If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.

GTA 4 may have a better frame-rate on Xbox One, but you're probably better off playing on Xbox 360

GTA 4 on Xbox One backwards compatibility is quite a peculiar thing.

Cover image for YouTube video

Last week, the Xbox 360 version of GTA 4 became playable on Xbox One thanks to the console's backwards compatibility.

As is usually the case with backwards compatible games, the transition doesn't always result in a performance improvements. Thanks to outlets like Digital Foundry, though, we get to actually find out if Xbox One is the best way to play the game.

The case of GTA 4 is complicated, as the site's recent analysis revealed. According to Digital Foundry, though raw frame-rate has improved, this may not be such a good thing.

You can expect up to a 5fps increase in some spots, but it's the frame-pacing issue that sours the experience. Xbox One delivers new frames at a rate very different from the Xbox 360 version's, and much later than the standard 16ms and 33ms intervals.

"It feels choppier and more uneven, while controller latency - hardly one of the game's strongest points on original hardware - sometimes feels significantly laggier on Xbox One. In certain areas, frame-pacing seems to normalise but by and large, in-game performance seems less stable," the site noted in the analysis.

Although these observations only apply to the main GTA 4 campaign for now, not including the Ballad of Gay Tony and The Lost and Damned, something doesn't feel quite right.

"As things stand, GTA4 is one of a small number of back-compat titles that we'd prefer to play on Xbox 360 instead, and we hope that the back-compat team goes back to take a closer look at the frame-pacing issues here," the site concludes.

The DLC add-ons will be tested later, but for now, things don't look promising.

Sign in and unlock a world of features

Get access to commenting, homepage personalisation, newsletters, and more!

In this article

Grand Theft Auto

PC

Grand Theft Auto IV

PS3, Xbox 360, PC

Related topics
About the Author
Sherif Saed avatar

Sherif Saed

Contributor

Sherif (he/him) is VG247’s go-to shooter and Souls-likes person. Whether it’s news, reviews, or op-eds – Sherif is always eager to tell you about video games. He's one of VG247's most veteran writers, with 10+ years experience on the site.

Comments