Sections

The grim inevitability of hacking: any fool can throw rocks

Friday, 3 January 2014 11:14 GMT By Matt Martin

Steam is down. Origin is down. League of Legends is down. Battle.net is down. Happy New Year.

Hackers took down the biggest gaming services on the internet this morning. Valve’s Steam was hit, as was EA’s Origin, Blizzard’s Battle.net and Riot’s League of Legends. A small group, upset that a professional player was streaming gameplay and hoping to make some money from it, was apparently responsible, and even went so far as to cause him to be arrested by armed police.

Luckily, you don’t have to suffer getting a gun pointed at your head, but you still have to face the grim inevitability of your favourite gaming service being hacked, of hitting refresh and staring at you own pudgy reflection in the blank screen. It’s another depressing brick in the wall of online gaming. There’s not much you can do but wait it out. It might last an hour. It might last a month.

Gamers are at the mercy of hackers and they must surely love it. Whether the result of personal vendettas or clumsy politics, we all feel the pain of their bludgeoning attacks. They don’t speak for me and I doubt they speak for you. I just want to play my game, but some asshole has it in a stranglehold, has wrestled it to the floor and is repeatedly DDoSing it in the face. It’s as frustrating for the game-makers as it is for the players, but it’s easy to lose sight of that and just shout at someone, anyone, to fix the fucking thing.

It’s not true anarchy or revolution or politics. It’s throwing rocks for the sake of fucking shit up.

According to today’s reports, all of this morning’s attacks could be thanks to a hacker group, these self-righteous internet vigilantes, being upset with just one person. In truth, it doesn’t matter. They may be annoyed with one corporation, or one game, or the whole world and everyone in it. There is no real justification for hacking a video game, sending a SWAT team to someone’s house, or prank calling a person because they tried to make some money off game streaming. Pranks? What are you, Dennis the Menace?

These gamers who are trying to turn their hobby into a living are entrepreneurial, thinking creatively and doing what we’re all trying to do: turn a job into a fun way of living. They’re not any of the real villains. They’re not the NSA or MI5 or News Corp. They’re not running for president. They didn’t shoot a Kennedy.

These kids attacking games with their mad script skillz are throwing stones. I doubt they fully understand what they’re doing. They may scratch a car or put a window through. They may crack a skull. They may miss completely. Does it take skill and knowledge to bring down a service like Steam? It does, but we don’t have to admire it. It’s not true anarchy or revolution or politics. It’s throwing rocks for the sake of fucking shit up, and damn the consequences. It’s Early Man thumping a car engine because he’s mad at the weather. It makes no sense.

That we just have to accept it is depressing. We can’t ignore it because it’s in our faces, everyone’s fun spoilt. It’s an insult. But what’s the solution? There isn’t one. Security gets beefed up but new attacks will come. It’s a never-ending battle, Sysphus pushing the boulder up the hill. It’s just a shame these latest pests aren’t in the path as it rolls back down to crush them like the cockroaches they are.

I’d like to pitch a solution but I can’t. It doesn’t matter if you think Steam is a monopoly, or Origin is heavy with the ban hammer, or Battle.net’s customisation options suck, or League of Legends is full of player abuse. These are problems that can be solved over time. It doesn’t look like hacking and DDoSing in games (or cracking, or whatever you want to call it this week) will ever disappear. But we have to stand up to the bullies for the mess and mockery they make. We have to soldier on, condemning the idiots and banding together to support the services we use and love.

Latest

  • Dota 2 International Compendium out next week, three annual championships added

    Valve has announced its adding three, yearly Dota 2 championships to its eSports roster along with the new that a new International Compendium will launch next week alongside a balance update for MOBA. The firm said it was adding three extra championships to the schedule as it recognized there was “room for improvement” on a […]

  • Dungeons 2 is now available on PC, Mac, Linux – watch the launch trailer

    Dungeons 2, the dungeon-crawling strategy sequel to Realmforge Studios’ Dungeons, has been released on Steam by publisher Kalypso. It can be yours for $39.99 on Steam and is available for Windows, Linux, Mac and SteamOS. The first game was released in 2011 and heavily influenced by Dungeon Keeper. A boxed version will arrive in North […]

  • This Mortal Kombat X “hidden character intros” video is rather humorous

    YouTuber Maximilian Dood mad has created a Mortal Kombat X video featuring “hidden” character intros centering around Scorpion and Sub-Zero. Some of the dialogue is rather funny, and we particularly liked the affectionate line uttered by Sub-Zero at one point. Just something fun for your Saturday. Enjoy.

  • Art of the Catch creator sheds more light on why he pulled the Skyrim mod off Steam

    The creator of Skyrim mod Art of the Catch has taken to Reddit to explain why he pulled the paid mod off Steam Workshop. Yesterday, it was revealed Chesko had pulled the fishing mod off Steam Workshop, after mod creator Fore stated he didn’t endorse Chesko charging for the mod because it used his his […]

  • Tripwire adds clause to Killing Floor 2 EULA banning paid mods

    Tripwire Interactive has updated its EULA for Killing Floor 2 stating that any mods players create for the game must be distributed free-of-charge. The end user agreement update, via PCgamesN, went live a couple of days after Valve announced it would allow mod creators to start charging for their creations. Bethesda is the first company […]

  • Five Nights at Freddy’s 3 recreated in LittleBigPlanet 3 is rather eerie

    LittleBigPlanet 3 players have created some really interesting content with the game’s level builder, but sometimes, the creations go beyond cute and bright and venture into the realm of creepy, as is the case with this Five Nights at Freddy’s 3 build. Created by TheLittleBigPlanetShow, the rather ominous level can be played with up to […]

  • Final Fantasy 14: Heavensward benchmark trailer shows off flying mounts, more

    Square Enix has released a rather nice benchmark video for Final Fantasy 14: Heavensward showing a battle, flying mounts and some of the new environments. Heavensward is the first expansion for Final Fantasy 14 and is slated for release on June 23 for PC, PlayStation 3 and PS4. The mac version is being handled by […]

  • Have a look at some Xenoblade Chronicles X gameplay

    During yesterday’s Xenoblade Chronicles X Nintendo Direct showcase, many details pertaining to the Monolith Soft title were announced, and quite a bit of gameplay was shown. The Wii U-exclusive contains real-time menu-based combat and four-player online questing along with diverse environments and the ability to use Skells, which are transforming mechs. These mechs are called […]

  • Here’s a look at The Elder Scrolls Online running on Xbox One

    The Elder Scrolls Online has a limited public beta test running this weekend on PS4 and Xbox One, and Eurogamer has been playing around in it. Have a look at the Khajiit sorcerer below in the Xbox One version. There isn’t an NDA in place for the beta, so expect to see more videos as […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 leaks reveal Zombie progression system, four-player co-op, more

    More Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 details surfaced overnight thanks to a leaked pamphlet with information pertaining to Zombies XP progression, four-player co-op and more. Posted on NeoGAF, the pamphlet the shooter will contain a new movement system, a Specialist character system for multiplayer, tailored maps, “cinematic arena-style play,” and complete character customization. The […]

  • Gears of War Remaster in the works for Xbox One, according to testers – report

    Overnight, a rumor surfaced claiming a remastered version of the original Gears of War was coming to Xbox One. According to playtesters, it isn’t a rumor at all. Polygon first broke the story, citing a source who showed the site sreencaps of the Locust invasion with updated visuals. Screenshots of the multiplayer showing improved lighting […]

  • GameStop promo outs Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 for November, pre-order for access to beta

    Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 will be released in November, according to what appears to be a leaked GameStop store promo posted on Kotaku. The exact date is November 6, which isn’t a surprise to anyone. On the promo, it notes that those who pre-order will be granted beta access for PC, PlayStation 4 […]

  • Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare Double XP and Elite Bonus weekend has kicked off

    Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare players can earn Double XP along with Elite Bonus on all platforms. There is even Double XP and Double Weapon XP on offer for Black Ops 2. The dry run is over. Prep for the Sunday reveal of #BlackOps3 begins now. 2XP/2XweapXP is live. pic.twitter.com/rn6SVtVJbY — Treyarch Studios (@Treyarch) April […]

  • Atlus makes “minor edits” to Dungeon Travelers 2 in order to avoid AO rating

    Atlus has announced it has made “minor edits” to four in-game images contained in Dungeon Travelers 2 to avoid an AO rating by the ESRB. According to a press release from the company, localization sometimes require changes to content in order for it to be “understood en masse,” which is why it worked closely with […]

  • Battlefield Hardline is 40% off through Origin this weekend

    The standard edition of Battlefield Hardline on PC is 40% off this weekend through EA’s Origin service. The Digital Deluxe Edition is also 40% off and includes various Battlepacks unavailable in the standard version. You can also pick up the Battlefield Hardline Ultimate edition for 23% off, which comes with all four planned expansions through […]

  • Submerged is an exploration-adventure game coming to multiple platforms

    Submerged is the latest title in development from Uppercut Games, and the exploration-adventure game is coming to PlayStation 4 and other platforms this year. The game takes place in a flooded city which Miku and her wounded brother Taku have reached by boat. Miku needs to find a safe place for her brother to rest […]

  • These screenshots for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt show superb attention to detail

    Some gorgeous new screenshots for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt have surfaced, and a couple are wallpaper worthy. Especially the one with the horse, but as you’re well aware, I’m horse crazed. The images below in the gallery have been scaled to fit properly, but if you head over to NeoGAF you can bask in […]

  • Namco kicks off Humble Store partnership with Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin

    Namco Bandai has started offering its PC titles on Humble Store, and this includes the recently released Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin. Other titles include Dragon Ball Xenoverse, and Project Cars. “In Japan, the Bandai Namco Group companies are known for supporting different charity programs and we are very happy to be […]

  • World of Tanks: 2,000 Bonus codes to give away

    Already have a World of Tanks account? We’ve got 2,000 codes for players to top up their Gold and Premium days. This weekend sees the World of Tanks Grand Finals take place in Poland, and we’ve got a bunch of game codes to give away to celebrate. Each Bonus PC code offers 150 Gold and […]

  • Mad Max contains Top Dog camps with boss fights

    Mad Max will have bases which vary in difficulty, some of which are considered a “finale” for a particular region and feature a boss fight. Speaking in the latest issue of GamesMaster via GamesRadar, the game’s producer John Fuller said this allows players to tailor their experience by deciding how much of a challenge they […]

  • Just Cause 3 gameplay trailer reveal coming next week

    Mark your calendars for Tuesday, April 28, because you won’t want to miss the gameplay reveal of Just Cause 3. Avalanche tweeted the date along with a teaser, as seen below. The box art has also made an appearance. Keep an eye on the game’s YouTube page, and we’ll be sure to post the video […]

  • First paid Skyrim Steam Workshop mod has been pulled

    Valve’s new incentive which allows modders to charge for their creations hasn’t been live for 24 hours yet, and already, one mod has been pulled. The mod in question was Chesko’s Fishing Mod for Skyrim, which the creator pulled after a community member questioned whether Chesko had permission from the creator of the character-idle animations […]

  • Resident Evil HD Remaster has sold over one million copies worldwide

    The HD remaster of Resident Evil has sold over one million copies worldwide since its January 20 release, Capcom has announced. The company attributed the sales milestone to producing a “great product” along with excellent word of mouth and praise from fans. In February, Capcom said Resident Evil HD Remaster was its fastest-selling digital title […]

  • The Crew: the Raid Car Pack and Raid Live Update now available for download

    The Crew players can now download the Raid Car Pack which is the last of four themes car packs. The Raid Live Update is also available, and it contains six new tuning specs. The car pack contains three new cars: the 2012 Cadillac Escalade, the off-road 2011 Volkswagen Touareg NF and the McLaren F1 supercar. […]

  • Geralt is very professional in the latest Witcher 3: Wild Hunt TV spot

    The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt has a new TV spot that’s short and to the point. The latest Witcher 3 trailer comes in the form of TV spot. It’s all CGI, and it looks good. If you’re more into gameplay trailers, the latest one will serve you well. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is out […]

  • Steam roguelike sale is live, offers deep discounts on a stellar collection of titles

    If you’re into challenging, procedurally-generated, and infinitely-replayable games, Steam’s current sale will hook you up. Steam is hosting a sale on roguelike games. Plenty of titles in the genre are on sale for upwards of 75% off. Highlights include Risk of Rain at 75% off, Don’t Starve at 66% off, Spelunky at 75% off, FTL: […]

  • Resident Evil: Revelations 2 finally gets online co-op in Raid Mode on Xbox One

    Resident Evil: Revelations 2 has been patched to support online play in Raid Mode on Xbox One. The Xbox One version of Resident Evil: Revelations 2 lacked online support in Raid Mode for a long time. Until today. A new patch has been released to bring that version in line with the rest of them. […]

  • A section in Killing Floor 2′s EULA about cyberbullying is riling up some fans

    Killing Floor 2 has recently got into a bit of trouble with some fans due to a clause in its EULA that gives the developer the right to revoke a user’s license without prior notice. The Killing Floor 2 EULA – just like many others found in modern games, has a section dedicated to cheating […]

  • World of Tanks: 2,000 free tanks and in-game cash to giveaway

    To celebrate the World of Tanks grand finals this weekend we’ve got some great freebies to give away to new players. We have 2,000 PC invite codes to giveaway, with each one offering new accounts a T2 Light Tank, 100 Gold and 1 Days Premium worth around €8.00. All you need to do is enter […]

  • Marvel announces partnership with Telltale, first game due in 2017

    Marvel and Telltale have entered into a partnership that will allow the developer to work on a new game series, due in 2017. Telltale has announced that it has partnered with Marvel Games, Marvel Entertainment’s video games division, for the development of a new game series. No indication was given as to what the new […]

73 Comments

  1. tenthousandgothsonacid

    “staring at you own pudgy reflection in the blank screen”

    Newsflash ! New editor calls all readers fat ! :)

    #1 1 year ago
  2. Patrick Garratt

    :D

    #2 1 year ago
  3. absolutezero

    Lets be honest here DDoS is hardly hacking, its stupidly easy to do and sites need a better defense against it. Whether thats something like a third party site like Skyfire or increased host communication.

    Script kiddies are stupid, drunk off of their own sense of importance and power over things that most people use as entertainment or time wasting. They seem to think that shutting down youtube for a couple of hours is a worthwhile endeavor. Its bizarre.

    I also play Tearaway in the dark so I don’t have to see my hideous mush peering into the World like some satanic Teletubbies Sun Baby.

    #3 1 year ago
  4. Faceless

    I think articles like these are giving the attackers what they want, or at the very least providing them with rife amusement. Not to mention it’s essentially advertising them, i.e. those who want to see more of this happening can call out to them.

    It is rather depressing that there is no solution, yes, but such articles are not it either. “Standing up” to bullies will at most resulting in attracting their attention and have them DDoS your website, too. Neither is publicly cursing at them “standing up”. It’s like waving your fist at their back.

    The best way to battle them is to raise awareness, in the hopes that one day their “fame” will attract authorities.

    #4 1 year ago
  5. SplatteredHouse

    “I think articles like these are giving the attackers what they want”

    “The best way to battle them is to raise awareness”

    Sorry? Anyway, I think this is a very good type of article. A bit of perspective most welcome.

    #5 1 year ago
  6. Faceless

    @5 Giving them prolonged spotlight and covering contemporary events are two vastly different things, I figured. Especially when this article is seething with passive aggression, rather than constructive thought.

    #6 1 year ago
  7. tenthousandgothsonacid

    @3 The Satanic Sun Babies is quite a good band name

    #7 1 year ago
  8. SplatteredHouse

    @6 Articles are written to an audience. Nothing in the article suggests the author is addressing the instigators.

    #8 1 year ago
  9. wickedcricket

    ummm who is this guy?

    @4 I totally agree!

    “..but you still have to face the grim inevitability of your favourite gaming service being hacked” – oh great another idiot who can’t tell a difference between a hacker and a cracker…

    “I’d like to pitch a solution but I can’t.” – then shout your filthy mouth ffs and leave it to professionals that are trying to fix the issue, glorifying criminals won’t make any difference here.

    I hate journalists that are trying to force through awareness to people that are already aware, so “shut your face Matt”.

    What do you think it is? IGN.com?

    #9 1 year ago
  10. Faceless

    @8 “They may be annoyed with one corporation, or one game, or the whole world and everyone in it. There is no real justification for hacking a video game, sending a SWAT team to someone’s house, or prank calling a person because they tried to make some money off game streaming. Pranks? What are you, Dennis the Menace?

    That aside, I wasn’t making the claim regarding who his addressees were. I was saying it’s giving them undeserved exposure while amusing them with impotent rage.

    #10 1 year ago
  11. Talkar

    @9
    Chill dude, if you disagree simply say so, no need to be a dick about it.
    Also, there is no rule defining that black hatters have to be called crackers. Only, the white hatters as a group takes distance from the term, while black hatters don’t, which mean black hatters can be called both hackers and crackers. They mean the same thing in that case.

    #11 1 year ago
  12. Dragon

    Just to clarify to any uninitiated, its just DDoS, no loss of any personal data these corporations had.

    #12 1 year ago
  13. Gekidami

    So this time the hackers arent heroes? Sorry, the goal posts move a bit to fast for me.

    #13 1 year ago
  14. Dave Cook

    @9 you mad bro?

    #14 1 year ago
  15. OlderGamer

    “But we have to stand up to the bullies for the mess and mockery they make.”

    Would that be the hackers or the corp. suits that force unfair, one sided forms of DRM down our throats with aim of maintaining control over our gaming? Because to be honest every time one of these mega million dollar “services” go down for a bit, part of me deep down smiles. Sure it can be a bit inconvenient, but hitting these goons in their wallets is the only thing they understand.

    If you look at the gaming industry with any level scope, it can be tough to separate the good guys from the bad.

    #15 1 year ago
  16. Dragon

    ^ Then dont buy their games. No one is forcing you too. Or do you enjoy people losing jobs?

    This internet company hate mentality is exactly what breeds these crackers.

    #16 1 year ago
  17. YoungZer0

    The kids are douchebags, no question about that, but I still find it incredibly pathetic that such huge corporations can be attacked this easily. It’s our games and money on the line here.

    #17 1 year ago
  18. OlderGamer

    I don’t think so Dragon. I think instances like this just point out the folly of always online structures. It highlights the fact that increasingly we don’t have any type of ownership over our game library. While the liscencing laws have always maintained that we never “Owned” a game, the fact remains that I can still(anytime I want) play my Retro systems. From Atari2600 to Stuff I own on Disc today. But I think as corp. control tightens going forward we will lose that ability. Even in the console space. We lost digital purchases made on Xbox(Orig), and we all stand to lose a lot more content once MS/Sony retire xb360/PS3.

    That is the crux of it for me.

    That being said, I am mainly a Steam gamer. And I play on PC more then anything else. I am not cutting my nose off to spite my face so to speak. Steam is back up and working fine at my end, btw. It just is what it is.

    Some things in life have checks and balances. The fact that online services can be taken down(seemingly at will) is one of those checks. It kept the X1 from being totally digital/online(public reaction/pressure). And in some small way I think that is a good thing.

    #18 1 year ago
  19. Joe Musashi

    suits that force unfair, one sided forms of DRM down our throats with aim of maintaining control over our gaming

    Nobody is forcing anything down anyone’s throat.

    It’s their platform, they created it, they spent the billions of dollars on R&D, manufacture and so on. As its theirs and belongs to them, they get to say under which terms its accessed.

    Nothing is being forced, you can simply walk away. Take it or leave it. Nobody is a villain.

    Gaming isn’t ‘ours’. And as commerce moves to service-based from box-based models, the myth of ownership is going to be increasingly removed from reality.

    Its pure melodrama to talk about this in reference to ‘bullies’ ‘villains’ and things ‘being forced down our throats’.

    As for hackers, the only way they act is to hack. That’s what defines them. It’s a destructive rather than constructive act. When hackers learn to engage in a constructive manner then they will make some progress. As it stands, they are just protesters throwing digital eggs at something.

    JM

    #19 1 year ago
  20. OlderGamer

    Look at it another way: who should you get mad at? The hackers or the company for being vulnerable? YoungZer0 has a point. I tend to blame the companies more. It is their responsibility. It is their show. And in most cases they are the ones pushing for connected services. If they can’ keep them safe….?

    #20 1 year ago
  21. Joe Musashi

    …that increasingly we don’t have any type of ownership over our game library…

    You never have. Get over it.

    JM

    #21 1 year ago
  22. OlderGamer

    Watch your steps fellas, would hate to see one of you falling from atop your high horses. That can happen sometimes when you drink too much coolaid.

    #22 1 year ago
  23. Gekidami

    Oh the irony. OG talking about high horses.

    #23 1 year ago
  24. Joe Musashi

    There’s nothing about being on a high-horse simply because some here understand the difference between ownership and assumed ownership and then performing melodramatic bleating when reality doesn’t fall in line with assumption.

    A snide remark doesn’t alter any of that.

    JM

    #24 1 year ago
  25. OlderGamer

    “While the liscencing laws have always maintained that we never “Owned” a game, the fact remains that I can still(anytime I want) play my Retro systems. From Atari2600 to Stuff I own on Disc today.”

    Miss that part Joe?

    And of course:

    “Its pure melodrama to talk about this in reference to ‘bullies’ ‘villains’ and things ‘being forced down our throats’.”

    And:

    “You never have. Get over it.”

    Aren’t snide at all.

    Joe, I liked you better as Kerplunk and Shatner. More transparent then.

    #25 1 year ago
  26. Ireland Michael

    @23 Having an opinion is a high horse now?

    Is there a single person on here anymore that can have a discussion without resorting to personal insults?

    ——-

    As for the topic, nobody is glorifying criminals. The point he’s making is that getting upset over things that happen on the internet is pointless.

    Companies do what they can to fix the problems, as quickly as they can. What the point in going nuts aboutit? There are people who completely lose their shit over this sort of stuff. It’s mindblowing. I mean seriously lose their shit. They go crazy online and scream and shot and spaz out for hours on end, because a game service goes down.

    It happens.

    If it happens when I want to enjoy that particular product… I just go something else until it’s fixed.

    Crazy idea, I know.

    #26 1 year ago
  27. Joe Musashi

    High horses don’t work when the horse is facing the wrong way.

    JM

    #27 1 year ago
  28. Legendaryboss

    First opinion piece within 24hrs of announced position, someone doesn’t mess about with time. This one is looking like it is gaining traction with the community as well.

    Hacking is a tricky business depending on whom your dealing with but the blame i think goes to both groups involved: The hackers and the organisation. Simply put an attack needs a group of hackers (the cause) and the ease of various attacks as it seems shows an organisation lack of security in terms of management of network (the victim).

    Should we acknowledge it? Yes we can’t brush it under the carpet as if nothing exists. Should we confront it? Well that ain’t our job rather the organisation under the spell.

    #28 1 year ago
  29. Cobra951

    While these self-righteous script morons bother me (who wouldn’t be bothered?) what really concerns me is the fact that they can achieve their goals at all. Is the infrastructure or security tech so poor that any idiot can go read some instructions or download a script, and wreak havoc on widespread services? There’s the real story. This is what needs to be brought out in the open, and shamed into improvement. Kids with rocks will never go away. So stop building structures out of thin glass.

    #29 1 year ago
  30. Ireland Michael

    @29 The tech and security isn’t poor at all. How do you protect an exploit you didn’t even know existed until someone exploited it?

    Technology and coding is obscenely complicated. A lot of these times these hackers are employed by companies themselves to brute force their programmes and code, in order to find those exploits in the first place. These people are experts at what they do.

    While yes, situations certainly do occur where someone simply “reads some instructions and wreck havoc”, it’s naive to suggest that this is case in most situations.

    Stuff like DDoS attacks are difficult to stop, as all they’re essentially doing is sending lots of requests to your site, to a degree the server simply can’t handle. Situations like stealing personal indentification isn’t really hacking most of the time, it’s phishing, which is simply convincing people through deception to provide their details.

    #30 1 year ago
  31. thegrimmling

    Anyone else find it funny how the conversation here is turning into who is the most correct?

    You are starting to sound like the kids you hate.

    #31 1 year ago
  32. noobman

    @32 Hows brother Dexter?

    #32 1 year ago
  33. salarta

    I think it’s pretty safe to say that the guys responsible for these things are nothing more than stupid, immature kids. Even if they’re physically adults, their actions speak to their mentality. The matter of their idiocy doesn’t change no matter what they do. Even by the simplest metric, they’re using tools other people made to carry out their antics, revealing they can’t do much of anything all by themselves.

    #33 1 year ago
  34. JB

    @21 so the whole reversal about Xbox One´s DRM policies had nothing to do with ownership issues…

    The whole reselling of licenses issue in Germany didn`t happen either…

    Yeah right…

    #34 1 year ago
  35. Ireland Michael

    @34 He’s been beating that horse for a while now, even though its deader than dead.

    Any data stored on my device and legally obtained by me is my complete ownership, to do with entirely as I please. I can mod it, hack it, change it and alter it however I please, as long as I don’t profit from it. The law backs this up, and the courts back this up. At least here in Europe.

    Licenses agreement, ToAs and EULAs mean absolutely nothing if the courts and laws system otherwise. They’re irrelevant documents made to coerce people away from even considering a reaction, nothing more, and they exist solely to try and protect the companies. I can’t speak for America, but our courts are actually invested in protecting people’s rights.

    #35 1 year ago
  36. Joe Musashi

    DRM isn’t about ownership, it’s about enforcement of control by the owners.

    A software licence is not software. Owning the former does not equate to ownership of the latter.

    Software/data isn’t physical. The notion that you own data it because you posess the physical medium it’s delivered on is a fallacy.

    JM

    #36 1 year ago
  37. Cobra951

    @35: Here in America, the fair-use doctrine is supposed to offer us similar consumer protection. Corporations have been trying to chip away at it, however, and we never know which way judicial decisions are going to go. My attitude is exactly the same as yours, regardless. I will continue to stake my complete ownership-and-control claim on anything that I buy, and I will reject outright any DRM systems which take any part of it away.

    #37 1 year ago
  38. Joe Musashi

    “My attitude is exactly the same as yours, regardless. I will continue to stake my complete ownership-and-control claim on anything that I buy, and I will reject outright any DRM systems which take any part of it away.”

    The bolded part is key. Do you know what you have bought? Because, in the context of videogames, if you think you have bought the software then you are mistaken.

    When I get the “I bought it so it’s mine!” argument presented, I picture someone standing up, folding their arms and sticking their chin out defiantly. Which is all well and good, but that doesn’t necessary make the statement true, regardless of the conviction it’s delivered with.

    As a consumer, your choices are to take it or leave it. Because ownership is never transferred to the consumer, the consumer is not granted the right to dictate the terms of usage.

    People have got used to assuming the opposite, however. When the genuine owners try to enforce their control you get the sort of reception the original XBox One’s DRM policy got. Outrage and outcry. That doesn’t mean Microsoft weren’t within their rights, just that people didn’t like the methods they were proposing.

    Microsoft should have left that for one more generation. Ultimately everything will go digital and the decades of self-indulgent misinterpretation of ownership will evaporate.

    To all and any that would argue otherwise I encourage you to read the software licence in your videogame manual(s).

    JM

    #38 1 year ago
  39. Ireland Michael

    @36 The law says otherwise.

    I own what’s on the disc. Completely and absolutely. Just as I own a book. I can do whatever I want with it. I can even resell it’s altered form (exchange of goods) as long as I don’t make copies. (piracy)

    In fact, the laws here are moving even more in defence of that. Digital services are required to permanently provide me with access to download anything that I purchased from them, as long as they remain in business. Even if they lose the rights to continue selling a particular title, they have to continue to provide access to it to anyone who previously bought it. Publishers are required to abide by this as well.

    “To all and any that would argue otherwise I encourage you to read the software licence in your videogame manual(s).”

    I encourage you to understand the fact that any time this argument has been made in a court of law in the EU it has been thrown out the windows.

    It has about as much wait as the “viewing licence” of a DVD. Those laws were devised for the purpose of combating piracy so they could use them in court against people guilty of such. No company is stupid enough to actually enforce them on people (except the RIAA, but hey… ‘Murica), and no high court would let them.

    You can claim “software license” as much as you please Joe, but the courts say you’re full of shit. Its a meaningless buzzword. In fact, laws are currently being put together in the EU *specifically* to declare that people do, in fact, possess ownership of data.

    Any company that claims otherwise with have a hundred interests groups with vast pockets of money breathing down their throats if they don’t comply.

    #39 1 year ago
  40. Joe Musashi

    @39 The law doesn’t say otherwise. You don’t own what’s on the disc. There are literally tens of millions of examples of this sitting on consumers shelves at the moment.

    There are some very significant lines being blurred here: ownership is absolutely central to the argument and it’s why ownership of the software is absolutely not transferred to you. It never will be. Not for 50 bucks. If you want to genuinely become the owner of the software it’s more likely to set you back six figures (and that’s not including the legal fees).

    Things like ‘access’ and ‘usage’ and ‘licence’ and even ‘reselling’ (which has a handful of exceptions and certainly does not nullify the millions of cases that make up the norm) are not the same as ‘ownership’.

    You are not the owner. You absolutely do not own the data, you merely have access to it under certain terms. (And you’ll typically find that those terms state that your usage of the data declares agreement of those terms. So proceeding to use the data and then arguing that you don’t care for the terms puts you on the wrong side of the argument by default)

    Digital distribution doesn’t make any difference to this argument. No changes in ownership (and the lack of transfer of ownership) will be being made.

    And I’ll tell you why: because it doesn’t need to be. Because those billions of apps on those billions of smartphones and tablets already outnumber physical game sales from past decades. The digital precedent has already been set. It’s been set years ago. But because there was no assumptions being made about ownership in the first place because people were getting latched on to “It’s physical, therefore I own it!” nobody has batted an eyelid.

    People are only getting bent out of shape because they believe the rules are changing. They’re not. People just have chosen to overlook the rules that didn’t suit their interests. What’s changing is the enforcement of the same rules. Now people are having to adhere to those rules. The change is that people can’t get away with their assumed ownership as much. And, naturally, they get upset about that and rattle out stock victim-pleas like “anti-consumer” at the drop of a hat.

    Extending the argument to digital is really showing how late to the party you are and how poor your comprehension is of this topic. The digital argument is already done. It was done before people were downloading Crazy Frog ringtones. That nobody was (back then) crying about owning something that was delivered purely digitally – like a ringtone – shows, very starkly, that this isn’t about rules changing.

    Ownership is key. And there is nothing that says you own the software and everything that says the publisher does.

    When you purchase a copy of Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, you do not own the music The Beatles wrote. The publisher still owns that music. When you buy a DVD of StarWars, George Lucas has not transferred complete control of his seminal property over to you for ten bucks (he transferred ownership of Star Wars etc to Disney – and for a LOT more money, they own it now). And when you spend money on a videogame, the ownership of that software is not transferred to you.

    There are billions of examples of what I’m talking about. There have been one or two, very laboured, very long-toothed, very specific exceptions made for one or two specific pieces of software in very specific reselling scenarios that support your view.

    Those laws were devised for the purpose of combating piracy so they could use them in court against people guilty of such. No company is stupid enough to actually enforce them on people, and no decent court would ever do so.

    That’s a very convenient way to look at laws. If you are arguing that laws and rights should be acknowledged then you make a huge contradiction by dismissing the laws and rights that serve people other than the consumer assuming ownership. You don’t get to cherry-pick which laws matter and which don’t on a whim.

    Here’s the rub. Let this one sink in:

    When you pay for something, why do you think the term is “consumer” and not “owner” ?

    JM

    #40 1 year ago
  41. monkeygourmet

    @Shatner

    Now you are pretty much copying and pasting from your blog.

    #41 1 year ago
  42. Ireland Michael

    @41 He’s muddying (deliberately or unintentionally, I’m not sure) intellectual property and copyright laws with ownership laws.

    Nobody is claiming people own the music, or the characters, or the stories. They’re claiming you own the right to keep it as your possession and do with it as you wish as long as you absolve all ownership of it when you sell it.

    It’s hilariously pedantic.

    …he has a blog?

    #42 1 year ago
  43. noobman

    TEA changed his name too robot JM lol

    #43 1 year ago
  44. monkeygourmet

    @42

    Yes, it was mentioned here, way back…

    #44 1 year ago
  45. JB

    @40 You`re simply wrong and your arguments are pure misinformation.

    It doesn`t matter how many times you repeat it. The European courts thinks otherwise.

    Your example of Sergeant Pepper`s Lonely hearts Club Band illustrate that perfectly. You own that particular copy of it when you buy it. When you purchased it the righst of that particular copy is yours. It doesn`t give you the right of distributing Beatles music or make more copies of Sergeant Pepper, but that copy is yours now and you can resell it if you want.It`s been that way for years and years.

    It doesn`t matter if you call it a license. If you buy a license it`s yours.

    There`s a legal term called the first sale doctrine, and that too has been the case for years and years.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine

    Phil Harrison tried to sell the “game ownership must change in the future” and failed. Microsoft made a 180 and Don Mattrick even said:

    “You told us how much you loved the flexibility you have today with games delivered on disc. The ability to lend, share, and resell these games at your discretion is of incredible importance to you,” he wrote. “Also important to you is the freedom to play offline, for any length of time, anywhere in the world.”

    Yet you still try and pretend that didn`t happen.

    >_<

    #45 1 year ago
  46. monkeygourmet

    @45

    Yes we know he’s talking shit. Just a bitter viewpoint that won’t hold up to scrutiny.

    Much like most of his output, I wouldn’t worry about trying to argue with him.

    #46 1 year ago
  47. JB

    @46 :)

    #47 1 year ago
  48. Joe Musashi

    JB owning a licence is not owning the material.

    Owning a software licence is not the same as owning the software.

    Thank you for clarifying that key point.

    All my other points still stand. They are all based on the understanding of ownership of software/data.

    All counter-arguments are based on assumptions or mixing up specifics.

    PR Speak doesn’t really mean a great deal. It’s designed to get people on side without actually having to do anything meaningful for it. Quoting PR speak chapter-and-verse back at me shows how effective that hollow tactic is.

    And the only reason you got that PR speech was because Microsoft proposed policy (whilst perfectly legal and in their right to enforce) was not popular. Not popular at all. So they backtracked and they said things that people wanted to hear instead of what they didn’t want to hear. Microsoft’s motivation was to make a change in order to secure sales. It was not an act of pro-consumer benevolence.

    And first sale doctrine – which is not a global outright policy anyway will be utterly nullified via digital delivery. Again: see how much it impacts the billions of ipad, iphone and smartphone app purchases. That is just the tip of the iceberg.

    Get ready to suck it up folks. Your mistaken belief that you own something you do not own is going to evaporate over the next generation. You will have no choice but to accept your assumed rights don’t mean much when you don’t actually own the thing in the first place.

    Every single day that passes, thousands of transactions take place that cement and add further weight to the point that I’m discussing. And if you think “It’ll never happen” look at what has already happened to the bricks-and-mortar music stores and chains that used to sell boxed music product. iTunes and digital, drm-laden delivery has decimated them. Same with places like Blockbuster vs Netflix. People are lapping this up.

    Cry, lie, stamp your feet, pull faces, make internet petitions, make desperately childish dismissive remarks, pretend decades of precedent don’t already exist, pretend billions of examples don’t already exist, pretend that a licence is software is data is a cd is digital and blur any specifics you like, pretend to ignore the change in the way content is being sold as it happens right around you :-

    It won’t make any difference. You are consumers, you are not owners.

    JM

    #48 1 year ago
  49. Ireland Michael

    “Again: see how much it impacts the billions of ipad, iphone and smartphone app purchases.”

    As long as Apple exists as a company, they are legally obliged to provide me means to access and download any content I bought from them, and any music I bought from them is my property for life – if I lose or damage it after their company goes under though, that is entirely on me.

    “And first sale doctrine – which is not a global outright policy anyway will be utterly nullified via digital delivery.”

    Digital delivery is a choice. You own your digital content anyway, so they doesn’t really matter.

    “Same with places like Blockbuster vs Netflix”

    Netflix is a service. Goods and services are entirely different things. People know that a Netfix is a rental service. They’re not stupid.

    “Get ready to suck it up folks. Your mistaken belief that you own something you do not own is going to evaporate over the next generation. You will have no choice but to accept your assumed rights don’t mean much when you don’t actually own the thing in the first place.”

    How? I will still own the right to keep and use the copy I bought however I see fit.

    “Cry, lie, stamp your feet, pull faces,”

    Nobody is doing anything of the sort, you pompous whiner.

    #49 1 year ago
  50. Joe Musashi

    “As long as Apple exists as a company, they are legally obliged to provide me means to access and download any content I bought from them, and any music I bought from them is my property for life – if I lose or damage it after their company goes under though, that is entirely on me.”

    Note the word in bold. The word you wrote.

    That has absolutely no bearing on the topic of ownership. How does your argument about reselling and doing what you like with it apply here? It doesn’t. You’re missing the point and arguing another that was never raised.

    “You own your digital content anyway, so they doesn’t really matter.”

    Not at all. You own it in as much as you own any other piece of software you have paid to access: which is to say you don’t own the software. Ownership has never been transferred to you. Access and ownership are two completely separate things. You’re (twice) referring to one and calling it the other.

    “Netflix is a service. Goods and services are entirely different things”

    Point missed about digital delivery. Well done. Also you will see more and more and more content being shifted to a service model of delivery – distancing you further from the mistaken sense of ownership you currently exhibit.

    “How? I will still own the right to keep and use the copy I bought however I see fit.”

    No you don’t. You never have. You don’t have the right of ownership. Because you don’t own it. Ownership has never been transferred to you.

    The same errors made again: blurring the lines of the details. Now your pushing access as ownership. Earlier you’re saying laws that don’t serve your interests don’t matter.

    In every single counterpoint I’ve ever read it’s abundantly clear to see it’s driven by a sense of entitlement. And the only rights people care about are the ones that serve their personal gain. Rights belonging to other parties can just be arbitrarily ignored or overrulled on a whim.

    That’s a ridiculous platform to argue from and one that no objective person can respect.

    Petty insults by way of response don’t negate any of those points.

    JM

    #50 1 year ago
  51. Ireland Michael

    You’re the sort of person Shatner, who would constantly asked to be punched in the face, and still try to claim that you are, in fact, not getting punched in the face.

    #51 1 year ago
  52. JB

    @48 ” It won’t make any difference. You are consumers, you are not owners.”

    That´s the very thing you don`t seem to grasp. Consumers have rights and owners have rights. That`s been the principle for decades. You seem to base your entire argument on the falsehood that only the owners have (or should have) rights. Buying a digital copy gives (or should give) the consumer the rights to that particular copy, they own it because they bought it, the previous owner exhausted their ownership during the sale. It doesn`t give the new owner rights to make more copies or alter the copy and it doesn`t give them the rights to ownership over the source material. That`s the way it`s been for decades for physical goods.

    The digital industry are arguing that digital goods are different from physical ones, so the spirit and principles of the first sale doctrine shouldn`t apply to their products. They`ve been trying all sorts of loopholes to get around the first sale doctrine, but it`s not fair to rent products to consumers at full price. It`s not fair that consumers should lose fundamental rights because of the form the content is delivered in. The EU ruling does not distinguish between digital or physical products. The principle is the same – if people buy a license or a product it`s theirs – they own it. If they want to resell it, it`s their right to do so.

    #52 1 year ago
  53. Joe Musashi

    “Consumers have rights and owners have rights.”

    The point is that consumers (who are not owners) do not get to overrule the endorsed rights of the owners because they happen to feel like it.

    The falsehood here is that the consumers are assuming their whims take precedence. There is plenty of evidence in this discussion that the rights/whims of anyone other than the consumer don’t even exist. Fair play to you JB that you actually acknowledge more than one party in this topic.

    Consumers do this because they are used to getting their own way because the genuine owners rarely persue consumers who carry out this inappropriate action. It’s not worth the time and effort usually – and the few times it has been persued it has made the owner appear villainous for enforcing their rights.

    I am not saying one party has rights and the other does not. It is not me that has argued that laws I don’t personally agree with simply do not matter, for example.

    But a consumer does NOT have the same rights that the owner does. And the owner’s rights – specifically in control on their material are for them to dictate, not the consumer.

    Like I say, you want to own the software, you’ll be writing a 6 figure sum for it.

    The EU ruling is absolutely worthless in respect of digital content. Because their is no enforcement to enable things like reselling content you are not the owner of. How are you going to legitimately resell that iPad app you just paid two bucks for?

    JM

    #53 1 year ago
  54. Ireland Michael

    Which is exactly why laws regarding digital ownership to expand that sort of thing are currently being discussed in the EU courts as we speak.

    Game, set and match.

    #54 1 year ago
  55. Joe Musashi

    So something that is being ‘discussed’ is conclusive proof of an outcome you’ve been arguing already exists? How does your time machine work, precisely?

    Firstly, if it’s being discussed, it isn’t decided. Your puerile and presumptuous “game, set and match” is hugely premature.

    Secondly, it will have ZERO effect on the argument of ownership. The transfer of ownership still will not occur in precisely the same way that it doesn’t occur right now. I guarantee it. If you want to genuinely become the owner of the content you are currently paying a few bucks for you can expect the fee for it to multiply by a factor of tens of thousands.

    At no time have you ever given any indiciation that you understand what it means to own software as opposed to posess a copy of someone else’s software or access someone else software. You have consistently mixed and matched and swapped these definitions around whenever it suits you.

    Remember: a licence is not software. Access is not ownership. Possessing a copy is not ownership of the software.

    The entire crux of all of this is driven by ownership. It’s something you still refuse to grasp and in your eagerness to prematurely claim you have ‘won’ a discussion you’ve exposed why your argument has been so patchy and inconsistent in the first place.

    And thirdly: content will continue to move towards a service driven model. Anything concerning ownership won’t fall into that model, it shifts purely to access. Evidence of that model already exists (look at PS+ and the way the content offered through it is yours whilst you remain a subscriber to the service for example).

    Have you any idea how simple it would be to move everything over to a subscription model for consoles? “Lifetime subscription to our game content service with the purchase of the hardware!”. The console then becomes a dongle to perform a one-time legitimacy check of the content with the user’s subscription. Bam. Done. Service model in place.

    iTunes will the one to watch as a result of any ongoing discussions. They’ve already set the precedent in this field and they’ll continue to do so.

    In the same manner of the currently ineffectual ruling, I don’t expect to see anything meaningful come of the ongoing discussions.

    This is not about giving entitled presumptuous consumers a legitimacy for their greed. It concerns many more parties than them. Assuming the outcome of anything as being purely beneficial to the consumer shows remarkable naivity.

    But it’s remarkable, isn’t it?

    Ignore decades of precedence and billions of examples (heck, don’t even acknowledge them).

    But the merest whiff of a hypothetical change that (you assume) will suit your personal gain is rock-solid conclusive evidence that you were right all along!

    (logically, it proves the exact opposite because of the chronology)

    Like I said before, this is not the first time such selectiveness has been exhibited in this discussion.

    JM

    #55 1 year ago
  56. Dragon

    @18,
    Quite ironic that “game ownership” agrument is coming you.
    Can you resell your steam PC games?

    #56 1 year ago
  57. lolatfanboys

    Let´s implement a huge amount of restrictive laws because we could´t log into steam for one day… lulz…But go on with the outrage and validate such people that do the “hacking”

    #57 1 year ago
  58. Ireland Michael

    @56 The law technically does allow you to sell digitally owned content, and it’s completely legal to do so, but they currently haven’t made it mandatory for companies to implement such a system. Lots of groups here believe it should he allowable, so don’t be surprised if it happens.

    #58 1 year ago
  59. Dragon

    ^Does it happen? Nope.

    #59 1 year ago
  60. Ireland Michael

    @59 If I wanted to, I could technically sell my Steam account to someone, as long as I gave up access to it, and no manner of words in the ToS would change the fact that the action would be supported in the high court.

    Obviously certain laws need to be updated to better reflect the digital landscape. Some of them are decades old. Buts that’s already happening and continues to improve. I wouldn’t be surprised if within the next half a decade or so a transfer system exists in most digital services, where you can, say, transfer your game to another person’s account and receive credit / payment in return.

    The companies obviously won’t want it. That’s irrelevant. The courts here are far more interested in maintaining people’s rights than making businesses happy, since they’re not dictated by dozens of millionaire lobby groups pushing schemes to line their wallets with more good.

    #60 1 year ago
  61. JB

    @59 Interestingly enough last year Apple and Amazon both patented systems for the resale and transfer of “used digital goods”:

    http://techcrunch.com/2013/03/07/apple-patents-a-system-for-the-resale-and-transfer-of-used-digital-goods/

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/amazon-patents-resale-marketplace-for-used-e-books-songs-and-other-digital-goods/2013/02/06/22f7d12e-70a0-11e2-a050-b83a7b35c4b5_story.html

    As expected the digital industry will try and fight this as long as possible, but it`s a fight they will lose sooner or later. The EU Highcourt ruling is very clear though. There`s no difference between a sale of a physical product, a digital copy or a license.

    The industry will argue in vain that digital copies don`t degrade over time and whatever loopholes they can think of…

    #61 1 year ago
  62. Dragon

    @60,61,
    Call me again when it happens.
    Present is the reality, and in reality it doesnt happen.

    @61,
    Sony patented a “smartwig” for people to wear. Will they launch it? No.

    #62 1 year ago
  63. cluggy89

    @60 Although correct in most cases you are wrong about being able to sell your steam account the subscriber agreement states

    “You may not reveal, share or otherwise allow others to use your password or Account. You agree that you are personally responsible for the use of your password and Account and for all of the communication and activity on Steam that results from use of your login name and password. You may not sell or charge others for the right to use your Account, or otherwise transfer your Account, nor may you sell, charge others for the right to use, or transfer any Subscriptions other than if and as expressly permitted by this Agreement (including any Subscription Terms or Rules of Use”
    source http://store.steampowered.com/subscriber_agreement/

    #63 1 year ago
  64. JB

    @63 Valve is facing another court battle in Germany due to their stance on game ownership and account selling. Valve won the first case in 2010, but it will be interesting to see how long they can keep it that way:

    http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130131/10292021839/valve-sued-germany-over-right-to-resell-games.shtml

    If you read the first page of the subscriber agreement you´ll notice that even today some of the conditions are useless in The European Union.

    It`s the same with EULA`s in The EU.

    #64 1 year ago
  65. Ireland Michael

    @62 Progress takes time.

    @63 The words in those documents are utterly meaningless if the high courts say the law states otherwise.

    It’s the whole reason EULA’s are called Agreements, not contracts. They’re just trying to use pressure to convince people that they *have* to do something, because they know a single individual wouldn’t really be able to take them to court. That’s why we have this awesome thing called class action lawsuits.

    The worst trend lately is businesses including conditions that you must waiver all right to sue a company. A condition that wouldn’t last a second if it was actually taken to court. People have far more rights than businesses constantly want to bully you into thinking you don’t.

    Just because it’s written down does not, in fact, make it law, and the perfect example of this is the license agreements on movies releases. They still to this day claim that you can’t resell (flat out bollocks) or lend them, and that they are for private viewing by you and you alone, but the reality is far different.

    Those “licenses” are utterly meaningless when actually applies to the real world and the average consumer, and carry little weight on an individual basis.

    #65 1 year ago
  66. Joe Musashi

    It’s a very convenient life to live where you arbitrarily decide that the rights of other parties simply don’t matter – in spite of the fact you have agreed to them – whenever it interferes with your personal gain.

    This self-indulgent whimsical approach to rights and, in particular, ownership of goods owned by another flies in the face of reality, of decades of reality and of billions of transactions. Rarely has there been such a staunch display of head-in-the-sand self service.

    Technology and commerce moves much faster than law.

    JM

    #66 1 year ago
  67. JB

    @66 We know you think consumer rights are a form of entitlement disorder that should be abolished.

    You still haven`t grasped the concept of ownership under copyright and IP laws which are based on centuries of transactions. As long as you don`t get the basics on that, your rants will remain pure misinformation.

    #67 1 year ago
  68. Joe Musashi

    I don’t think that at all.

    But I’m not the one lording around insisting laws that don’t serve my personal gain ‘don’t matter’ and that the rights and interests of people other than myself are ‘irrelevant’. That sort of attitude is the one that shows entitlement – and it has been exhibited with relish in this discussion.

    I understand the basics entirely. And, as you’re and others are so persistently and eagerly ignoring, I have decades of real-world evidence and billions (and millions more every day) of instances which perfectly demonstrate the central point that this topic revolves around: ownership.

    The rights of all need to be considered – especially those that genuinely have ownership – not just the greedy few that assume ownership and then attempt to dismiss anything that doesn’t further their personal gain. At best, those presenting counter arguments have been using hypothesis and assumption (twisted to suit their goals) rather than the actual day-to-day reality that I use as my substance.

    I am a consumer as much as anyone. I’m just not selfish enough to think mine are the only rights that matter.

    JM

    #68 1 year ago
  69. Ireland Michael

    “But I’m not the one lording around insisting laws that don’t serve my personal gain ‘don’t matter’ and that the rights and interests of people other than myself are ‘irrelevant’.”

    It’s not about my personal gain. I don’t care about ownership. I’m not concerned with owning things beyond what I need to survive. It’s about what has actually stood up in a court of law and written down in law itself versus what businesses claim.

    Just because a million people *want* to get metaphorically fucked in the ass doesn’t actually make it legal to do so.

    #69 1 year ago
  70. Joe Musashi

    For someone who has stated that selective laws don’t matter and that the interests of other parties that don’t further your personal gain are irrelevant, it’s odd that you’d now dispute that notion.

    But then, the twisting turning nature of your argument has been wildly inconsistent from the outset. It’s just makes even less sense to argue a point one minute and then claim you never did in the next.

    None of that matters. Because reality is what matters. And in the real world, today, you are still not (and have never been) the owners. So, in the real world, today, you don’t get to dictate which laws and rights matter and you don’t get to dictate the control of something you don’t own.

    Insisting that your self-indulgent theories are, in fact, reality and have come to pass and represent some sort of victory for your inconsistent and ill-considered argument are just a fallacy.

    The thing is there’s three things that people need to factor:

    a) the consumer’s desire for the content
    b) the rights of all parties
    c) the owner of the content (that’d be not you)

    Let’s assume that, the magical legal rainbow unicorn declares full control of the content to the consumer.

    This won’t suit the interests of the folks in c) but they are beholden to the magical legal rainbow unicorn’s decree as per b).

    So the folks in c) will change their model so that their interests will not be curtailed by b).

    And this is where a) comes into play.

    Because the consumers will follow based on their desire for the content offered. And so they will pro-actively move away from those rights granted by the magical legal rainbow unicorn.

    This is not theoretical. This has already happened countless times over.

    And when the same wheels turn and another transition occurs (this time from a content model to a subscription model – as we’re already seeing in a number of places) the consumers will transition with it.

    This is what the benefits of being the genuine owner are. You get to control the consumption and acquisition of your content. The owner leads, the consumer follows.

    JM

    #70 1 year ago
  71. Ireland Michael

    Derpa derpa. Derpity derp. Deeeeeeeeerp!

    #71 1 year ago
  72. Legendaryboss

    Opinion piece = hacking themed = network takedown = Games/Services attacked = comments section mainly consists about game ownership debate.

    I see a missing puzzle.

    #72 1 year ago
  73. Christopher Jack

    Outside of digital video games there are countless situations where you can transfer licenses, not qualifications like a drivers license obviously but like service contracts for example. I switched a phone contract into my name mere months ago for example.

    You never own the game but you do own the license to use the game(like a service) & despite the rocky road of the terms of service you may find yourself legally able to switch ownership of the license & access to the service depending on your territory

    #73 1 year ago

Comments are now closed on this article.

  • Bungie weekly update: Commendations begone

    Destiny’s weekly update is here to determine the fate of all those Commendations you’ve been earning in the past few months. Bungie started off this week’s update with a recap of the details revealed during the recent livestream. There wasn’t really anything on this front that they haven’t talked about already. With the exception of […]

  • This GTA 5 trainer lets you play as almost anything and it’s the best thing ever

    Want to play GTA 5 as a monkey, a cat, a fish, a deer or some other non-human thing that we eat or keep as a pet? ScriptHook has you covered. Not only can you play as critters, it change other game values, according to an explanation from PC Gamer. These values include making changes […]

  • EA Sports moves Rory McIlroy PGA TOUR release date to July

    EA Sports has announced Rory McIlroy PGA TOUR will be released in July. Originally announced for June, the golf game will now release the same week as the Open Championship at St. Andrews, on July 14. EA also provided some more color on gameplay features such as the ability to customize the game by borrowing […]

  • Jason Voorhees joins Mortal Kombat X in May, Kombat Pack owners get first dibs

    Jason Voorhees will arrive for Mortal Kombat X players in May, NetherRealm Studios announced today during the latest Kombat Kast. Jason will be shown for the first time on Monday, May 4 during a special Kombat Kast. According to EventHub which watched the livestream, the developer will also show off the character’s move and Variations. […]

  • The Witcher 3: Nvidia heads to Poland for a behind-the-scenes look – video

    A video for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt has been released, taking you behind-the-scenes with CD Projekt RED. Nvidia’s GeForce crew went to the firm’s studio in Poland to talk with the game’s executive producer John Mamais, who provides a look at the PC version of the upcoming RPG. CD Projekt, according to the video […]

  • Microsoft notes decline in Xbox unit sales for Q3 FY15 to 1.6 million

    Microsoft reported its Q3 FY15 earnings today, citing growth in Xbox Live usage as one of the contributing factors to the firm’s reported revenue. However, the firm noted a decline in units sales for its Xbox consoles during the quarter. Microsoft Q3 2014 (yoy comparison) Microsoft Q1 fiscal 2015 Microsoft Q2 fiscal 2015 The firm […]

  • Powerplay is a new feature included in the Elite: Dangerous May update

    The next update for Elite: Dangerous is coming next month and it includes a new feature called Powerplay. According to Frontier Developments, Powerplay allows players to participate in an ongoing battle that “enhances every aspect” of the game. Players can become allies with a number of galactic Powers and guide their strategy, pursue objectives in […]

  • Facebook says it’s “too early” to discuss large-scale shipments of Oculus Rift

    Facebook has said it is “too early” to discuss large-scale shipments of Oculus Rift as the VR headset is still in the development stages. Speaking during a call to investors, Facebook CFO David Wehner said the company had nothing to announce regarding the amount of stock it expected to ship. “We have not announced any […]

  • Battlefield Hardline’s first patch and rental server program hits next week

    Battlefield Hardline’s first patch has a release date for both consoles and PC. PC & Console patch and RSP for Consoles coming April 28th. Fixes include TDM spawns and more: http://t.co/BZYJeomPlr pic.twitter.com/27TCiY8hmf — Battlefield (@Battlefield) April 23, 2015 The update will include fixes to Punkbuster, Nvidia DirectX drivers, TDM spawns, contains weapon balance tweaks and […]

  • Modders can now earn money through Steam Workshop starting today with Skyrim

    Valve has introduced a new functionality within Steam Workshop which will allow mod makers to earn money for their creations, starting with Skyrim. The update will allow content such as mods, items, or maps to be sold through Steam Workshop for titles which have the feature enabled. A new “streamlined process for listing” has been […]

  • Play Skyrim for free this weekend on Steam and take 75% off while you’re at it

    Skyrim is free this weekend on Steam providing wanna-be Dragonborns who have procrastinated on wetting their blades with Stormcloak blood the perfect opportunity to give the RPG a try. Head over to Steam and download the game and play for free until April 26 at 1am PDT. The game is also 75% off if you […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 “Ember” teaser video released ahead of full reveal

    Activision has released a Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 teaser video titled “Ember” and you can watch it right here. Here’s the video blurb: “In the next 50 years, technological advancements will lead us into a world where only those who risk going too far, will find out how far we can actually go.” […]

  • Dragon Age Keep update includes more customizability and control

    Bioware has updated Dragon Age Keep after listening to community feedback. The update includes more customization and control over heroes, world states, career and more. Players can now customize hero portraits or delete Dragon Age: Inquisition heroes from the Hero section. They can also remove playthrough states from the World State Manager and keep up […]

  • Here’s a look at some Conker community creations in Project Spark

    Conker’s Bug Reunion releases today, and below is a video showing some of the community creations you will be able to download using the creation pack. Project Spark is a free download on Xbox One and Windows 8.1, and you can download the Conker Creation Pack today. It contains 350 assets in order for users […]

  • Rainbow Six: Siege video shines spotlight on the British Counter Terrorist Unit

    Ubisoft has released a Rainbow Six: Siege video which gives you a look at the British Counter Terrorist Unit which features “the best of the Army, Navy, and Air Force.” The firm said that over the next few weeks it will introduce the public to each of the units in the game. Rainbow Six Siege […]

  • Mario Kart 8 DLC and Mewtwo for Super Smash Bros. headline eShop update in North America

    Nintendo has updated the North American end of the eShop with an update and new DLC for Mario Kart 8 and the Mewtwo DLC for Super Smash Bros. Other highlights include Mario Kart DS on Wii U Virtual Console, the continuation of International StreetPass Week and more. Full update is below. Nintendo eShop Mario Kart […]

  • Square Enix host E3 2015 conference this year on June 16

    With Final Fantasy 15, Rise of the Tomb Raider and Deus Ex: Mankind Divided on the horizon, it should come as no surprise to learn that Square Enix will be hosting a dedicated E3 2015 conference this year. The presentation will take place Tuesday, June 16 at 9am PDT/12pm EDT/5pm UK. It will be broadcast […]

  • Final Fantasy 4: The After Years 3D remake releasing on Steam next month

    Final Fantasy 4: The After Years has been given a makeover and will be released on Steam of PC next month. You can now pre-order it on Steam and take 10% off for the time being. The game will be released on the digital service May 12 and will include trading cards and achievements. Thanks, […]

  • This Project Cars video shows off the racer’s multiplayer

    Project Cars developer Slightly Mad has released a new video giving you a look at the game’s multiplayer. The game is out next month, and if you would like to refresh yourself on the tracks included,  give this a look. While you are clicking links, here’s the minimum and recommended PC specifications which dropped last […]

  • Looks like Logitech is getting out of OEM mouse production business [Clarification]

    Logitech will no longer produce “low-end” mice, citing a decline in PC accessories. This story has been updated to include a clarification. According to a Reuters report, per MCV, the firm will instead focus on video accessories and streaming music, as its wireless Bluetooth speakers are now its best-selling product rage. This will help offset […]

  • Win! We have 1,000 Heroes of the Storm beta keys to give away

    Must have more MOBA? Win one of our 1,000 Heroes of the Storm beta keys and see if you’re more Blizzard than LoL. Can’t wait for June 2? Of course you can’t. We have 1,000 closed beta keys for Heroes of the Storm to give away this week, allowing you access before Blizzard’s MOBA goes […]

  • Xenoblade Chronicles X Nintendo Direct airs tomorrow, April 24

    A Nintendo Direct devoted entirely to Xenoblade Chronicles X will air this Friday, April 24. The video showcase will start at 11am PDT/2pm EDT/7pm UK. After the showcase, a new Nintendo Treehouse: Live presentation featuring the game will air. This is the second Xenoblace Chronicles X Nintendo Direct, but the first in English. The first […]

  • Blizzard will have 500 game stations set up at gamescom 2015

    Blizzard is heading to gamescom 2015 in August and it will have 500 game stations set up for attendees to get their hands on five of its titles. The developer will be set up in Hall 7 and those who stop by will be able to get hands-on with the latest content for Heroes of […]

  • PS4 price cut to £299 in UK

    Sony has dropped the price of the PS4 in the UK. For a limited time only, you can grab the console for £299.99 from Argos, Game, Tesco and Very. Go to Amazon.co.uk and you’ll get it for £289. You’ve only got until April 28, then it goes back up to £349. Go, go, go. For […]

  • Mad Max: first ever gameplay footage revealed

    Today, we get to finally take our first look at gameplay from Mad Max. Avalanche and Warner Bros. have shown off the first gameplay trailer for Mad Max today. The trailer below offers a look at melee combat, car combat, customisation and much more. Give it a watch below: There are a few new screenshots […]

  • Overlord: Fellowship of Evil has four-player co-op like we figured

    Codemasters has pulled the veil back on the next Overlord game, and its a four-player co-op game called Overlord: Fellowship of Evil. Rhianna Pratchett is back to write the story. The game may be co-op at its core, but it can still be played single-player. Each of the four playable character have strengths and weaknesses, […]

  • Update now available for Pokemon Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire, Pokemon X and Y

    Pokemon Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire along with Pokemon X and Y are being updated by Nintendo to fix a few bugs and in-game text. There’s also the possibility of a few hacks and exploits being fixed. Per Nintendo Life (via Serebii), both patches are 250-270 blocks in size, and it’s a mandatory update which […]

  • Side-scrolling cover shooter Not a Hero gets a demo

    Not a Hero, the upcoming game from OlliOlli developer Roll7, has received a demo. The demo for Not a Hero was made available today on Steam. In the game, you play as Steve, the campaign manager for BunnyLord. A time-travelling rabbit who’s running for mayor of London. Think this is an absurd premise? This trailer […]

  • You have until April 30 to export your Green Day: Rock Band tracks to Rock Band 3

    Harmonix has announced that those looking to export their song collection from Green Day: Rock Band into Rock Band 3 can only do so until the end of the month. April 30 will be the cutoff date for anyone who wants to export tracks from Green Day: Rock Band into their Rock Band 3 library, […]

  • Batman: Arkham Knight minimum, recommended, and ultra PC specs revealed

    Batman: Arkham Knight is looking like it’s going to be quite a taxing game. Nvidia has released a list of the minimum, recommended, and ultra PC requirements for Batman: Arkham Knight. Here’s the full thing: Minimum OS: Win 7 SP1, Win 8.1 (64-bit Operating System Required) Processor: Intel Core i5-750, 2.67 GHz | AMD Phenom […]

  • Bloodborne patch 1.03 is live, reduces loading times, fixes suspend/resume bugs, more

    Patch 1.03 is now live for Bloodborne. The patch reduces loading times, adds item descriptions to loading screens, and fixes other various bugs. From Software has pushed update 1.03 live to all Bloodborne owners. As promised, it reduces loading times by approximately 5 to 15 seconds. Another new addition is showing item descriptions instead of […]

  • Battlefield 4: first look at Community Map in action

    Get your first look at the map designed by the community of Battlefield 4. Battlefield 4′s community-designed map is a reality. DICE has recently updated CTE to include an early version of the map. It’s not fully textured as Westie is about to show you, but the layout is nearly finalised. Westie goes over the […]

  • Microsoft apologises for uploading misleading Witcher 3: Wild Hunt footage

    Xbox’s YouTube channel uploaded a video of The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt yesterday that was captured from the PC build. The most recent gameplay video for the The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt appeared on the Xbox YouTube channel and showed a quest from the game’s opening section. A few minutes after it had gone live, […]

  • Assassin’s Creed creator’s new game is Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey

    Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey is the game Assassin’s Creed creator Patrice Desilets has been working on. Patrice Desilets has just announced that the next game his indie studio Panache Digital Games is making is called Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey. The announcement comes from Desilets’s keynote at the Reboot Develop event in Croatia. The trailer started […]

  • Bloodborne: Cathedral Ward closed door mystery solved

    The mystery of the locked door at the bottom of the Cathedral Ward in Bloodborne has been solved. Bloodborne, like earlier From Software games, is filled with doors that don’t open the first time you try them. Some will give you “locked” messages, others “does not open from this side”. Some of these will open […]

  • Assassin’s Creed creator Patrice Desilets is revealing his next game now [UPDATE: ended]

    Patrice Desilets, one of the original creators of Assassin’s Creed is hosting a presentation where he’s expected to talk about his next project. Patrice Desilets has emerged once again. This time he’s attending development conference in Croatia. Desilets is giving a live keynote and there’s a good chance we’re going to hear about his next […]

  • Destiny House of Wolves: everything you need to know about gear upgrades & The Reef

    Bungie revealed plenty of important details in last night’s Destiny stream. Let’s go over everything. Alex wants to make sure you don’t miss any of the information revealed yesterday. Most of it affects all Destiny players too, even those who don’t intend on buying House of Wolves. During the first stream, Bungie explained the armour […]

  • Mod-friendly Galactic Civilizations 3 will leave Steam Early Access in May

    Galactic Civilizations 3 will leave Steam Early Access next month for a full release, Stardok has announced. The developer called the game the “largest and most diverse strategy sandbox to date,” as players have a variety of tools such as diplomatic treaties to resource exchanges, and United Planets resolutions to hundreds of research directions for […]

  • Ys 6: The Ark of Napishtim is out next week on PC – here’s the pre-order trailer

    Ys 6: The Ark of Napishtim will be released next week on PC, and today, we have a pre-order trailer for you. The game will be made available on April 28 for $19.99/€17.99/£13.99 on GOG, the Humble Store and Steam. Along with improvements over the original PSP version, it will contain less backtracking, controller support […]

  • Destiny: House of Wolves – full gear set up to level 34 in PvP and PvE, upgrades, more

    The Destiny: House of Wolves livestream this afternoon was chock full of information. Read onward for our full report. According to Bungie, Petra Venj, who serves the Queen, is the main story agent who leads the player through the main series of quests. Players who complete bounties will be able to level up in her […]

  • Destiny: House of Wolves – watch the livestream right here

    Bungie will host a Destiny: House of Wolves livestream at 2pm EDT today, and you can watch it right here. Watch live video from Bungie on www.twitch.tv The stream will introduce the new social space, The Reef, as well as gear upgrade paths. House of Wolves contains new Strike missions, The Prison of Elders three-player […]

  • FIFA Ultimate Team: week of April 22 team includes Barcelona, Chelsea players

    This week’s FIFA 15 Team of the Week is now available for FIFA Ultimate Team players. Each team member, as with previous weeks, is selected base on the previous weekend’s matches. Here’s the list of players now available: Starting GK: Claudio Bravo – FC Barcelona (Spain) CB: Leonardo Bonucci – Juventus (Italy) CB: Ömer Toprak […]

  • Sony’s Spring Fever Sale winds down with Shovel Knight and Call of Duty discounts

    It’s the final week of Sony’s Spring Fever Sale which means more games have been added to the mix. Shovel Knight, which launches today is one offer, and the rest are all Cal of Duty titles. The Taken movie series is on sale as well. With Shovel Knight available today on PlayStation 3, PS4 and […]

  • Drivers for Xbox controllers, voice messages, more features available in Xbox One preview

    Microsoft has announced new features coming to Xbox One and the Xbox App on Windows 10 through the preview program this month. Some of the new features have been requested by the community for both Xbox One and Xbox One SmartGlass. Here’s what to expect, straight from the horse’s mouth: Xbox on Windows 10 Game […]

  • Total War: Warhammer has been announced for PC, Mac, SteamOS

    Total War: Warhammer has been announced after previous teases from The Creative Assembly touched upon it. The game will contain “gigantic monsters, flying creatures, legendary heroes and storms of magical power.” It is also the first in a trilogy which includes two additional standalone titles and extra content packs. It will feature thousands of warriors […]

  • This video for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt features a quest from the prologue

    A new video for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt has been released, showing off the Precious Cargo quest contained in the game’s prologue. The quest tasks Geralt with helping a merchant retrieve a mysterious box from the swamps. The scene looks familiar, but we’ve seen so many videos for the game it’s hard to tell […]

  • Limited public beta for The Elder Scrolls Online kicks off tomorrow on consoles

    The limited public beta for The Elder Scrolls Online: Tamriel Unlimited will launch on PlayStation 4 and Xbox One tomorrow, and Sony has provided details on the tester for those who’ve been invited to participate. The beta test contains the full version of the game and will run from April 23-27, and will start and […]

  • Dying Light debuts in second place on Media Create charts

    Techland’s Dying Light made its debut in Japan lats week, coming in a respectable second place behind Nintendo’s Girls Mode 3: Kirakira Code. The zombie shooter sold 25,530 units on PlayStation 4, while the top earner for the week moved a little over 55,000 units on 3DS. Another western release when landed on the chart, […]

  • Lord of Magna: Maiden Heaven will release in the west this June

    Lord of Magna: Maiden Heaven has been given a release date by XSEED Games, which announced the localization back in February. The title will launch for 3DS in North America on June 2 digitally and through retail. It will be an eShop only title in Europe and Australia when it releases on June 4. A […]

  • This Overlord video teases four new faces of evil

    A new Overlord game is in the works, going by the previous teasing and this video – which teases the possibility of four-payer co-op. Or just four characters to choose from. We don’t know just yet – all we know is the team is asking you to “join the fellowship.” A new entry in the […]

  • GTA movie will star Daniel Radcliffe as Rockstar’s Sam Houser, the BBC confirms

    The GTA movie Game Changer will star Daniel Radcliffe as Rockstar co-founder and president Sam Houser, theBBC has confirmed. The BBC also confirmed Bill Paxton will play Jack Thompson, a role Paxton already confirmed last week when speaking with Deadline. Here’s the synopsis per the BBC: “Conceived for an adult audience, this special 90-minute drama […]

  • Take a look at Etrian Odyssey 2 Untold’s Classic Mode

    Etrian Odyssey 2 Untold’s Classic Mode has received a trailer today. Etrian Odyssey 2 Untold will come with two modes, Classic and Story. Classic Mode was trailered today and in it, you’ll get to make your party by choosing from 13 classes. You’ll be able to customise them too using the character creation tool. Revamped […]

  • Shovel Knight: Plague of Shadows to come with new challenge mode

    Shovel Knight’s upcoming expansion Plague of Shadows will bring with it a new challenge mode. Shovel Knight developer Yacht Club Games has revealed the challenge mode, one of the new additions coming to the game with the free Plague of Shadows expansion. “Are you more into digging than distillation? Already have your Feats book long […]

  • Nvidia releases complete graphical guide for GTA 5

    Those with GeForce cards will be happy to know that Nvidia has released a comprehensive graphical tweaks guide for GTA 5. Nvidia usually produces graphical guides for the big AAA games, and GTA 5 is no different. Their guides offer in-depth coverage of each in-game setting, how much they affect framerate, if they can be […]

  • Cthulhu voodoo: why Bloodborne is the best Lovecraftian game

    Sherif Said tackles Bloodborne’s links to Lovecraftian horror, explaining why you should face the madness and immerse yourself in its lore. Spoilers inside. No other game could commit to its themes so religiously without feeling the need to compromise its vision and veer towards accessibility. Bloodborne stands tall above any game that dares attach itself […]

  • WWE 2K15 is coming to PC this year

    WWE 2K15 will make its way to PC this spring. WWE announced that WWE 2K15 will make its debut on PC in the spring. The game will be based on the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions, both of which came out in November. MyCareer and 2K Showaces modes are included, as well as all […]

  • GTA 5 PC: new mod adds snow to GTA Online

    If you’re looking to get some snow in your GTA Online, someone figured out a way. Modder ECB2 created a mod that works with GTA Online on PC. The mod is called “Snow in GTA Online” and it does what it says on the tin. YouTube channel imperfectplayers captured a video showing it in action. […]

  • Deals with Gold: Call of Duty edition

    Xbox Live Deals with Gold for the week of April 20 are now live with mostly Call of Duty games. Various Call of Duty games are on sale on Xbox One and Xbox 360 through Xbox Live this week. Indie games Never Alone and We Are Doomed managed to sneak in as well. With the […]

  • Mortal Kombat X: PSN sign in problems fixed in new patch

    Patch 1.03 is now live for Mortal Kombat X and it brings an end to the aggravating sing in issue encountered by some users on PS4. Mortal Kombat X 1.03 patch has been released. The patch fixes bug CE-34878-0, which affected the PlayStation 4 version. The bug caused users to have to log in and […]

  • GTA 5 PC: new patch fixes Windows Media Player issue, getting stuck in the clouds

    GTA 5 has received a new patch on PC to fix issues caused by the lack of Windows Media Player and getting stuck between online matches. Patch 335.1 is now available to all owners of GTA 5 on PC. The strange issue that affected those who didn’t have Windows Media Player installed, has been fixed. […]