Games Critics Award has announced its first annual Game of the Year Award. "Considering games across all platforms, released commercially in North America between January 1, 2007 and December 31, 2007, the judges have voted to decide on the best of the best for the year."
We thought the best of the best went to Top Gun. Apparently they go to Rapture.
2 The Orange Box
3 Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
4 Rock Band
5 Super Mario Galaxy
6 Halo 3
7 Mass Effect
8 God of War II
9 Assassin's Creed
10 Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
A list of judges can be found here. You can't say fairer than that, really.