Animal Crossing: New Horizons Redd Fake Art – How to spot fake paintings and statues

By James Billcliffe, Thursday, 25 June 2020 16:22 GMT

It’s time to add the study of fine art to your Animal Crossing: New Horizons Villager’s growing list of qualities. He’s a rare visitor, but the wily fox Jolly Redd is a returning vendor in Animal Crossing: New Horizons, selling masterpieces of “questionable” authenticity.

To broaden the knowledge of the arts on your island home, here’s how to unlock Redd’s Treasure Trawler, as well as tell whether his gallery of art is fake or real.

Redd was added post-launch in an update to New Horizons, and the Treasure Trawler peddles masterworks from around the world – but there’s a catch. In Redd’s inventory are pieces of deviously crafted fake art, paintings and statues, which could fool even the most meticulous collector. However, your old pal Blathers will be able to give anything you buy the definitive seal of approval.

All of the pieces are Animal Crossing versions of a world-famous tour-de-force by some of the most respected practitioners in history – including van Gogh, da Vinci, and Rembrandt, as well as classical Japanese artists.

Not only can you display these new art pieces in your home, but Blathers has opened a whole extra wing of the museum to show them off. By submitting pieces to the museum, you’ll get some extra information on their artist and creation.

How to spot Redd’s fake art, paintings and statues

If – like me – you haven’t had the luxury of whiling away the years on an art history degree, then the subtle discrepancies in the fake art pieces can be difficult to spot – especially the paintings.

To tell Redd’s fakes from the real deal, you’re looking for tiny differences in the Animal Crossing version to the real-life work. This can take the form of things that are missing, things that are added, things that have changed size, or things that have changed color from the original.

One tip is to use the zoomed-in view you get of a piece before you buy to thoroughly inspect it. But you can also speak to your regular villagers for a bit of extra info. If any of them mention they bought a specific fake painting or statue from Redd then you know the one he’s trying to sell you is fake too!

Refer to the lists below for a full run-down of what you need to know.

Redd’s Haunted Paintings and Statues

With a few of the faux masterpieces, it’s not just the mistakes that tip you off to their authenticity. There are a few works the community have dubbed “haunted” paintings and statues because of their habit of doing weird and wonderful things.

These include:

The haunted Ancient Statue which levitates from its podium.

The fake Wistful Painting and Scary Painting can both be haunted too – they blink and change their expression respectively. There’s also the fake Graceful Painting, which has a creepy shadowy figure appear on the back of its frame.

You can see all of them in the embedded video below (volume warning):

Animal Crossing: New Horizons Fake Paintings list

Below are all of the paintings that were datamined from Animal Crossing: New Horizons, including their real-world counterparts.

It is possible for Redd’s inventory to be all fake, the rotten scoundrel. If this happens, you can either buy one of the counterfeits to display in your own home or leave the trawler in a huff.

The differences between the authentic and fake paintings – as well as the statues – were reported on the r/AnimalCrossing subreddit by u/Acadiaa.

We’ve listed all of the errors which out them as fakes, as well as adding pictures of the real art, so you can make comparisons with what Redd’s stocking.

Click or tap the images for a larger view.

Animal Crossing: New Horizons Redd Fake Art List
Art Animal Crossing Name:Art Real Name:Real vs Fake:What the real-life painting looks like:
Academic PaintingThe Vitruvian Man by Leonardo da Vinci Fake has stain in the top right corner
Amazing PaintingThe Night Watch by RembrandtIn the fake, the man in the middle with a red sash is not wearing a hat
Basic PaintingThe Blue Boy by Thomas GainsboroughIn the fake, the Blue Boy has a full fringe (bangs) with no gaps for his forehead
Calm Painting A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte by Georges SeuratHas no fake
Common PaintingThe Gleaners by Jean-Francois MilletHas no fake
Detailed PaintingRooster and Hen with Hydrangeas by Ito JakuchuFake is missing the japanese script on the left-hand side of the painting
Dynamic PaintingThe Great Wave off Kanagawa by HokusaiIn previous games, there was a fake version where the island in the background was too big, but reported to have no fake in New Horizons
Famous PaintingThe Mona LisaFake has saucy arched eyebrows
Flowery PaintingSunflowers by Vincent van GoghHas no fake
Glowing PaintingThe Fighting Temeraire by Joseph TurnerHas no fake
Graceful PaintingBeauty Looking Back by Hishikawa MoronobuIn the fake, the figure is too big -she should only take up about half the brown background
Jolly PaintingSummer by Giuseppe ArcimboldoReal has a flower protruding from chest, the fake does not
Moody PaintingThe Sower by Jean-Francois MilletHas no fake
Moving PaintingThe Birth of Venus by Sandro Botticelli The fake has no trees in the top right corner
Mysterious Painting The Isle of the Dead or Die Toteninsel by Arnold BocklinHas no fake
Nice PaintingThe Fifer by Edouard ManetHas no fake
Perfect PaintingStill Life with Apples and Oranges by Paul CezanneHas no fake
Proper Painting A Bar at the Folies-Bergere by Edouard ManetHas no fake
Quaint PaintingThe Milkmaid by Johannes VermeerFake is pouring a lot more milk
Scary PaintingKabuki Actor Ōtani Oniji III as Yakko Edobei in the Play The Colored Reins of a Loving Wife by Toshusai Sharaku The fake has eyebrows that point up like the figure is confused, whereas they should be pointed down in a frown
Scenic PaintingThe Hunters in the Snow or The Return of the Hunters by Pieter BruegelFake only has one hunter on the left and fewer dogs
Serene PaintingLady with an Ermine by Leonardo da VinciThe ermine is white in the real painting, it's different colors in the fake
Sinking PaintingOphelia by John Everett MillaisHas no fake
Solemn Painting Las Meninas or The Ladies-in-waiting by Diego VelazquezIn the fake, the man in the background has his arm pointed up like he's waving, in the real one it's more horizontal
Twinkling Painting Starry Night by Vincent van GoghHas no fake
Warm Painting The Clothed Maja or La Maja Vestida by Francisco de GyoaHas no fake
Wild Painting Left HalfWind God and Thunder God by Ogata Korin (Raijin)Figure should be white in real painting, but he's green in the fake
Wild Painting Right HalfWind God and Thunder God by Ogata Korin (Fuujin)Figure should be green in the real painting, but is white in the fake
Wistful PaintingThe Girl with the Pearl Earring by Johannes VermeerThe girl has a big star earring in the fake
Worthy PaintingLiberty Leading the People by Eugène DelacroixHas no fake

Animal Crossing: New Horizons Fake Statues list

If you’re more of an outdoorsy type, here are all of the statues that were datamined from Animal Crossing: New Horizons.

We’ve rounded up a list of everything that makes the bogus ones fake, and included a picture of the real thing for your reference. You can click or tap the images for a larger view.

Animal Crossing: New Horizons Redd Fake Statues List
Statue Animal Crossing Name:Statue Real Name:Real vs Fake:What the real-life statue looks like:
Ancient StatueA Doguu figureThe fake has pointy antennae on the side of its head
Beautiful StatueVenus de MiloThe fake has a necklace on
Familiar StatueThe Thinker or Le Penseur by Auguste RodinHas no fake
Gallant StatueDavid by Michelangelo Fake is holding something under his arm
Great StatueHawaiian Kamehameha statue Has no fake
Informative StatueThe Rosetta StoneThe fake one is blue
Motherly StatueThe Capitoline WolfThe wolf in the fake statue has a tongue hanging out of her mouth
Mystic StatueBust of NefertitiThe fake statue is wearing an earring
Robust StatueThe Discobolus of MyronThe fake is wearing a band around its discus-throwing wrist
Rock-head StatueOlmec HeadThe fake one is smiling
Tremendous StatueHoumuwu dingThe fake has a cover on the box, the real one is left open
Valiant StatueThe Winged Victory of SamothraceOn the real statue, its bare left leg is visible
Warrior StatueEmperor Qinshihuang's Terracotta ArmyThe fake is leaning on a long weapon in front of it - the real one doesn't hold anything

How to get art and unlock Redd’s Treasure Trawler

There’s actually quite an involved process to get Redd’s Treasure Trawler to visit with art and statues for your island.

For a visual guide, this video from YouTuber TagBackTV shows the whole process, but we’ll write it out too:

First, you need to make sure you’ve downloaded the latest update so that all of the content will appear in-game. Next, go to Blathers in the town Museum and he’ll have an announcement: a new fine art wing of the building is being planned.

Blathers will ask you to keep an eye out for art to put on display, and to bring him any you find.

Now wait until the next day and look around your island. You should find a new visitor – the sneaky orange fox, Redd. He’s managed to drop his “crazy” moniker from previous games, but he’s no less wily.

Speak to Redd and he’ll offer you a totally legit piece of artwork for the low-low price of about 500,000 bells. When you baulk at the figure he’ll drop the sum 100-fold, and you’ll only have to pay about 5000 bells. From what I’ve seen, the first piece of art Redd sells you will be real. But different people will get different works. For example I got the Wistful Painting of Girl with a Pearl Earring, while TagBackTV in the video got the Academic Painting of The Vitruvian Man.

Take him up on the cut-price deal, then go and show the art to Blathers. With the pristine painting now in his possession, Blathers will begin construction on the new-and-improved Museum.

That means it’ll be closed for a full day while renovations take place.

Once it’s done-and-dusted, you’ll be able to peruse the fine art room of the Museum. Head back outside for a celebratory ceremony if you want to have one, then look around your island.

The devious Redd should appear again on your island, only this time when you speak to him he’ll say he’s dropped anchor on the northern shore of your island.

Now you can head up to his Treasure Trawler to visit Redd’s art gallery showroom. It should be on the secluded beach that’s in the middle of the northern shore of your island – you’ll need a ladder to get there.

Inside, there will be two furniture pieces, and four pieces of art.

However you need to be selective; you can only buy one piece of art per day, although you can grab as many furniture pieces on top of that as you like.

Redd is an island visitor like Gulliver and Saharah, so he won’t be there every day. Once you’ve purchased a painting or statue he’ll ship it to your mailbox to collect the next day.

For more on Animal Crossing: New Horizons, check out our lists of all of the fish prices, as well as all of the bug prices.

Or if you’re more excited about the new stuff coming to your island, here’s how the upgrade to Nook’s Cranny happens!

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.