant a person’s physical form into a 3D landscape is even remotely similar to a camera that does nothing other than detect changes in light.

    They’re about as similar as chalk and cheese. The Eye Toy comparison is a lazy cop-out for PS3 fanboys who don’t want to believe that the 360 is capable of doing something different or better.

    “wth?”

    What? Natal has been breathing down the Arc’s neck since E3. Watching “the wand” being announced after Microsoft’s Natal reveal was frankly pathetic to watch.

    The arc has nothing going for it beyond being a Wii Motion Plus rip-off, and unless Sony packs it *and* the PS Eye with every new machine then Microsoft has already won this battle.

    #25 5 years ago
  26. Michael O’Connor

    And please, before any of you respond accusing me of being a 360 fanboy… and it will happen… save your breath. Most of my favourite games of this generation, and most of the games I want the most this year are PS3 exclusives.

    #26 5 years ago
  27. Eregol

    Is MS packaging every new Xbox with Natal Michael?
    No?
    Then why would it matter that Sony wont be packaging every new console with Arc?
    I’m pretty sure that camera + wand will be less than $50, and that an extra wand will still be under that amount. So, it wont be any more expensive to buy than Natal will be.

    And you must have missed the Sony tech demos for PSEye that show 3D model head and face tracking that went out last year.

    The PSEye can do more than you think.

    #27 5 years ago
  28. The Hindle

    Next to nothing is known about Arc so how do you know it has next to nothing going for it? Do you know what games it has in development or how the games will use the device?

    Microsoft have been hyping Natal yes but Sony will reveal thiers more when they have games to show the software at its best.

    Have you actually played Natal to know its going to own the Arc?

    #28 5 years ago
  29. Michael O’Connor

    “Is MS packaging every new Xbox with Natal Michael?”

    There has been lots of speculation and rumour that yes, in fact, Microsoft will be packing the Natal with every new Xbox 360 after it launches: http://www.oxm.co.uk/article.php?id=14296 So the chances are very, very high.

    “And you must have missed the Sony tech demos for PSEye that show 3D model head and face tracking that went out last year.”

    That is nothing more than very smart manipulation of its already existing fuctions. That does not make it a motion capturing device, nor can it do any of the Natal’s unique functions.

    “Have you actually played Natal to know its going to own the Arc? Thats about the biggest fanboy statement ive read on this site so far.”

    No I haven’t, but then, you seem to be under the delusion that the average consumer cares about quality. If they did, the Wii would never have sold as well as it does.

    I’m talking from a consumer perspective, not a personal perspective, and the quality of a game or product is one of the least significant factors in selling it – consumer interest, smart advertising and sales strategies, and targeting the right market is all that matters.

    #29 5 years ago
  30. Eregol

    I have yet to see any proof that Natal will be any more than a PSEye with bells and whistles.
    They’ve not shown it doing anything that the PSEye cannot do.

    1:1 movement with PSEye will be a plus too.

    #30 5 years ago
  31. The Hindle

    Youre a fan of Playstation exclusives Micheal so if From Software or Media Molecule or ND made a motion control game you would still write it off?

    #31 5 years ago
  32. The Hindle

    The Arc will be easier to market then Natal in my opinion as people will look at it and think oh thats the Playstations version of the Wii remote.

    How you would market Natal i dont know. How do you get across that it doesnt require a controller it would confuse the average consumer.

    #32 5 years ago
  33. Quiiick

    @ #26
    A 360 fanboy disguised as a PS3 fanboy. But a fanboy non the less.

    #33 5 years ago
  34. NiceFellow

    @23 – I’m not going to call you a fanboy, and Arc does look a lot like a Wiimote – but I reckon it’s got more chance of being better for games as a result – nothing I’ve seen on Natal looks good IMHO. Everything has looked worse than what Wii does, so by my reckoning at least Sony will be able to match the Wii experience whereas Natal I think just looks unplayable.

    Love it as an interface, though. I want it hooked up to my PC asap so I can start giving it some Minority Report style access.

    #34 5 years ago
  35. Michael O’Connor

    “Youre a fan of Playstation exclusives Micheal so if From Software or Media Molecule or ND made a motion control game you would still write it off?”

    Not if it they’re good, no (though last time I checked, From Software made 360 games as well), but my main point was never about quality, but its consumer potential.

    That said, I’m not going to ignore the fact that the Arc is little more than a glorified WiiMote. Yes, I *do* think its sad and pathetic of Sony, a company who is regularly innovative and creative with its game, to so blatantly rip-off the competition. That’s usually Microsoft’s thing.

    (Oh look, I just insulted Microsft! Don’t die of shock!)

    “They’ve not shown it doing anything that the PSEye cannot do.”

    Right… well… when they start releasing games using the motion captured movements of an actual person on the PS3… we can discuss that point.

    “A 360 fanboy disguised as a PS3 fanboy. But a fanboy non the less.”

    If you’re going to troll, try harder please. My copy of Heavy Rain isn’t going to play itself, so I’d at least appreciate it if you made an insult with some substance behind it.

    #35 5 years ago
  36. Quiiick

    The only real problem I see with the “arc” is that it is comprised of two items. You can’t use the arc without the PS3eye. That’s complicated for marketing this thing and it makes it more expensive than “natal” from the get go.

    #36 5 years ago
  37. Michael O’Connor

    Valid point, Quiiick. If they don’t package both together, most people won’t care, and if they don’t package it with the machine, even less people will care.

    Obviously this applies to Microsoft as well. All hints suggest that it *will* come packaged with the 360, but if it doesn’t… then Microsoft are just as stupid. The WiiMote concept would never have taken off if it had simply been an add-on to an existing console.

    #37 5 years ago
  38. Seraphemz

    Michael – same can be said for the ‘Arc’

    and at E3 Sony wasn’t the one showing ‘smoke and mirrors’

    #38 5 years ago
  39. OlderGamer

    A couple of things

    Way too many fanboys wearing rose tinited glasses on this site.

    Natal and Arc will both underachieve.

    Both will be too expensive, too combersom to use, too ambitious to pull off, and unless they are 100% packed in(read given away for free) both will be a flop.

    Hardecore PS3/XB360 owning gamers don’t want to play motion controlled games. Those few that do, also own a Wii. The Mrs and me played Wii Sports last night, good times.

    The massive amount of Casual Gamers that would be interested in casual motion controls, already are one of the near 70million Wii owners.

    I do not believe that there are gamers out there thinking that if only they could play Halo, Uncharted, or BFBC2 while waving their hands through the air, their lives would be more full filling. Its a dumb idea.

    Who needs to use motion controls to start a movie? Is something somehow wrong with a remote or controler? How does moving your arm instead of pressing one button make more sense? Its a dumb idea.

    Ever play Lair? I did it was bad. Decent enough game, that had such bad motion controls it got patched post release so it could be played via standard duel analog sticks. How is Arc going to improve on that? Is Lair 2 going to benifit from motion controls? Its a dumb idea.

    Ever play a Wii? Most of the good games are 1st party. Most of the good controling games are either uber simple, or they incorperate the analog stick atachment for the Wiimote. Zelda, Metriod, Mario Galaxy all use a traditional analog thumb stick in your hand to perform basic char movements. The Wiimote is used to enhance char actions. Is the Arc going to also have an anolog stick that can be attached? Will Natal have buttons to press?

    Alot of question. More doubts then answers. And it all boils down to Sony, MS, and their respective Core audiences trying to figure out why Nintendo did so well with Wii. And of course trying to mimic it.

    Simple answer:

    Different demographics. My 70 yr old folks own and use a Wii. No way they are going to buy a PS3 or a XB360 because of ARC or Natal.

    And ask yourself, do you really want to play the next Jax and Dextar or Banjo games as Mario Galaxy clones? Are you excited Xbox360 Fit Around the World? How does Little Big Planet Mini Game Battle Royal sound?

    Beware the wolf is sheeps clothing. Becareful of what you wish for.

    If you want to play a Wii, buy a Wii.

    #39 5 years ago
  40. Quiiick

    @ #35
    Relax! Don’t be so dead serious. My comment (#33) wasn’t meant to be insulting. I was only joking.
    Calm down please, even if you get all the heat in this thread.

    #40 5 years ago
  41. Michael O’Connor

    “and at E3 Sony wasn’t the one showing ’smoke and mirrors’”

    Smoke and mirrors? That’s unny, I distinctly recall numerous live presentations of the software…

    “Unless they are 100% packed in(read given away for free) both will be a flop.”

    Then its a good thing that all hints suggest that the Natal will be packed in with the console, right?

    I’m calling it now. See you guys at E3.

    “Are you excited Xbox360 Fit Around the World?”

    Yes I am, actually. A fitness product that requires you to actual BE PHYSICAL ACTIVE is a hell of a lot more awesome than standing on a giant steel box.

    Lets not forget that everyone thought the Wii would be a flop. “Nobody wants to move around while playing games”. How wrong they were…

    “Relax! Don’t be so dead serious. My comment (#33) wasn’t meant to be insulting. I was only joking.”

    I’m entirely calm. I’m practically a living Vulcan. *laughs*

    I simply responded to your accusation that I was a fanboy, which you said in a fairly direct manner with absolutely no hints of humour. Please feel free to show me the exclamation points or other such signs to show that I wasn’t calm.

    Apparently people don’t like discourse. Kinda defeats the point of posting on the internet if you don’t.

    #41 5 years ago
  42. Gekidami

    “That said, I’m not going to ignore the fact that the Arc is little more than a glorified WiiMote. Yes, I *do* think its sad and pathetic of Sony, a company who is regularly innovative and creative with its game, to so blatantly rip-off the competition.”

    You know, Sony have been messing around with colour tracking (the main part of ARC) for quite some time. Hell, they even demoed it the same day they revealed the PS3 (And yes, the guy from both those videos is the same guy that presented the wand at E3 09).

    On a sidenote Media Molecule have already showed LBP working with ARC.

    #42 5 years ago
  43. Michael O’Connor

    I fail to see your point, Geki. It’s still a rip-off in concept, if not in how its executed.

    Obviously they needed to invent new hardware since the WiiMote is patented by Nintendo, but at the end of the day it does exactly the same thing as the Wii Motion Plus does, depth of field tracking of a physical object.

    Natal is a motion capturing device. It detects the entire human body and can transpose it into a game as a physical object. The *potential* for that is huge. Whether companies can actually take advantage of that potential is another matter.

    #43 5 years ago
  44. OlderGamer

    #41 packing it in with new consoles is a good start. But our house owns 3 xb360s and 2 PS3s, we won’t be buying another xb360 for natal. Are they going to give us three or even one natal set up? Doubt it.

    Giving it away for new consumers is a good idea, but it won’t help the already estanblished user base.

    Do you use Wii Fit?

    we own it, you can do several exercises w/o the board. Infact several Wii exercise games don’t use the board at all. You physicly move around. Even with the baord, its more about balance then just standing there. I am not preaching about it, but lest I know what it does and doesn’t do. No bias slant.

    #44 5 years ago
  45. get2sammyb

    Your points irritate me a little Michael. Have you played EyePet per chance? That thing is pretty close to augmented reality, and it was done last year, in 2009.

    I’m not going to say Natal is good for nothing, and I’m sure it’s going to outsell Arc. But for quality experiences I’d hedge a bet with Sony’s development studios. Sony Studio London and Sony Studio Cambridge have been making these “kind” of experiences for years — it would be naive to think just because they have some new tech, a developer like Rare can jump in a beat those studios at their own game.

    Natal will outsell Arc and will probably get more support than Arc — either way I’d wait and see what the in-house studios have to offer before you write it off. Sony’s European teams are VERY creative — and it’ll be interesting to see what a studio like Japan Studio can come up with for Arc too.

    Either way, I still stand that we’ve seen MUCH MORE practical use for Arc than Natal at this stage. Microsoft are still sticking with that Ricochet demo, that frankly does not look fun. And if anyone expect Milo to be a reality, they indeed are dreaming. A side-project at Lionhead managing to create artificial life that an organisation such as NASA couldn’t manage? Yeah right.

    People can talk about potential all they like (and Microsoft have done), it’s time to show. I think it’s going to get VERY interesting when Sony show their hand.

    Word is Studio Cambridge are working on the “blockbuster” title for this device, and apparently Sony have a lot of “core” support for the device too. Again, it might not be a hit commercially, but that doesn’t make it “shit” or “worse than Natal”.

    Given the levels of hype (particularly from people who hate the Wii), I expect a huge backlash when the inevitable XBOX Fitness game becomes the staple of Natal’s lineup.

    #45 5 years ago
  46. Erthazus

    @ Michael, sorry but it is the same thing from person who is trying to make lame excuse: I’m not a fanboy i have all 3 consoles…

    Its just the person who have more money to spent on their hobby or GAMES (!). You can have all systems or like some games from other system but you can have your favourite system that you can defend all the time. I for example have all systems (except of 360 because i’m afraid of RROD. I have all systems since NES and everything works fine. when they will solve problem with Red Ring Of Death i will buy console, or i’m starting to think about Arcade version of it because Alan Wake will be amazing and it is cancelled on my PC =() and i prefer to play on my PC more then all my devices combined even if they have much better games. Not just better games… MUCH, MUCH BETTER GAMES.

    Michael you are an Xbot.

    Second, if you never played Playstation Eye games then i can’t talk with you seriously. In the tech they are absolutely similar except that Natal can use technology further with 3D motion capture. Basically you will just have better games VISUALLY right? Right.

    but sitting in front of your TV and shit, does not improve your experience a bit. Its the same thing with wands, but with accuracy wand such as Playstation motion controller you can FEEL the trigger and movement and especially your character.

    you will understand that if you will but PS Eye and try it. Buy it and try to play with some 1st party games and after that you will say: Yeah, thats really is a sucky experience.

    Natal and PS Eye is the same experience except that Natal have enhanced features that improve visual experience ONLY! you can create games like Milo and Kate YES (and you are wating for the game like that with artificial life??? Lol), but games like Ricochet and dynamic games simply suck ass. Microsoft still stick with that stupid Ricochet demo and it still not fun.

    #46 5 years ago
  47. The Hindle

    OG just summed it up perfectly in comment 39.

    #47 5 years ago
  48. Michael O’Connor

    “#41 packing it in with new consoles is a good start. But our house owns 3 xb360s and 2 PS3s, we won’t be buying another xb360 for natal. Are they going to give us three or even one natal set up? Doubt it.”

    Obviously not, but you can just buy one and share it out. Like you said, its a start. And if Microsoft pack it with the machine and Sony doesn’t, the battle between the two is already won.

    I never said it would be the Wii. That would be stupid. That’s not the point though. I will be very surprised if Sony are still supporting the Arc as a significant part of the console’s experience two years down the line.

    “Do you use Wii Fit?”

    Yes, I do have Wii Fit. My sister once broke her leg using the thing. You’re also limited to a very specific point while using it, which is retarded.

    “Different demographics. My 70 yr old folks own and use a Wii. No way they are going to buy a PS3 or a XB360 because of ARC or Natal.”

    Maybe if you show it to them, and it comes out with some genuinely inventive games, it might. You never know. Stranger things have happened…

    Who ever thought Nintendo would be the leader in generation, for example? Who ever thought Sony would topple Nintendo in the 90s? Who ever thought that Microsoft would become a significant part of the gaming landscape?

    Nobody. It’s an unpredictable industry. At the end of the day, all we’re all doing is guessing really. My money is on Natal.

    #48 5 years ago
  49. Michael O’Connor

    “You can have all systems or like some games from other system but you can have your favourite system that you can defend all the time”

    I defend Sony and Nintendo constantly. I constantly debunk people’s accusations that the Wii is nothing more than a shovelware console, and I always defend the fact that Sony is far more creatively diverse and challenging with its games.

    That doesn’t mean I have to like the Arc.

    “when they will solve problem with Red Ring Of Death i will buy console.”

    They solved the problems with the RROD years ago.

    “Second, if you never played Playstation Eye games then i can’t talk with you seriously.”

    I owe one, and I also have the original EyeToy and numerous games for it, but thanks for assuming.

    “Basically you will just have better games VISUALLY right? Right.”

    No, I’m saying the potential of putting your own physical body into a game is huge. The *potential*. There is no more potential with the Arc than there is with the Wii, and I already own a Wii.

    “you can create games like Milo and Kate”

    I will point out right now that Milo and Kate is a terrible example of what Natal is capable of. That game *could* easily be done with the PlayStation Eye. I’m not going to deny that for a second. But I’m more interested in the concept of Milo and Kate than I am with the technology behind it – I’d buy it regardless of what console it was on.

    “Have you played EyePet per chance? That thing is pretty close to augmented reality, and it was done last year, in 2009.”

    Yes I have. It’s quite fun. That doesn’t mean I think the Arc will be a success. EyePet was the first game in years to make the Eye remotely relevant. If that’s the kind of support they end up giving the Arc…

    “Either way, I still stand that we’ve seen MUCH MORE practical use for Arc than Natal at this stage.”

    I’m far more interested in new experience than treading the same ground. And the Arc treads far too familiar ground.

    #49 5 years ago
  50. get2sammyb

    What new experience have you SEEN from Natal then Michael? Honestly?

    You seem to berate other posters for assuming, but in all honesty I think you’re assuming a lot of what’s possible with Natal — and you’re drawing your assumptions from the PR that Microsoft have fed you.

    I also think you’re judging success by sales rather than experience.

    #50 5 years ago
  51. Michael O’Connor

    “I also think you’re judging success by sales rather than experience.”

    I already said I’m arguing consumer interest, not personal interest.

    “You’re drawing your assumptions from the PR that Microsoft have fed you.”

    No, I’m drawing my assumptions from the tech demos they showed. Soccer games where you physically kick the ball during penalties. Tennis games using an actual racket. Fitness titles that actually require you to move around properly. The multiplayer potential is also interesting to consider. And those are just the ideas off the top of my head.

    But hey, I guess I’m different from most gamers seeing as I actually *like* the idea of being physically active…

    #51 5 years ago
  52. Gekidami

    “It’s still a rip-off in concept, if not in how its executed.”

    Like Natal with the EyeToy you mean? Sure in execution… (you know where this is going).

    “Obviously they needed to invent new hardware since the WiiMote is patented by Nintendo”

    Sony have been working on this tech since the early PS2 days. I’m not to sure what you expected them to do with it; Decide to scrap it because Nintendo released the Wii in between time? Its tech that requires it be held in a persons hand, making it into a ‘wand’ was sort of a no-brainer (notice how in PS2 tech demo up there he also calls it a “wand”).

    #52 5 years ago
  53. Michael O’Connor

    “Like Natal with the EyeToy you mean? Sure in execution… (you know where this is going).”

    The Eye is not capable of motion capturing. It is not capable of taking a physical human body and putting it into a 3D landscape as a 3D object. All the Eye does is take notice of changes in light and reacts accordingly.

    So no, it’s not even remotely similar.

    #53 5 years ago
  54. Newbie101

    With eyepet couldn’t you draw something on a piece of paper, put it in front of the camera, and it comes out in full 3d for your pet to play with? Sounds cool if you ask me.

    #54 5 years ago
  55. Michael O’Connor

    Yes, *that* is similar. I’m not talking about that. That’s like saying a Walkman is similar to an iPod because they can both play music.

    I’m talking about the motion capturing component, which is *the* major backbone of the Natal.

    #55 5 years ago
  56. Gekidami

    “The Eye is not capable of motion capturing. It is not capable of taking a physical human body and putting it into a 3D landscape as a 3D object. All the Eye does is take notice of changes in light and reacts accordingly.”

    You’re just being an idiot now. The concept of the EyeToy is to let games react to the players physical movements. Same as Natal, how it does it is -as you said- just different execution. The concept is the same and according to you copying a concept is the greatest crime.

    “No, I’m drawing my assumptions from the tech demos they showed. Soccer games where you physically kick the ball during penalties. Tennis games using an actual racket. Fitness titles that actually require you to move around properly.”

    Got a link? I mean a link actually showing tech demos that exist rather then that a fabricated “heres an idea” video MS showed at E3 in which everything showed is clearly not running in realtime.

    #56 5 years ago
  57. OlderGamer

    Seems like its Mr. O’Connor vs 2/3rds the site.

    In the end only time will tell. I don’t think either will do well. I fully expect a Wii price drop to stifle their sales this holiday season.

    #57 5 years ago
  58. dirigiblebill

    The problem with the internet is that nobody backs down.

    #58 5 years ago
  59. Seraphemz

    Get – +1 awesome point.

    #59 5 years ago
  60. Michael O’Connor

    It detects those physical movements through the subtle change in light. You’re stuck with having to stand there and reacting to the on-screen graphics.

    It cannot emulate a human being physical movements directly. If I punch with an Eyetoy, I have to punch *at* the physical image painted on the screen, and it simply detects that the change in light has occurred there. This can also be cheated by using any object – it doesn’t even have to be a person in front of the camera.

    If I punch with a Natal, my 3D avatar will actually punch forward as a physical *object* within the game world. And you will have to actually use your own body.

    The Arc detects movements and moves the pointer on the screen accordingly. This is *exactly* what the WiiMote does.

    Comparing a 3D motion capturing device that can create real, 3D movement within a game to a 2D camera that simply detects change in light is far from the blatant comparisons between the WiiMote and the Arc.

    Those are two entirely different experiences.

    “Got a link? I mean a link actually showing tech demos that exist rather then that a fabricated “heres an idea” video MS showed at E3 in which everything shows is clearly not running in realtime.”

    The ball game and the painting thing were both running in real time.

    “Seems like its Mr. O’Connor vs 2/3rds the site.”

    Good for them. I wasn’t aware that I was obliged to follow other people’s opinions. If someone doesn’t want to argue something or have a discussion, they do *not* have to respond to me. Just like in the real world.

    #60 5 years ago
  61. CroMagnon

    As fascinating as this discussion is, I’m more amused by Dyer’s statement that Arc will have more third party support than Natal because it’s easier to program for.

    That sounds exactly like Apple when they boasted that the iPhone had twice as many games as the DS and PSP combined. Wii and iPhone shovelware is hardly a good precedent for the Arc – but I suspect that it will probably follow that model.

    I’m not claiming that Natal will be any better in terms of ridiculous gimmicky party games, but maybe the difficulty in programming means that even if there won’t be an increase in quality, at least the quantity of shitty games will be lower on the XBox.

    #61 5 years ago
  62. get2sammyb

    Where’ve you seen these kicking a football demoes? I’ve seen Ricochet, Painting, Milo (not live demo), and some shitty implementation into Burnout, Katamari and Half-Life (which you’d do best to ignore if you’re arguing for Natal).

    #62 5 years ago
  63. NiceFellow

    Just to add to the madness because I can’t resist didn’t I see somewhere (perhaps here) that Sony was augmenting the software side of the Eyetoy to include facial recognition and some degree of motion tracking, bringing it closer to Natal from the camera/software point of view and allowing that to integrate with the controllers for input?

    BTW Oldergamer is spot on about the implications of pack in vs separate and the fact the Wii probably already has a ton of the potential market-share for this.

    On another note, I wonder how many Eyetoy’s have actually sold for PS3 with EyePet, Eye of Judgment, etc as in theory Sony might have a an in-built audience for some initial sales.

    #63 5 years ago
  64. Eregol

    “No, I’m drawing my assumptions from the tech demos they showed. Soccer games where you physically kick the ball during penalties.”

    Are you the only person who has seen this, because I don’t think anyone else here has.
    And without some sort of feedback you’re never going to know how hard you actually kicked the ball….

    By the way, what happened to the 360s wonderful camera add-on that came with ‘You’re in the movies’? One game and then ‘poof’ gone?
    I hope they support Natal better.

    #64 5 years ago
  65. mtmind2

    @get2sammyb who said “Where’ve you seen these kicking a football demoes?”

    Yes, I was wondering about that.

    And said “and some shitty implementation into Burnout, Katamari and Half-Life”.

    I haven’t seen Natal with HL myself, and Katamari was interesting, but the Burnout demo was far from being a “shitty implementation”. Natal worked extremely well for that Burnout demo, and with negligible lag.

    My problem with Arc is that it’s very much a “me-too” product, and I think this is why it hasn’t caught the public imagination as Natal has. So whilst it’s great to have a more accurate Wiimote, I’m skeptical that Arc will offer much more beyond Wii type casual games on the PS3.

    Natal is also going to be more for the casual gamer, the type who is currently happy with the Wii, however compared to Arc I think there’s more chance of Natal capturing the Wii audience looking for something new.

    #65 5 years ago
  66. Michael O’Connor

    “Are you the only person who has seen this, because I don’t think anyone else here has.”

    “Where’ve you seen these kicking a football demoes?”

    It was an example of what it could do. As I have already said a million times before, I’m talking about the device’s potential vs. Arc’s potential. Until both of them are actually released, that’s all *anyone* can do.

    The comprehension skills of the most of the members on this website, or their ability to actually hold a coherent discussion without turning into ignorant and defensive fanboys is not that high.

    Thank god we have posters like OlderGamer.

    “By the way, what happened to the 360s wonderful camera add-on that came with ‘You’re in the movies’? One game and then ‘poof’ gone?”

    The camera was out long before You’re In The Movies was released. That was a stab at a casual game, and a failed one at that. But the camera was never invented for that purpose.

    Natal is being pushed as an integral part of the 360, as part of the next five years of the console’s lifespan. This is hardly a cheap stab at some casual games with only one or two titles.

    Microsoft’s biggest problem is that they often don’t put enough force and commitment behind their endeavours. The degree to which they’re pushing the Natal hardware though is proof enough that this won’t be a flash-in-the-pan idea like those “casual games” were.

    #66 5 years ago
  67. Eregol

    To be honest Michael, everything you’re saying is stuff that was rolled out when the Wii was first announced.
    Now the Wii is drowning underneath shovelware and third parties are deserting it as the titles that are worth playing and actually cost to make are over-looked in favour of carnival games and things grannies will play.

    I remain sceptical of both Natal and Arc, I never asked for motion control (although it worked beautifully with Flower). The Arc has it’s limitations, same as the Wiimote, and arc has just as many.

    The whole idea of head tracking and other things just cannot be implemented as to turn your head to look means you will be looking away from the screen. Bloody stupid idea.

    “The comprehension skills of the most of the members on this website, or their ability to actually hold a coherent discussion without turning into ignorant and defensive fanboys is not that high.”

    Please don’t insult our intelligence by the way Michael. You’re not exactly covering yourself with glory in some of your arguments.
    You’ve constantly sung the praises of Natal while dismissing Arc and not said anything the other way around.
    Everyone else has said positives for both, and negatives, you only seem to be coming from one direction, the MS camp. That is why you’re being labelled a fanboy.

    #67 5 years ago
  68. Michael O’Connor

    “You’ve constantly sung the praises of Natal while dismissing Arc and not said anything the other way around.”

    I have said numerous times that if the games are good, I’ll play them. That doesn’t change the fact that I have no love for the device itself. A rip-off is a rip-off.

    #68 5 years ago
  69. mtmind2

    @Michael O’Connor who wrote “A rip-off is a rip-off”

    But that’s the same claim made by some about Natal. Some say it’s nothing more than an enhanced Eyetoy, and therefore it’s a rip-off. Some say Arc is just a more accurate Wii, and hence it’s a rip-off.

    Technology is about progress, it’s about development, and both Arc and Natal are good examples of this, both offer something beyond the tech which inspired them, and therefore neither are rip-offs.

    #69 5 years ago
  70. Michael O’Connor

    Except for the fact that the Natal is *not* a rip-off of the Eye Toy, and isn’t even remotely *close* to being one.

    #70 5 years ago
  71. mtmind2

    And except for the fact that Arc is *not* a rip-off of the Wiimote and isn’t even remotely *close* to being one.

    Btw, I’m very excited over Natal (albeit disappointed by the removal of the onboard processor), but I’m excited about Arc too, I’m just more skeptical over it’s role in PS3 games compared to Natal for 360 games.

    #71 5 years ago
  72. Michael O’Connor

    “And except for the fact that Arc is *not* a rip-off of the Wiimote and isn’t even remotely *close* to being one.”

    You mean, ignoring that they both serve exactly the same function? Stick a Wii Motion Plus Sensor on the WiiMote and they do *exactly* the same thing.

    #72 5 years ago
  73. mtmind2

    It’s not exactly the same. Whilst the Wii Motion Plus improves the accuracy of the Wiimote, it’s still just an extra set of gyros added to the Wiimote to serve that purpose. The Wiimote + MP does NOT (and will never) give the gamer 1:1 response time, whereas Arc has been designed for that level of accuracy on the PS3.

    The differences coming mostly from the fact that the Wiimote has a tiny infrared camera/sensor at the end of the controller to detect the IR LEDS within the sensor bar, whereas Arc uses the PSEye camera to detect the light at the end of the controller, both for spacial position and distance.

    #73 5 years ago
  74. Michael O’Connor

    Yes, but they still do the same thing. Detect the movement of an object in your hand in real time and display it on screen. 1:1 response doesn’t change that they do the same exact thing *in-game*.

    #74 5 years ago
  75. mtmind2

    Doing the same thing has nothing to do with it, they achieve the end result in a different way for key areas and similar in others, where Arc achieves significant superior accuracy and speed compared to the Wiimote as a result of those differences.

    Natal is nothing new either. 3DV’s Z-camera or ZCam (webcam with InfaRed cam to measure distance) has been around for *years*, and made an appearance at numerous tech shows.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8_yWZFcgPPk&feature=fvw
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=233hzDgkwWM&feature=related

    MS bought the company last year (protecting Natal from competition as well as gaining access to 3DV’s existing tech).

    So even if we dismiss the claim that Natal is an EyeToy rip-off, since Natal does *exactly* the same thing as the ZCam, then by your logic Natal *is* a rip-off, a ZCam rip-off!

    Note: EyeToy creator Richard Marks demonstrated the ZCam connected to the PS2 way back in 2004.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jYHr0I-iFHE

    So like I said, both Arc and Natal are enhancements to existing technology, and therefore neither are rip-offs.

    #75 5 years ago
  76. Eregol

    @75
    Your comments prove Michael’s comments wrong and are therefore invalid.
    :-D
    Lols

    #76 5 years ago
  77. OlderGamer

    Eregol Said:

    “Now the Wii is drowning underneath shovelware and third parties are deserting it as the titles that are worth playing and actually cost to make are over-looked in favour of carnival games and things grannies will play.”

    Agreed and this is the number one reason for me, that I am at times almost fearful of the so called casual gamers and their market. They simply can not tell an AAA game from shovelware. And with todays graphics and marketing it can be tough to tell from a simple box alone. Factor in that price point as a key factor of purchase for said demographic and the Wii is just being overrun with craptastic games.

    Why would anyone want that for the PS3 or xb360?

    I have so many reservations about these pruducts(Arc/Natal) that I don’t really know where to begin.

    Either we are going to get crap shovelware games that we never heard of before made by companies looking to cash in that we have never heard of before… Or ….established game franchises will incorperate these technologies into their current and future versions.

    I would rather have a traditionaly controlled version of CoD, GoW, Halo, Uncharted, FIFA or LBP. I doubt games that allow you to toggle between game pad or arc/natal is going to work either. I am not looking forward to playing GT5 online and watching the car infront of me swurving all over the track because the fool is trying to use motion controls to drive.

    And, to be honest, I really don’t want or need a game of kick the ball against a wall of colored bricks.

    I can just see someone sneezing while playing a game of Natal, then what? You better not have to itch your face while playing either. How heavy is the Arc? Because as silly as it seems, my arms can get tired after playing certian Wii games for a while.

    But if your excited to play the endless wave of garbage that is being ported over from the Wii to the PS3 as we speak, then your in luck. If you just gotta navagate your XB360 menus by waving your arms through the air, your day is coming.

    #77 5 years ago

Comments are now closed on this article.

  • No Man’s Sky dev explains what you actually do in the game

    No Man’s Sky is simultaneously the most intriguing mystery and the most scary. Developer Hello Games is asked some questions and gives some solid answers. Eurogamer asked Hello Games’ Sean Murray a number of questions that are on everyone’s mind when they think about No Man’s Sky. The biggest one being, what do you actually […]

  • Dying Light physical release set for February 27, Be The Zombie mode goes free

    The release date for the physical version of Dying Light has been confirmed for Europe, along with the release dates for all regions. Dying Light developer Techland has confirmed that the PC version of the game will release digitally, worldwide, on January 27. The physical version and the digital PS4 and Xbox One versions will […]

  • Guild Wars 2 is $10 this weekend

    ArenaNet is offering Guild Wars 2 for $10 this weekend only, and hosting a double XP event during the same period. The regular and Digital Deluxe editions of Guild Wars 2 are both offered at 75% off this weekend. The regular edition can be yours for just $10 while the Deluxe is $15. The offer […]

  • Cyberpunk 2077 development still going, but the focus is on The Witcher 3, says dev

    If you’re dying to hear anything about CD Projekt Red’s Cyberpunk 2077, you’ll be waiting a while still. The focus is on The Witcher 3 right now. Ever since Cyberpunk 2077′s announcement all the way back in 2012 developer CD Projekt Red has been really quiet about the sci-fi RPG. We’ve not seen any gameplay […]

  • Digital pet Animin gamecards get May release

    With AR being all the go, it might be worth checking out virtual pet Animin for iOS and Android. Game-cards for Animin, the virtual pet for iOS and Android, are set to appear at UK retail this May, the developers have announced. Animin sits on your touch device and does cute stuff. The little dude […]

  • You won’t need a new GPU for DirectX 12, except for some features

    Microsoft has clarified that while you’ll need a new GPU to get the full potential of DirectX 12, existing hardware will support it just fine. Microsoft’s Mike Ybarra said in a press meeting following the Windows 10 event that you will need a new graphics card to get “the full benefits” of DirectX 12. “There […]

  • Assassin’s Creed Victory: fans speculate over characters and locations

    Ubisoft has not yet started talking about Assassin’s Creed: Victory, so some eager fans are speculating about everything they can just from those leaked screens. A very popular thread right now on the Ubisoft forums attempts to gather fans’ specualtion about characters, events and story of Assassin’s Creed: Victory. What followed was quite a lot […]

  • This is what co-op looks like in Dying Light

    Dying Light’s cop-op mode has been given a short demo by developer Techland. Dying Light supports drop-in/ drop-out co-op for up to four players. The entire campaign is playable in co-op, and there are special co-op challenges. Watch as four members of developer Techland take on the game’s zombie apocalypse. Dying Light is out January […]

  • Get Saints Row 2, Saints Row: The Third and all DLC for $5

    Bundle Stars’ latest bundle packs Saints Row 2 and the complete Saints Row: The Third for $5. The Saints Row bundle is priced $5. It is live now and for another 14 days. It comes with Saints Row 2, Saints Row: The Third – The Full Package, which is basically the game plus all the […]

  • Destiny: Xur location and inventory for January 23, 24

    Xur: Agent of the Nine has made the trek to Destiny’s Tower for another week of business. Destiny’s Exotics vendor, Xur: Agent of the Nine has arrived at the Tower as per the weekly schedule. Xur will sell you Exotic weapons and armour pieces if you have the Strange Coins to afford it. He also […]

  • Bloodborne is getting two special edition PS4s in Japan

    Sony will launch two limited-edition, Bloodborne-themed PlayStation 4 bundles in Japan. Two bundles are available, one in black and another in white, complete with a controller and a headset. The hard disk cover is engraved with the title and the cover shot. Both bundles come with the collector’s edition release of the game, which was […]

  • Best Destiny videos of the week – Xur vs Cryptarch rap battle

    Destiny has once more produced a slew of entertaining, educational and occasionally baffling videos. Destiny players have repeatedly sparked crazes by exploiting the game’s little foibles – Sparrow surfing is one example. This latest one is kind of mysterious; I don’t know how it’s done, or why you would want to, but Hidden Reach has […]

  • The Sims 4 free for 48 hours with Origin Game Time

    The Sims 4 is the latest game to be offered free through Origin’s Game Time promotion. The Sims 4 is now free to download from Origin, granting you a 48 hour window to try it out and see if you want to pay for the full game. The free time starts counting as soon as […]

  • Check out Destiny’s new PvP mode, Doubles

    Destiny Crucible players can enjoy a new kind of PvP action with Doubles. Destiny may not be as PvP focused as some Halo fans were hoping, but Bungie is slowly ramping up Crucible support, starting with better Iron Banner events. Some time ago the developer promised to introduce experimental game modes, and the latest Bungie […]

  • Halo: New Blood novel launching digitally in March

    A new Halo novel will explore the backstory of Gunnery Sergeant Edward Buck. Halo: New Blood is a digital-first short novel launching on March 2. The 60,000 word novel was penned by Matt Forbeck, an award-winning author of many licensed fantasy and sci-fi publications. It’s an all-new story, but fans of Halo 3: ODST will […]

  • Destiny players purchased 1.1 million Ice Breakers last week

    Destiny players know what’s hot, and Exotic sniper rifle Ice Breaker is definitely warm. Destiny vendor Xur offered Ice Breaker for sale last weekend, much to the delight of everyone yet to find this terrific bit of gear. According to the latest Bungle Weekly Update, Xur sold 1,143,320 Ice Breakers. He left the tower with […]

  • Dragon Age: Inquisition nets GLAAD special recognition award

    Dragon Age: Inquisition has been honoured for its diverse representation by LGBT advocacy body GLAAD. Dragon Age: Inquisition will receive a special recognition award for “the many complex and unique LGBT characters prominently integrated throughout the game”. GLAAD doesn’t normally honour video games (maybe one day, if we ever have enough that deserve it), but […]

  • The Order: 1886 AR game is full of puzzles

    The Order: 1886 has spawned a new promotional website with lots of info to ferret out. Called The Order Exposed, the new site pertains to be the blog of a missing researcher, who had been hoping to uncover the secrets of the alternate history. This on its own is quite interesting but it’s also full […]

  • Grow Home is the next game to follow Child of Light, Valiant Hearts

    Ubisoft has announced another small passion project in the wake of the success of recent releases. Child of Light, Valiant Hearts: The Great War and Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon are all the products of a new initiative at Ubisoft where the publisher lets key developers rest after big triple-A projects by working on something […]

  • What mysterious reveal is Xbox teasing for May 4?

    Xbox is teasing something we’ll be waiting quite a while to learn more about. Xbox community manager Raj Patel tweeted the following earlier today: Hmm… pic.twitter.com/4wBGu6xsDc — Raj Patel (@Rajio) January 22, 2015 NeoGAF users spotted the morse code in the background of the image, which translates as follows: “Presented by Xbox, 10am PDT, 1pm […]

  • 2011 PSN hack class action settlement claim forms available

    PlayStation Network members affected by the 2011 hack and downtime can now claim part of a $15 million settlement. The PSN was down for months on end in 2011 following a major hack, which resulted in user details being compromised. Sony apologised and provided free games as compensation, but unhappy gamers banded together in a […]

  • Final Fantasy 15 has a true open world

    Final Fantasy 15 doesn’t just have “open world gameplay”, it has a true open world – one continuous stretch of environment. “The world is connected by continuous land,” director Hajime Tabata told Gamespot. “If those areas were disconnected, it would feel distant from reality. You’ll find that you’ll be able to walk or drive or […]

  • Suikoden, Suikoden 2 EU PSN release date locked down

    Suikoden and its first sequel will be available via the European PlayStation Network soon. Suikoden publisher Konami has confirmed a February 4 release date for the two RPG classics. CONFIRMED! #Suikoden I & II EU #PSN release date is FEB 4TH! http://t.co/ObOIvZDJAK pic.twitter.com/aM760R2Gez — Konami UK (@KonamiUK) January 22, 2015 It’s been a long wait […]

  • Dying Light physical release set for February 20, says Gamestop Italy

    Dying Light’s physical release has been delayed, but at least one European retailer thinks it knows what’s going on. Dying Light’s physical release date is February 20, according to Gamestop Italy. According to Tmag (Italian, via Google Translate), there’s been no response from local representatives of publisher Warner Bros. Although the digital release will take […]

  • Free online multiplayer update now available for Trials Fusion

    Online multiplayer is now available as a free update to Trials Fusion. The online component includes three new four to eight player multiplayer modes on PC, PS4 and Xbox One and up to four players on Xbox 360. These are the three new gameplay modes included with the update can be found through a previous […]

  • This video for indie survival horror Monstrum features all in-game footage

    Monstrum launches on Steam Early Access January 29 and today, you can have a look at a video for it featuring all in-game footage. Developed by Team Junkfish the survival horror game set on a derelict cargo ship which combines roguelike elements, such as procedurally generated levels and permadeath thanks to AI driven predators. Monstrum […]

  • Here’s quick look at Dead Rising: Watchtower starring Rob Riggle

    A short look at the film adaptation of Dead Rising has surfaced. Transformers director Lorenzo di Bonaventura headed the project and it was directed by Zach Lipovsky. It stars comedy actor Rob Riggle as Frank West, along with Academy Awards nominated actress Virginia Madsen (Candyman, Sideways), Dennis Haysbert (24), Meghan Ory (Once Upon a Time), and […]

  • A Kickstarter for Underworld Ascendant will launch next month

    OtherSide Entertainment, an independent games studio fronted by Paul Neurath, has announced it’s developing Underworld Ascendant. Neurath is the founder and CEO of the new studio ad his resume includes franchises such as Thief, System Shock and 1992′s Underworld Underworld. The studio hopes Underworld Ascendant will “innovate and revitalize” the fantasy genre. More details will […]

  • APB Reloaded heading to PS4 and Xbox One during Q2 2015

    APB Reloaded will indeed be heading to PlayStation 4 and Xbox One during late Q2 this year, which puts its release sometime around the end of June. Reloaded Productions announced in September 2014 it was working on bringing the free-to-play PC title to consoles during the Digital Media Wire event in New York City. The […]

  • Game of Thrones: Episode 2 -The Lost Lords arrives in February – video

    Release dates for Game of Thrones: A Telltale Games Series have been announced. A new video offering a “first look” has also appeared. Below is the story synopsis, which you may want to skip if you haven’t played Episode One. House Forrester is in disarray. Their liege lord and his heir are dead, and Ironrath […]

  • The open beta for Nosgoth has gone live

    Consider this a friendly reminder: the Nosgoth open beta has started. Announced last week, the open beta can be accessed through the official website. Once you link your Steam account, just log into the service and start downloading the client. Everyone that plays the tester will receive double XP through January 28. More information is […]

  • First gameplay footage of Homeworld Remastered Collection being shown this weekend

    Homeworld Remastered Collection news and the first gameplay footage of Gearbox Software’s remake will be revealed at PAX South this weekend. The news and video will be shown during the Inside Gearbox Software panel at 10.30am CST on Sunday. It will also be streamed on Twitch. Gearbox is hoping to have Homeworld Remastered released by […]

  • Latest Final Fantasy Type-0 HD video delves more into combat

    Square Enix has released its latest Orience News video for Final Fantasy Type-0 HD, and it provides insight into character combat styles and techniques. In the video you will see the elite combat force of Class Zero going deeper into battle to improve their skills. Combat is party-based and each of the three characters in […]

  • Something really cool happens when you finish Resident Evil HD *spoiler*

    Those who finish Resident Evil HD will be met with a really nice surprise at the end. If you wish to find out what it is on your own, DO NOT head below the break. You have been warned. According to images posted by Reddit user omeganemesis28, a thank you message from Resident Evil creator […]

  • Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain release date “should be” announced soon

    A release date for Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain “should be able” to be announced soon, according to the latest Kojima Station webcast. New information on the game will also be announced at the Taipei Game Show on January 31, per Game Spark (thanks, Gemtasu). “I know you’ve all been eagerly await for […]

  • Punch-Out!!, more Throwback offerings arrive on Nintendo US eShop

    Nintendo has updated the North American end of the eShop with Punch-Out!!, Citizens of Earth and Part Two of the Throwback Sale. Here’s the entire update: Nintendo eShop releases Punch-Out!! (originally for Wii) – also 50% off until January 29 Citizens of Earth – introductory price of $11.99 until January 27 Breezeblox (Wii) Midnight (Wii […]

  • The Witcher Battle Arena has arrived on the App Store and Google Play

    The Witcher Battle Arena, CD Projekt RED and Fuero Games’ mobile MOBA, has been released. In Battle Arena, two three-hero teams fight it out as they try to capture and hold conquest points. The game features “no pay-to-win elements”, instead it contains a “player-friendly monetization system.” Every item and functionality can be unlocked entirely through […]

  • Second wave of Star Wars titles arrive on GOG, third wave next week

    The second wave of Star Wars titles will arrive on GOG.com today with more coming January 27. Today you can pick up the following: Star Wars: Rogue Squadron 3D (digital distribution premiere) Star Wars Rebellion (digital distribution premiere) Star Wars Empire at War: Gold Pack On January 27, the final three games of this wave […]

  • If Microsoft is serious about PC games, Xbox One should be the real Steam Machine

    Forget the magic space goggles. Maybe Valve doesn’t have the wherewithal to realise PC gaming’s TV dream, but Microsoft holds all the keys. If Microsoft really wants to get into PC gaming full-time, it needs to get around the table with Mr Newell and its platinum chequebook. “It’s time for us to talk about gaming […]

  • Hyperdimension Neptunia Re;Birth 1 releases on Steam next week

    Hyperdimension Neptunia Re;Birth 1 will be released on Steam for PC next week. The PC version of the was announced earlier this month and contains upgraded graphics, runs in 1080p, and has both Japanese and English audio. It will release on January 28 for $14.99. Fairy Fencer F and Hyperdimension Neptunia Re;Birth 2 also coming […]

  • Take a look at the controls and special abilities in The Order: 1886

    The Order: 1886 has a new trailer available that highlights the game’s controls and reveals the two special abilities the main protagonist has at his disposal. The game uses a similar control scheme to other shooters, but just in case you wanted to see more gameplay, we’ve got just the thing. The most interesting parts […]

  • These elderly people are better at GTA 5 than you’d expect

    Do old people get video games? Namely something known for its violence like GTA? Well, you’re about to find out. The latest REACT production sits a few elderly men and women in a room and lets them play GTA 5. The results are not what you’d expect, they start off getting a feel for the […]

  • More major Microsoft titles will be coming to PC

    Microsoft will bring more of its franchises to PC. Following on from yesterday’s big Windows stream, Microsoft has released a full recap on Xbox Wire. In the blog post, the firm hid a small bit of news revealing that Fable Legends will not be the only title to come to PC. “Today we announced that […]

  • Someone is attempting to recreate Dark Souls’ Lordran in Minecraft

    Lordran, the land of the ancient lords will soon be explorable in Minecraft thanks to a passionate modder. Davweed is a talented modder attempting to recreate the entire world of Lordran in Minecraft. Lordran is the land where the entire Dark Souls game is set. The goal is to make it a 1:1 scale of […]

  • Elite: Dangerous is getting Community Goals with update 1.1 – all the details

    Patch 1.1 is Elite: Dangerous’ first major update. Developer Frontier has detailed Community Goals, the big change coming with the patch, and more. We were told last week that big additions are coming with patch 1.1, due in February. Today, we learn in more detail what those features are. Namely, what the developer is calling […]

  • Sunset Overdrive, Skyrim and Dead Rising 3 highlight this week’s Deals with Gold

    A new week, a new set of deals for Xbox Live Gold subscribers and we’ve got the full list. Major Nelson posted the deals which are live now and run through Monday, January 26. Highlights include Sunset Overdrive, Dead Rising 3, Skyrim, Final Fantasy 13-2 and more. Check the full list below. Xbox One Dead […]

  • Survarium: 10,000 FREE Premium account keys to give away

    We have 10,000 codes to give away for MMOFPS Survarium, granting the player a Premium account for 24 hours along with 5,000 Silver coins. Each key gives the player a Premium account for 24 hours along with 5,000 Silver in-game currency. A Premium account gives you 50 percent more experience, income and reputation for 24 […]

  • “I don’t like people thinking we’re doing underhanded, dirty shit,” says Evolve dev

    Despite what it looks like, Evolve developers did not intend to give out the wrong signals when it comes to the game’s DLC plan. Evolve creative director Phil Robb spoke to Destructoid in an interview that was conducted late last year about the studio’s approach to DLC, map packs and more. Robb’s idea is that […]

  • Clock Tower spiritual successor Night Cry gets first screens

    Night Cry is coming along nicely and today we get our first look at it. Ever since the announcement of Project Scissors (at the time) last September, and then the name change to Night Cry, we’ve been waiting to see what the game looks like, especially since it’s developed with mobile platforms in mind. Today, […]

  • Tekken X Street Fighter is still happening, 40 people working on it

    Tekken X Street Fighter is definitely not vaporware. A team of 40 developers is currently working on it, according to director Katushiro Harada. Harada was interviewed by Polygon. In the interview, he touched on many topics, one of which is the status of the seemingly-never-coming-out Tekken X Street Fighter. “It’s very difficult to talk about,” […]

  • From Game of Thrones to Borderlands: all of Telltale’s adventure games rated

    Telltale Games has an impressive back catalogue of licensed adventure games to its name, and we have opinions about all of them. Note that this rundown doesn’t include bundles, the non-adventure games or games published by Telltale but created by other developers. It’s also got a fair bit of speculation in it, since at least […]

  • There is probably a new Battletoads game coming

    If you’ve watched last night’s Windows presentation you knew you recognised that logo on Phil Spencer’s t-shirt. Wearing a t-shirt with a logo of an upcoming game is an antic we’ve come to expect from Xbox boss Phil Spencer now. Based on that, we wouldn’t be alone in predicting that a new Battletoads game is […]

  • Here’s a short, 60fps trailer for DmC: Definitive Edition

    DmC: Definitive Edition has a new video available that shows the game running at 60 frames-per-second. Capcom has put out a short new trailer for the Definitive Edition of DmC: Devil May Cry that takes a look at different stages and boss fights. The video begs to watched in 1080p60 quality, if your connection can […]

  • Xbox One to PC streaming targeting 1080p, 60fps

    Microsoft has revealed that it’s looking to achieve 1080p resolution at 60 frames-per-second when the Xbox One game streaming launches later this year. The question of what final resolution and framerate Xbox One game streaming will operate at was on a lot of people’s minds when the demo was shown. Thankfully, Microsoft’s Mike Ybarra has […]

  • Microsoft is looking at offering PC to Xbox streaming

    Having announced Xbox One to PC streaming as part of its Windows event last night, Microsoft said that making the process a two-way street is on the cards. Microsoft’s Phil Spencer sat down to do a group interview following the Windows event and talked a little bit about the firm’s plans for streaming, including a […]

  • Watch John Romero play Doom

    John Romero made DOOM, and now you can watch him play it, dropping many a delightful gem of insight regarding one of the most important shooters of all time. This video was organised by Double Fine as part of its Devs Play series, a thing I only just discovered and now want to marathon all […]

  • World of Speed has gotten fairly pretty over the past year

    World of Speed has produced a new trailer, showing off the racing MMO’s progress over the past year. Announced one year ago, World of Speed is looking pretty damn shiny now. Check it out in this trailer, which introduces the Mountain Spiral Road location and teases several yet to be revealed. World of Speed comes […]

  • Minecraft user data leaked in plain text – change your passwords

    Minecraft users should change their passwords and those of any accounts using the same log-in details. Minecraft’s user data servers have apparently been compromised, with user names and passwords leaked online in plain text. 1,800 Mojang accounts were affected. The news comes via German source Heise and The Guardian and has been treated quite seriously […]

  • Resident Evil: The Final Chapter will commence filming in August

    The sixth Resident Evil movie is back on track. Resident Evil: The Final Chapter will begin filming in August, having been delayed to accomodate star Milla Jovovich’s pregnancy. In a Facebook post, Jovovich said she’s currently being very mindful of gaining enough weight to ensure a healthy birth for her second child, without the risk […]

  • Nintendo bosses “do not really understand modern gaming”, says former executive

    Former Nintendo executive Dan Adelman has provided frank insight into the Japanese platform holder’s inner workings. Adelman, who was one of Nintendo’s most important developer liaisons, left in August 2014. One of the first things he did was say that Nintendo had issued a gag order on his social media use, and shortly thereafter called […]