From Dark Souls to DayZ: the high-risk, high-reward cycle of masochistic gaming

By Brenna Hillier
30 June 2014 08:14 GMT

Jump to page: 1 2

What is it about games that punish us for failure that is so damn addictive?


“Some triple-A games will quietly masturbate themselves to completion if you just hold the left analog stick forward.”

If you spend a lot of time reading comment threads on video game websites, you’ll probably be familiar with the opinion that games are getting easier. Older gamers often grumble that the industry push for “accessibility” has stripped the challenge out of games, and younger gamers are often so hyped up on the ultra-competitive multiplayer culture that they’re incapable of admitting that they find a game difficult for fear of being called a wuss.

The drive to open blockbuster games to larger audiences has certainly left us with some amusing anomalies (some triple-A games will quietly masturbate themselves to completion if you just hold the left analog stick forward), even as the difficulties of the ubiquitous twin-analog, eight-button control scheme remains a barrier to bringing new players in. But over the past few years we’ve seen a resurgence of interest in – and sales of – games that demand much, much more from their players.

If it were one or two divisive titles we could dismiss this phenomenon as a blip in history, but we’re talking about some of the most popular and celebrated titles in recent years. What is it about masochistic games that has sucked us in, chewed us up, spat us out – and left us begging for more? Let’s look at a couple of case studies.

Dark Souls

Dark Souls is the poster child for brutally difficult games with huge mainstream recognition. Building on the cult success for forerunner Demon’s Souls, Dark Souls came into the world with a reputation for being hard as a technophile let loose in Yamada Denki. That’s an irresistible lure for many gamers who fancy their 733t sk177z cannot be topped, and especially for Xbox 360 fans who had been denied a crack at Demon’s Souls and wanted to prove themselves tougher than their PS3 brethren. Namco Bandai’s marketing didn’t miss a trick in capitalising on this fearsome reputation, and the rest is top ten chart history.


“The success of Dark Souls is that it is beatable, once you learn the rules. Physical dexterity is required, but it’s not beyond the average gamer.”

You’ll still hear the occasional dissenter, of course. The whole Souls formula evolved from the old-school days, when Japanese gamers would band together on bulletin boards to figure out how to play largely incomprehensible western RPGs. As such, the series can feel deeply unfair to beginners: one-hit kills, ambushes, inexplicable strengths and weaknesses, and a supreme lack of hand holding come as a serious shock to the system. “Why would you do this to yourself?” detractors ask. “Why not go play something fun?”

For those who push on through, or who have a friend on hand to help them weather the initial adjustment period, the fun soon becomes apparent. A dear friend of mine tried to play on a couple of occasions, giving up after an hour or two each time. On his third go, though, he was determined to push on through, loaded up with tips and tricks from the internet. He still didn’t seem to be enjoying himself very much, but one day he messaged me to say something like “I’m just sitting here thinking: I bet I could beat that boss if I just tried such-and-such. I just want to load it up and have one go. Is this how Dark Souls is supposed to feel?”

Yes, it is. The success of Dark Souls is that it is beatable, once you learn the rules. Physical dexterity is required, but it’s not beyond the average gamer – as long as they are mindful of the rules. Slowly exploring and figuring out what the game is throwing at you (or reading a walkthrough and consulting friends, in the spirit of the original premise) is a delight, and the first time you sit bolt upright in bed and exclaim “I bet he can’t shoot me through that pillar but I could totally lob a fireball around it” or similar is when you know it has its hold on you.

The mechanics of Dark Souls and friends are actually pretty generous: your time is not wasted when you die, as you respawn at the last checkpoint activated – although these are few and far between. Any items you find remain yours, and any bosses you kill remain dead. And even souls, which represent currency and XP, will only be lost if you die twice in a row without reaching your own bloodstain. Plus, there are no survival mechanics such as hunger or thirst to hurry you into trouble when you should be exploring carefully, and From Software is not above celebrating exploits if they’re clever enough.

Next: A look at DayZ and what both games have in common.

Jump to page: 1 2

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our policy.

VG247 logo

Buy our t-shirts, yeah

They're far more stylish than your average video game website tat.

VG247 merch