Sections

E3 2014: Were the press conferences any good? Did Sony beat Microsoft? Expert opinion here

Tuesday, 10th June 2014 20:29 GMT By Patrick Garratt

The dust’s settling on the E3 press conferences. Find out what our writers thought of the showings from Microsoft, Sony, EA and Ubisoft.

fifa_15_header

Who won? The best opinion on the E3 2014 press conferences from the VG247 team. Read and profit.

And make sure you’re caught up on our extensive press conference reports.

Breaking news

35 Comments

Sign in to post a comment.

  1. Joe Musashi

    This is the sort of event that a poll would make a lot of sense for. ;)

    Ubisoft won for themselves. They get their games into MS and Sony’s conferences plust have a conference all to themselves.

    Nintendo’s compact presentation was the best format. The ‘and we have one more thing to show you‘ didn’t really compare to MS’s Crackdown or Sony’s Uncharted 4.

    Game of the conferences: No Man’s Sky.
    Surprise of the conferences: Splatoon.
    Best presenter: Aisha Tyler. Slick, professional, knows how to handle a golf-clap.

    All of the above is fact, not opinion. Just so you know.

    JM

    #1 1 month ago
  2. DirtEHarry

    Promoting those tendentious articles of Mr. Martin doesn’t make them better.

    #2 1 month ago
  3. psxman

    Came expecting “Expert opinion”…

    #3 1 month ago
  4. Legendaryboss

    @psxman Me too, would have been Pat saying fuck you too Matt. Brenna and Dave my opinion is better than yours.

    #4 1 month ago
  5. Legendaryboss

    Poor Steph, she is left out of the team :(

    #5 1 month ago
  6. OmegaSlayer

    Nintendo was the one who pleased their fans most.
    Period.
    Rest was between the meh and the average.

    #6 1 month ago
  7. Untold stories

    I say Nintendo

    #7 1 month ago
  8. Stephany Nunneley

    @Legendaryboss I am too nice to have a solid opinion. :) I’d be like: “yay! good job everyone!” That’s why. HAHA!

    #8 1 month ago
  9. Legendaryboss

    @Stephany Nunneley Fair enough ;)

    #9 1 month ago
  10. polygem

    “Surprise of the conferences: Splatoon.”

    Unfortunately this game must have been only a dream…

    “Nintendo don’t have the infrastructure or tools to support a game of this type. The’ll do MMOs before they do competitive MP TPS. Not that they’re moving in the direction to do either venture.
    Not. Gonna. Happen.”

    JM

    opinions, facts, opinions, it can get cofusing

    #10 1 month ago
  11. A Zombie Riot

    How I would rank all of the press conferences/events that took place…

    Microsoft/Nintendo – Simply for having the focus of games. And they both showed off a lot. Learning more about SSB for Wii U and 3DS was great. The Legend of Zelda for Wii U was fantastic. Microsoft announcing Crackdown at the end was a huge nice surprise, and we got to see Fable Legends finally.
    Ubisoft – Started off showing the first 5 minutes of Far Cry 4… which escalated quickly, lol. Showed off more games we knew about and then ended with the surprise Rainbow Six Siege. Fantastic ending!
    Sony – No Man’s Sky looks great and it looks like the company didn’t lose much (or anything, really) from their flood. Great! Hearing the news of GTA V coming to nex-gen platforms finally was a nice surprise… but that was really it for me. The Order looked good and Bloodborn looks promising but there really wasn’t much else there for me.
    EA – Started off with SW: Battlefront and holy crap does that game look beautiful. Then Mirror’s Edge, The Sims 4 and Battlefield: Hardline… the rest was mostly sports games or Bioware’s games… and while Dragon Age was shown off quite a bit… Mass Effect was only a tease and same with their new IP. I figured we would’ve gotten more of ME at this point. Also, WTF at their golf game! Why is Battlefield 4 invading golf??!?!!? ;)

    Overall, it was still fantastic and I’m glad we got to see the amount of games we did!

    #11 1 month ago
  12. ManuOtaku

    For me are were equally good, this is the first time that all 3 came on the same level.
    But considering past events, for how bad they were, i was surprised with nintendo and microsoft, they exceeded my expectations, while sony did came short, because my expectations were higher due the quality of their pasts events.

    overall A great E3 for all gamers regardless of personal allegiance.

    #12 1 month ago
  13. Legendaryboss

    @10
    Complains about “shit stirring”, proceeds to “shit stir.” You’ve likely turned this thread into something else.

    #13 1 month ago
  14. polygem

    @Legendaryboss:
    funny that you complain now but not….oh, forget it, nevermind.

    #14 1 month ago
  15. Legendaryboss

    @14
    An acknowledgement is not complaining.

    #15 1 month ago
  16. polygem

    teling joe that he was wrong is not shit stirring

    #16 1 month ago
  17. polygem

    telling joe that he was wrong is not shit stirring

    #17 1 month ago
  18. Legendaryboss

    Whatevs.

    #18 1 month ago
  19. polygem

    @Legendaryboss

    “Interesting”

    Legendaryboss

    #19 1 month ago
  20. kingy

    Nintendo gave me a reason to buy a wii u (zelda) .Sony made me feel better about buying a ps4 and Microsoft have still left me thinking about a Xbox one that’s about it for me

    #20 1 month ago
  21. polygem

    this was the initial shit spark btw lb.
    “All of the above is fact, not opinion. Just so you know.”
    you know the posting history. you can read and decipher that reference. it´s not that hard really.
    you just don´t want to. or you really can´t but that would be worrying.

    #21 1 month ago
  22. Legendaryboss

    Hmmm you didn’t understand my post, making assumptions on my behalf and @19
    Da fuck! Since you can never get any my posts accurately, it just isn’t worth explaining.

    #22 1 month ago
  23. Joe Musashi

    Easy there, child. Your hypocrisy is showing. Again.

    And, at this point there is zero detail on how it will work as an online mp game or how you’re going to coordinate team-play without standard functionality like team chat. Tapping a second screen to teleport to someone’s location is not a substitute for the absence of years old standard functionality used by everyone else. Compare it to the spoken coordination of the Rainbow 6 or BF Hardline demos.

    My objective point concerning lack of infrastructure is amply demonstrated by Nintendo in light of what those other two examples show. And there are many more examples.

    Remember: your OPINION on lack of standard functionality doesn’t alter the FACT it is still lacking. Petulant point scoring, childish sulking and blatant hypocrisy do not seem to be altering those facts either.

    JM

    #23 1 month ago
  24. Brenna Hillier

    I love it when threads devolve into meta-arguments about who is meaningfully engaging with the topic and who is just having fights.

    Wait, not love. The other one. The one where I get out the ban hammer. Desist.

    #24 1 month ago
  25. NocturnalB

    There was no clear winner for me, but that’s because I was digging games from everybody’s conference this year. I’m just so bummed that we have to wait till next year for a lot of them! No Man’s Sky is looking awesome, and I can’t friggin WAIT to play Batman. And I’m really happy that The Order has finally shown a little more of what bad guys you’ll be facing, that monster in the trailer definitely made it more compelling for me.

    So many goods delivered man. My wallet’s already aching. Also I’m on the same gush fest that Pat is having over the new GTA 5 ports.

    #25 1 month ago
  26. OlderGamer

    I think nintendo.

    Period.

    #26 1 month ago
  27. Nintendo1985

    Experts? Lol, no no, more like Sony fanboys.
    http://www.destructoid.com/fact-ps3-fanboys-are-the-worst-149259.phtml

    #27 1 month ago
  28. Gheritt White

    • Game of the Conference: Sunset Overdrive (runner up: Mirror’s Edge 2)
    • Surprise of the Conference: Phantom Dust (runner up: No Man’s Sky)

    #28 1 month ago
  29. polygem

    yes brenna, ban hammer please! i would say joe and me deserve it. we´ve both been nasty.

    @Joe:
    “The’ll do MMOs before they do competitive MP TPS. Not that they’re moving in the direction to do either venture.”
    JM

    #29 1 month ago
  30. polygem

    @joe

    http://www.vg247.com/forum/topic/mario-sunshine-themed-watergun-mp-tps/

    i want to only see you once, just once (once), discuss things with some good will, a joe willing to take a step back when appropriate.

    once you´ll be able to manage that and maybe will even be able to stop hiding one or two sideblows in every post,..you have become a true ninjii (cuz they got honor).

    off for some short holidays now. will prolly derail this again later. with a great tan.

    show-wise:

    nintendo

    the rest was embarrassing in style and presentation. an industry making a caricature out of itself,

    there have been a few good looking games though like ori, no man´s sky, the new from game.

    most of the stuff shown was hugely disappointing though and it mainly showed an industry that has lost the passion for games. it probably needs another crash at this point.

    #30 1 month ago
  31. ChristopherJack

    Sony
    1. Entwined
    2. Driveclub
    3. LBP3
    4. Hotline Miami: Wrong Number
    5. Broforce
    6. Titan Souls
    7. Not a Hero
    8. The Talos Principle
    9. Bloodborne
    10. Abzu
    11. The Last of Us- Remastered
    12. The Order : 1886
    13. Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End
    14. Magicka 2
    15. Grim Fandango- Remastered
    16. Let it Die
    17. No Man’s Sky
    18. Ratchet & Clank- Remastered
    19. InFamous: First Light- Standalone DLC

    Sony get early/exclusive Betas/features/content &/or for Destiny, Battlefield Hardline, GTA V, Far Cry 4, Dead Island 2, Disney Infinity, Mortal Kombat X, MGS 5: The Phantom Pain & Batman: Arkham Knight.

    Microsoft
    1. Forza Horizon 2
    2. Disney Fantasia: Music Evolved
    3. Sunset Overdrive
    4. Halo: Master Chief Collection
    5. Dance Central Spotlight
    6. Ori & the Blind forest
    7. Inside
    8. Halo 5: Guardians
    9. Crackdown
    10. Fable Legends
    11. Scalebound
    12. Phantom Dust
    Microsoft get first dibs on DLC from: Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare, Assassin’s Creed: Unity, The Division, Dragon Age: Inquisition and Evolve.

    Now quality is subjective but I’ve gotta give it to Sony since Halo now bores me. Not only do Sony have the better current library(subjective again but they have well over twice as many games that you can play on PS4 that you can’t play on XB1), you also know they have a lot they didn’t show today, games like Deep Down that have already been announced & those that we know Sony still have to unveil, not to mention Sony always saves something for TGS & Gamescom.

    #31 1 month ago
  32. lubu

    “Expert opinion here”
    oh please

    #32 1 month ago
  33. Joe Musashi

    @31 “..you also know they have a lot they didn’t show today, games like Deep Down that have already been announced & those that we know Sony still have to unveil, not to mention Sony always saves something for TGS & Gamescom.”

    Whilst I can see where you’re coming from, I think it’s a little unfair to give credit to a certain conference where you refer to things that weren’t shown or may be shown at another venue altogether.

    The same could be true for Microsoft. Did we see what Black Tusk or Rare or other MS studios were doing? Given recent Microsoft comments on Rare’s freedom of options, it could be a big surprise or add diversity to the Xbox portfolio. Stuff we know about wasn’t shown (ie Quantum Break) so shouldn’t MS be earning credit for that if appraisals are to be fair?

    I’m just playing devil’s advocate, of course – you openly declare subjectivity after all. ;)

    JM

    #33 1 month ago
  34. OmegaSlayer

    @Nintendo1985 Jim Sterling, which is a total idiot with fat even in his brain, wrote that in 2009…
    Has the world stopped there for you, mr. Nintendo?

    #34 1 month ago
  35. Seventizz

    Anyone with a brain (that’s not wrapped up in stupid blind fanboyism) can see Microsoft stole the show. Sony’s show was boring and too long, Nintendo is well, Nintendo, and Microsoft delivered a stellar lineup with what they promised – games.

    #35 1 month ago