Sections

UPDATE: indies hit by Content ID on their own trailers, Twitter rage ensues

Wednesday, 18 December 2013 08:48 GMT By Dave Cook

YouTubers across the world are reporting a torrent of YouTube Content ID warnings landing in their inboxes in what is the start of a crackdown on monetised video game content. Get up-to-date reports on the matter here.

UPDATE 6: A host of indie developers have found Content ID claims in their inboxes now, from companies Indmusic and Tunecore, based on songs that they themselves have created.

Thomas Was Alone developer Mike Bithell was first to hit out at Indmusic on Twitter:

Vlambeer’s Rami Ismail tweeted out a fair warning to his fellow indies:

VVVVVV developer Terry Cavanagh was also stung by Content ID claims on his own trailers:

The simple answer seems to stop working with Indmusic and Tunecore from now on, but the whole issue appears to be far from simple right now. Both companies have failed to comment on the matter, and we’re still waiting for Idol to get back to us on the initial run of content strikes. That’s been a week now.

Via CVG.

UPDATE 5: YouTuber GnomeWrecker has tweeted that despite the Content ID match issued removing his revenue streams, his contract with media company Maker/Polaris is now locked. The legally-binding contract suggests that even though Gnome’s revenue from YouTube has been hit, he still has to create content under his contract.

Despite being contract bound, Gnome added that Maker/Polaris didn’t have much to do with the creation of his content:

Regarding the issue The Escapist’s Jim Sterling confirmed Gnome’s predicament:

We’ve asked Gnome to further clarify his position at present. Via Splatteredhouse.

UPDATE 4: Oddworld Inhabitants and Just Add Water have posted a blog update on the YouTube Content ID issue. It reads, “We at Oddworld Inhabitants, Inc. would like to reassure YouTubers that we continue to give our explicit permission to anyone on the service to broadcast using Oddworld games, including Abe’s Oddysee, Abe’s Exoddus, Munch’s Oddysee, Stranger’s Wrath, and the upcoming New ‘n’ Tasty (and any updated, HD versions).This includes Let’s Plays, commercial trailers, and screen shots.

“In fact, nothing makes us happier than to see you guys enjoying our games, and it’s something we encourage wholeheartedly. So as we’ll continue to push our content through our own YouTube channel, we have no plans to issue copyright claims to others.If you are on the end of one of these new ContentID copyright flags as a result of showing Oddworld game footage, please contact us.

UPDATE 3: Valve has just stepped forward to give gamers its blessing, and to actively encourage YouTubers to make videos using its games.

It comes in a post published by the company, which reads, “We encourage our users to make videos using Valve game content, such as playthrough or instruction videos or SFM movies. We are fine with publishing these videos to your website or YouTube or similar video sharing services. We’re not fine with taking assets from our games (e.g. voice, music, items) and distributing those separately.

“Use of our content in videos must be non-commercial. By that we mean you can’t charge users to view or access your videos. You also can’t sell or license your videos to others for a payment of any kind.

“You are free to monetize your videos via the YouTube partner program and similar programs on other video sharing sites. Please don’t ask us to write YouTube and tell them its fine with us to post a particular video using Valve content. It’s not possible to respond to each such request. Point them to this page.

“Of course this policy applies only to Valve content. If you include someone else’s content in your video, such as music, you will have to get permission from the owner.”

UPDATE 2: YouTuber DPJ has published a video guide explaining possible ways to skirt around Content ID strikes. Watch it below:

UPDATE:

YouTuber Angry Joe has revealed that 62 of his videos have been flagged by the video service’s Content ID system. On the video he calls out those making the claims over music used in videos, footage and original content like his Tomb Raider interview. He also cites the Fair Use clauses found in US law and accuses YouTube of waiting until channels generated millions of views before using Content ID strikes to take money away from creators.

He argues that seeking permission for game review videos will see negative reviews rejected by publishers, and that the approval process will damage content creators, not to mention take away what is essentially free advertising for the game creators and publishers.

Joe adds that he cannot get in touch with YouTube and any channels he’s tried have resulted in no response. An official YouTube statement in the Content ID format reads, “We recently enabled Content ID scanning on channels identified as affiliates of MCNs. This has resulted in new copyright claims for some users, based on policies set by the relevant content owners. As ever, channel owners can easily dispute Content ID claims if they believe those claims are invalid.”

So this means that yes, this is now an official policy at YouTube. It begs the question why Content ID match claims are coming from companies with no visible links from game publishers

ORIGINAL STORY:

The breaking news and reports are being compiled into a NeoGAF thread, which suggests many companies are now approaching content creators with Content ID claims.

Force Strategy Gaming has posted a discussion explaining what is going on among the video creation community.

They explain that there’s a YouTube monetisation review process going on in about a month, and that over the past week, many video creators have started receiving a vast amount of Content IDMatch claims on their footage, mostly from a company called ‘IDOL,’ a prominent music distribution firm.

Force Strategy feels that videos containing cut-scenes, trailers and game music are among the most common claims. He stresses that 10-seconds of a trailer is considered fair use, and that anything over that will increase the chances of a person receiving a claim. One way around claims is to become affiliated with an approved channel like Machinima.

However, VG247′s source – who runs a managed channel and serves over 6.7 million views a month – stresses that publishers are now coming forward to say that it isn’t them making the claims. Claims are, instead, coming from IDOL and are largely linked to music used in clips.

Our source told us, “YouTube flipped a switch 2 days ago and it seemingly matches any copyrighted footage (seems to be game audio) with their music library and then gives out content ID claims. IDOL is a company that distributes many individual music companies, which is why they’re linked to many of the claims.”

We’ve asked IDOL to comment.

Claims are coming thick and fast without warning. Just look at TheRadBrad’s email inbox:

Other video creators have taken to Twitter and voiced their displeasure:

Videos can be approved by submitting them to YouTube’s confirmation process early next year, clearing them for monetisation. However the review process can take between a few hours to days. The issue is that approved content will be late and therefore will not make its creator as much money. Some of those in pre-approved relationships are still getting claims, but nowhere near the same volume.

There now seems to be a misunderstandaing and confusion over the rules for YouTubers deemed ‘Affiliate’ and ‘Managed.’ Are they exempt? Will they have their content culled? What are the rules? The impending changes were outlined in this press release, but confusion lingers.

On the Content ID changes coming for Affiliates and Managed users in January, our source added, “Starting Janaury, ‘affiliate’ partners = videos will be put into monetization review as opposed to the instant monetization we’ve all had for years, which is basically bad news for gaming channels as it takes YouTube days to review and there’s still no guarantee they’ll approve the claim unless you have permission from the company to monetize their IP.

“Managed” partners = exempt from all content ID claims and protected by both Google and its network. Instant monetization remains, etc. YouTube has told networks make your partners managed or affiliate. If the partner is affiliate, they can get copyright strikes and content ID claims, etc., and the network won’t be affected and won’t be responsible.

“If the network’s “managed” partners receive a single copyright strike throughout their entire “managed” partners whether that be 50 or 100, they get fined, penalized. 3 total copyright strikes is bad news for the network so they’ll only make MASSIVE and very valuable partners “managed” as they now share the responsibility of a copyright strike with a “managed” partner.

“If you’re managed, you’re fine and can monetize anything you want. If you’re affiliate, your’re royally fucked and you might as well just quit YouTube.

“Summary: 99% of YouTube gaming channels will die soon.”

For those doing this as a full time job, it surely comes as a huge blow. Publishers seemed to be using home-grown videos as an increasing avenue for coverage, and while games like Battlefield 4 have received plenty of videos from people like jackfrags that are – essentially – free advertising – you’d expect them to be encouraged, not nuked in this fashion.

Publishers aligned against new wave of copyright claims

Deep Silver‘s Maurice Tan said on Twitter that the publisher is not issuing any Content ID claims, later reinforcing this stance with a longer statement placing the blame on Idol and Shock Entertainment, encouraging users to dispute the claims, and confirming it has raised the issue with YouTube.

“Deep Silver has no intention of preventing players, who like to create gaming content on YouTube using our games, from doing so. Nor do we seek to block any videos of the kind. This includes Let’s Play, Walkthrough, Review, or other edited or commentated videos that are monetized by a player. Whether your opinion of our games is positive or negative in your YouTube video, it is not our right as a games publisher to infringe on your basic right to voice your opinion freely using a public platform,” the company said.

“We will be monitoring the changes on YouTube and any other online medium that lets our fans share their common passion for games, and react and adapt to facilitate our communities wherever they are. You will not be alone in this, whatever changes may come. Within the games industry, including at our competitors, there are many who share this vision. Adapting to change may sometimes take time, so we hope that the gaming community will be patient with not just us, but others as well, as we collectively strive to resolve any issues that arise.”

Ubisoft also issued a statement urging anyone who receives a claim from Idol to step forward and ask to have them removed.

Bossa Studios of Surgeon Simulator fame, issued a statement saying it wants to reassure YouTubers that it gives its “express permission to anyone who wishes to create Let’s Play or gaming commentary videos using our games.”

“We love to see people playing our games, and will continue to be actively involved with our fans and YouTube community,” said the firm in a statement to VG247. “YouTubers’ passion for what they do not only inspires other fans to play, but also the Bossa team to make our games better. We’re always excited to see what fans can do with our games.”

Here are similar responses from Capcom, Naughty Dog and Codemasters.

YouTube’s response

Meanwhile, YouTube has issued a statement on the matter to Game Informer, stating anyone who is issued an infringement notice can file a dispute.

“Nothing illustrates the incredible growth and evolution of YouTube better than the enterprise class of businesses being built on the platform today,” a YouTube spokesperson stated. “As these networks grow, we’re making product and policy updates that will help them operate at scale. We are also rolling out tools that will provide more transparency for creators and networks alike. This is part of our commitment to ensure that all enterprise partners can continue to thrive and be successful on YouTube.

“We recently enabled Content ID scanning on channels identified as affiliates of MCNs. This has resulted in new copyright claims for some users, based on policies set by the relevant content owners. As ever, channel owners can easily dispute Content ID claims if they believe those claims are invalid.”

Do you run a YouTube channel? Have you received strikes? If so, what’s your take on the matter?

Latest

  • Batman: Arkham Knight – Robin, Nightwing, Azrael star in new trailer

    Not long until now until the third part of the Arkham trilogy is released – here’s a new trailer showing some interesting team-ups. It looks like Robin, Nightwing and Azrael will all be making more than a cameo appearance. Batman: Arkham Knight is due on June 23 on PC, Xbox One and PS4. Thanks, TheDufase19089.

  • GTA 5 PC mods: falling whales, North Yankton unlocked and a cat rampage

    So how are those GTA 5 PC mods coming along? Quite nicely if we take a look at a batch of new mods for the game. It seems the community is having a fair bit of fun accessing restricted content and messing around with the local wildlife. Let’s start with a look at what happens […]

  • Manhunt is the best GTA 5 movie you’ll see today

    Created using the Rockstar Editor from GTA 5 on PC, this movie by AbsolutePab is pretty effin’ delicious. The three minute Manhunt action movie was created by the same guy behind this short inspired by The Purge and The Graffiti of Los Santos documentary. You should subscribe to AbsolutePab on YouTube. You really should.

  • Halo 5 Guardians getting limited edition Xbox One console

    Thinking of buying a new Xbox One? You might want to wait until October 27. Because Microsoft is planning to release a limited edition console alongside the game, as confirmed by 343 Industries studio head Josh Holmes. @juliocurt There is a limited edition console coming, yes. It hasn’t been revealed yet, but it’s pretty sweet. […]

  • Silent Hills reportedly cancelled, PT axed from PSN store

    Konami’s collaboration with Del Toro is over, playable demo to disappear on Wednesday Update: Konami has told Eurogamer that it will continue to work on the Silent Hill franchise and its contract with actor Norman Reedus has expired, although no other information specific to Silent Hills has been made clear. Original story: The Silent Hill […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 Zombies will be “totally unique, mind-blowing”

    Welcome back Treyarch’s “own unique brand of mind-fuckery” to Call of Duty. Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 developer Treyarch has said Zombies mode in this year’s game will be completely different to the campaign and multiplayer games. Speaking at a briefing last week, studio head Mark Lamia said players should expect something entirely different. […]

  • Meet the specialist classes of Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 multiplayer

    Hands-on impressions of four new classes and their special abilities shaking up Call of Duty multiplayer. What’s exciting about this year’s Call of Duty is that we were able to get hands on with three different multiplayer maps and four of the new classes this early in development. Although the number of maps is still […]

  • Here’s the PC specs for Call of Duty: Black Ops 3

    The PC specs for Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 have been confirmed well ahead of the game’s November 6 release. Releasing the specs over six months before the game is due highlights how far along the game is in development. The specs are designed with low end and high end builds in mind. Get […]

  • Open beta for Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 ahead of Nov 6 release date

    Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 will offer an open beta to every player who pre-orders the game. The open beta is for the three supported formats – PC, Xbox One and PS4 – there is no version of Black Ops 3 for PS3 or Xbox 360. Solid details for the beta are yet to […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 brings back 4-player co-op campaign

    This year’s Call of Duty campaign is designed specifically for four players to experience together. Let’s get boots on the ground, soldier. Don’t call it an Exo skeleton. Call it the Direct Neural Interface. Okay, it’s a little less catchy, but the DNI biotechnology in Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 will feel familiar to […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 – watch the first official trailer here

    Here’s the first full trailer for Call of Duty: Black Ops 3, due for release on November 6. Anyone who pre-orders the game will get access to the open beta. The game will be released on PS4, Xbox One and PC. You can read hands-on impressions of the multiplayer here, check out early info on […]

  • Dota 2 International Compendium out next week, three annual championships added

    Valve has announced its adding three, yearly Dota 2 championships to its eSports roster along with the new that a new International Compendium will launch next week alongside a balance update for MOBA. The firm said it was adding three extra championships to the schedule as it recognized there was “room for improvement” on a […]

  • Dungeons 2 is now available on PC, Mac, Linux – watch the launch trailer

    Dungeons 2, the dungeon-crawling strategy sequel to Realmforge Studios’ Dungeons, has been released on Steam by publisher Kalypso. It can be yours for $39.99 on Steam and is available for Windows, Linux, Mac and SteamOS. The first game was released in 2011 and heavily influenced by Dungeon Keeper. A boxed version will arrive in North […]

  • This Mortal Kombat X “hidden character intros” video is rather humorous

    YouTuber Maximilian Dood mad has created a Mortal Kombat X video featuring “hidden” character intros centering around Scorpion and Sub-Zero. Some of the dialogue is rather funny, and we particularly liked the affectionate line uttered by Sub-Zero at one point. Just something fun for your Saturday. Enjoy.

  • Art of the Catch creator sheds more light on why he pulled the Skyrim mod off Steam

    The creator of Skyrim mod Art of the Catch has taken to Reddit to explain why he pulled the paid mod off Steam Workshop. Yesterday, it was revealed Chesko had pulled the fishing mod off Steam Workshop, after mod creator Fore stated he didn’t endorse Chesko charging for the mod because it used his his […]

  • Tripwire adds clause to Killing Floor 2 EULA banning paid mods

    Tripwire Interactive has updated its EULA for Killing Floor 2 stating that any mods players create for the game must be distributed free-of-charge. The end user agreement update, via PCgamesN, went live a couple of days after Valve announced it would allow mod creators to start charging for their creations. Bethesda is the first company […]

  • Five Nights at Freddy’s 3 recreated in LittleBigPlanet 3 is rather eerie

    LittleBigPlanet 3 players have created some really interesting content with the game’s level builder, but sometimes, the creations go beyond cute and bright and venture into the realm of creepy, as is the case with this Five Nights at Freddy’s 3 build. Created by TheLittleBigPlanetShow, the rather ominous level can be played with up to […]

  • Final Fantasy 14: Heavensward benchmark trailer shows off flying mounts, more

    Square Enix has released a rather nice benchmark video for Final Fantasy 14: Heavensward showing a battle, flying mounts and some of the new environments. Heavensward is the first expansion for Final Fantasy 14 and is slated for release on June 23 for PC, PlayStation 3 and PS4. The mac version is being handled by […]

  • Have a look at some Xenoblade Chronicles X gameplay

    During yesterday’s Xenoblade Chronicles X Nintendo Direct showcase, many details pertaining to the Monolith Soft title were announced, and quite a bit of gameplay was shown. The Wii U-exclusive contains real-time menu-based combat and four-player online questing along with diverse environments and the ability to use Skells, which are transforming mechs. These mechs are called […]

  • Here’s a look at The Elder Scrolls Online running on Xbox One

    The Elder Scrolls Online has a limited public beta test running this weekend on PS4 and Xbox One, and Eurogamer has been playing around in it. Have a look at the Khajiit sorcerer below in the Xbox One version. There isn’t an NDA in place for the beta, so expect to see more videos as […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 leaks reveal Zombie progression system, four-player co-op, more

    More Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 details surfaced overnight thanks to a leaked pamphlet with information pertaining to Zombies XP progression, four-player co-op and more. Posted on NeoGAF, the pamphlet the shooter will contain a new movement system, a Specialist character system for multiplayer, tailored maps, “cinematic arena-style play,” and complete character customization. The […]

  • Gears of War Remaster in the works for Xbox One, according to testers – report

    Overnight, a rumor surfaced claiming a remastered version of the original Gears of War was coming to Xbox One. According to playtesters, it isn’t a rumor at all. Polygon first broke the story, citing a source who showed the site sreencaps of the Locust invasion with updated visuals. Screenshots of the multiplayer showing improved lighting […]

  • GameStop promo outs Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 for November, pre-order for access to beta

    Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 will be released in November, according to what appears to be a leaked GameStop store promo posted on Kotaku. The exact date is November 6, which isn’t a surprise to anyone. On the promo, it notes that those who pre-order will be granted beta access for PC, PlayStation 4 […]

  • Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare Double XP and Elite Bonus weekend has kicked off

    Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare players can earn Double XP along with Elite Bonus on all platforms. There is even Double XP and Double Weapon XP on offer for Black Ops 2. The dry run is over. Prep for the Sunday reveal of #BlackOps3 begins now. 2XP/2XweapXP is live. pic.twitter.com/rn6SVtVJbY — Treyarch Studios (@Treyarch) April […]

  • Atlus makes “minor edits” to Dungeon Travelers 2 in order to avoid AO rating

    Atlus has announced it has made “minor edits” to four in-game images contained in Dungeon Travelers 2 to avoid an AO rating by the ESRB. According to a press release from the company, localization sometimes require changes to content in order for it to be “understood en masse,” which is why it worked closely with […]

  • Battlefield Hardline is 40% off through Origin this weekend

    The standard edition of Battlefield Hardline on PC is 40% off this weekend through EA’s Origin service. The Digital Deluxe Edition is also 40% off and includes various Battlepacks unavailable in the standard version. You can also pick up the Battlefield Hardline Ultimate edition for 23% off, which comes with all four planned expansions through […]

  • Submerged is an exploration-adventure game coming to multiple platforms

    Submerged is the latest title in development from Uppercut Games, and the exploration-adventure game is coming to PlayStation 4 and other platforms this year. The game takes place in a flooded city which Miku and her wounded brother Taku have reached by boat. Miku needs to find a safe place for her brother to rest […]

  • These screenshots for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt show superb attention to detail

    Some gorgeous new screenshots for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt have surfaced, and a couple are wallpaper worthy. Especially the one with the horse, but as you’re well aware, I’m horse crazed. The images below in the gallery have been scaled to fit properly, but if you head over to NeoGAF you can bask in […]

  • Namco kicks off Humble Store partnership with Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin

    Namco Bandai has started offering its PC titles on Humble Store, and this includes the recently released Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin. Other titles include Dragon Ball Xenoverse, and Project Cars. “In Japan, the Bandai Namco Group companies are known for supporting different charity programs and we are very happy to be […]

  • World of Tanks: 2,000 Bonus codes to give away

    Already have a World of Tanks account? We’ve got 2,000 codes for players to top up their Gold and Premium days. This weekend sees the World of Tanks Grand Finals take place in Poland, and we’ve got a bunch of game codes to give away to celebrate. Each Bonus PC code offers 150 Gold and […]

82 Comments

  1. Kieran

    Its weird why they would ban free advertising

    #1 1 year ago
  2. GrimRita

    @1 because they are stupid. Most publishers and Marketing tits don’t understand just how vital ‘Lets Play’ and other such videos are.

    But I guess its all about greed and poor Youtube are caught up in a lawsuit over copyright and have to act.

    All publishers seem to care about is the short life span of their game, the limited DLC and how much they can get back before they make another generic game

    Sad day for the gamer
    Consumers 1-1 Retarded Publishers

    #2 1 year ago
  3. MFBB

    #1 they dont want you to earn money with it, which is kinda understandable.

    Someone uses your product (music/video/game/IP etc) and makes money without asking you or offering you some of those profits.

    You know someone like PewDiePie at the top of Youtube, is earning around 4-5 million dollars 2013 using music/games content from companies etc.

    They want some of that profit for sure.

    #3 1 year ago
  4. Eregol

    Guess this is why videogamer.com isn’t putting their stuff on Youtube at the moment.

    #4 1 year ago
  5. Dave Cook

    @2 It’s not publishers issuing the strikes.

    #5 1 year ago
  6. SplatteredHouse

    https://twitter.com/TiLMEN/status/410722530597408768 also, The Jimquisition covered this topic yesterday: http://www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/jimquisition/8565-Copyright-War

    #6 1 year ago
  7. jon_

    Well, Capcom striked one of the videos on my website Youtube channel because I used like 5 seconds of Dead Rising 3 Launch Trailer, I tried to get the claim removed and got a message saying “Capcom declined to remove the report so the video cannot be monetized in any way and also it could be removed from your channel”.
    Great.

    #7 1 year ago
  8. Dave Cook

    @7 That goes completely against their claim that hey’re not making strikes. Thanks for exposing that one Jon.

    @6 Yep, but we just got a whole ton of quotes and new info on the matter. I’ll check out Jim’s piece after lunch.

    #8 1 year ago
  9. SplatteredHouse

    @5 Absolutely it isn’t. The publishers are stepping in to fend off the claims by authorising usage, once they are made aware of the incidents. Youtube/content producers not having to take on faceless multimedia license holder themselves is bound to be a relief to many.

    @Dave I haven’t been able to view the vid myself, yet, but Jim’s new Escapist position, (that site’s high video output, along with his own YT activity) would suggest to me he might have something worth hearing on this.

    #9 1 year ago
  10. hives

    It’s silly. People will just go to their own websites, like RedLetterMedia.

    Shame what YouTube has become. I mean, striking down video, not even LP, but news video, because there was 12 seconds of boss battle music in background…?

    And the new monetization review system will kill all news channells. Waiting 2 days for aproval? Yeah, sure…

    I just hope all good YouTubers will be fine after taking their videos elsewhere.

    #10 1 year ago
  11. TheBlackHole

    What. A. Joke.

    Love TheRadBrad’s channel.

    #11 1 year ago
  12. Joe Musashi

    “I hate so much that companies are now making money off of my voice and my work.”

    Somebody needs to get a sense of perspective.

    I greatly enjoy Lets Play videos and the like, but this action only serves to reinforce how deluded people are when it comes to content ownership and rights – and the right to profit from material owned by others.

    JM

    #12 1 year ago
  13. CyberMarco

    It’s like FIAT asking me to pay them royalties for using my (bought) car for taxi fares!

    #13 1 year ago
  14. xxxGamesMasterxxx

    There’s a new war coming “The Copyright War”, Prepare for mayhem.

    #14 1 year ago
  15. SplatteredHouse

    This Tetraninja? reached out to larger channels after he’s found himself with 400 vids and climbing that have been claimed against https://twitter.com/TetraNinja/status/410451595235561472
    Shows how much of these channels I watch. There’s just very little time I want to spend watching other people play a game, unless the focus is on “critiquing” of the subject matter, in which I’m already sufficiently interested in hearing about.
    (inb4, buttherearereviewsforthatlol)

    That aside, I hope they get a new stake put in the ground soon. Permitting claiming against anything existing seems bizarre, if not also opportunistic in the extreme. Youtube, what is it doing?

    #15 1 year ago
  16. Cobra951

    @13: Interesting analogy. But the legitimate claims would be more like you’re using technology stolen from your car on a new product that you are marketing successfully. How many of them are legitimate? I have no idea. But I do know that copyright must be protected by the owner, or it is lost. It’s a legal requirement. It could be these are just greedy, corporate bad guys. But I’m not ready to conclude that just yet. I need to read more about the whole mess.

    #16 1 year ago
  17. SplatteredHouse

    https://twitter.com/JimSterling/status/410779054502326272 @16 Claims of that nature can only be illegitimate. More: “The videos they’re flagging are all explicitly parody ones using trailer footage. It’s so dumb.”

    #17 1 year ago
  18. The_Red

    Guys… guys!? What happened to YouTube?
    First they did the horrible overhaul of comment system a few weeks ago and now this, which is a million times worse than anything SEGA or Nintendo have doing to the videos with their games.

    #18 1 year ago
  19. Cobra951

    Interesting. Seems like the perfect opportunity for some upstart to grab a piece of Youtube’s market. Creativity needs a less monolithic outlet than Google.

    #19 1 year ago
  20. CyberMarco

    @Cobra951

    Another one, music corporations asking royalties for playing the music they published in my pub.

    #20 1 year ago
  21. SplatteredHouse

    Apparently, Machinima, one of the largest game content MCN (Multi-channel-network) had no clue what was going on, until people informed them about it, after the claims began in earnest. They claim all networks are being similarly battered.

    @20 I just noticed one of the composers/artist of music on twitter saying that he was not informed when his own content used in other people’s vids was subject to copyright claims. So, it seems to go both ways. If they’re believed to be “ripping off” his work, then why isn’t that person informed, as he is the most wronged party.
    @18 The Youtube comment system is godawful. They should keep Google out of YT, beyond the point that one owns the other. It’s like whoever presided over crushing what-was GameStation decided to go for a Round 2!

    #21 1 year ago
  22. OwningXylophone

    @ Cyber

    Assuming the pub in question has a PPL license (which they would legally need to play the music in the first place), then they already are.

    #22 1 year ago
  23. POOhead

    Good, all these lets play vids are fucking cringie, most of them release one day so they get money off advertisement anyways, both greedy cunts if you ask me

    #23 1 year ago
  24. SplatteredHouse

    @22 In that case, you’re taking a previously licensed media (eg a song) but you’re using it for instance, you put on the radio with its free carousel stream of appealing content to make the REST of your business/premises more appealing/homely to customers.
    You’re using someone else’s content to further your own, unrelated business. I’m not surprised if creators kicked off about that. Not for Public Broadcast doesn’t leave much to question.

    #24 1 year ago
  25. CyberMarco

    @OwningXylophone

    Does it matter? Playing music from a radio station then, or even from youtube.

    #25 1 year ago
  26. SplatteredHouse

    Yeah, but Marco, your pub is being enhanced and enriched, on a recurring basis by their content – for which you paid the one-time price of the cost of audio equipment. That’s why you can do that, provided you have the license, so you are paying a little to use their talent.

    #26 1 year ago
  27. darkkai3

    @21 I should probably quickly mention that what was TGS (The GameStation) was rebranded to Polaris.

    #27 1 year ago
  28. SplatteredHouse

    @27 No, no. I was talking about the retail chain, before it got homogenised. And now. ironically enough, under the name of GAME, has all the impression, presence and use of an electronics boutique! xD

    #28 1 year ago
  29. CyberMarco

    Still they didn’t see any of the money that I spent on the audio equipment.

    Also, what license do you mean? License to be able to operate a bar, or to be able to play music?

    #29 1 year ago
  30. SplatteredHouse

    Xylophone’s PPL that he/she mentioned. Whether it applies in your country or not, maybe it doesn’t, but it’s the public presentation part that requires the license. We are getting v far off-topic, though! :o

    #30 1 year ago
  31. Meatball

    What really annoys me about YT’s system is that it’s arse-backwards. Last time I checked, it was still “innocent until proven guilty”, but on YT it’s currently “guilty until proven innocent, and good luck proving that!”.

    #31 1 year ago
  32. Dirk

    Interesting to see Silent Hill 3 on there as it’s a 10 year old game. I wonder how far back they’re willing to go, will be seeing Spectrum and C64 game videos being removed?

    @31
    That’s always the case when money is involved.

    #32 1 year ago
  33. OwningXylophone

    @Cyber

    To be legally able to play music (via radio, youtube, jukebox, any other means) in a public place (that includes pubs, warehouses, anywhere where joe public could hear it) a PPL license is required. The money charged is then distributed to artists. As splattered says, basically you are using their work to further your own business.

    *EDIT* Good point, this may not exist in your country (as I have no idea where you are from), but I’d be amazed if it didn’t in one form or another… The record industry love collecting cash. And for the off topic remarks, this is no different to what is happening here, with the games industry trying to prevent people profiting from their work without any reimbursement.

    #33 1 year ago
  34. SplatteredHouse

    @33…Not quite. In the case of one, it is a usage, unaltered of an existing work. In the other, time and effort may have been spent to release what could be argued as a created derivative (after the channel owner’s input – and how much were THEY responsible for those views, and then potentially accumulated income…) That’s the difference – how do you quantify (and qualify) the extent to which the presenter’s input added to the content, in each case!

    If you were to say, well, why don’t they insist that NO monetization can occur – if all income goes to the game license holder – what does that do? Games publishers have an investment in keeping their games looking good, and being looked at. They’ve been issuing to reviewers regulations as to what can and can’t be seen; because of that. So perhaps, it’s better that channels take the time to produce quality content, when using those IPs and that footage. Can they do that. Can they afford to do that, if they’re going to see nothing from it?

    #34 1 year ago
  35. CyberMarco

    I see. I haven’t heard anything about it, at least for Greece and Italy. I’ll search around a bit to get a clue.

    *Edit.

    Found this. http://www.aepi.gr/index.php?option=com_content&task=blogcategory&id=66&Itemid=112&lang=en

    I think you need a license after all…

    #35 1 year ago
  36. SplatteredHouse

    I think Youtube is central to the rise of these program/contents. A collecting point for all of the video content, which serves advertising. I think it unlikely to believe that the quality producers started off in it for the money; but wouldn’t they be as irked at seeing license holders banking on THEIR talent and input, just as much…They don’t shout as loud, and singularly, though.

    #36 1 year ago
  37. thiz

    This was announced to youtube partners months ago. Old news is old. There is nothing special about it. Content ID hits dont mean anything. Strikes are what people need to be concerned about.

    #37 1 year ago
  38. SplatteredHouse

    Yes, and spam (comments that add nothing of value to the discussion) is still pointless. Dismiss all you want, but these “hits” clearly mean a lot to the content producer in the video. As well as the others in his position we’ve mentioned in this thread and seen speak out, recently. He states that he can’t do what he is doing today, in the event that he cannot monetise his work.

    #38 1 year ago
  39. thiz

    @38: Deadly argument aka “I reply to you and tell you that your comment is spam, so I win” – are you 12? Seriously. People never understand what Content-ID actually mean. They are just to stupid to differentiate it from other stuff. Which is what makes all of these comments worthless.

    A Content-ID hit is just means that there is a signature found on your video that indicates that you might have used some stuff that doesnt belong to you but it doesnt effect monetizing in any shape or form. Please get a clue before commenting on topics like this.

    I am a content producer myself, and its a fact, that this new wave of Content-ID hits dont matter. People just want to get mad about something and go for drama, because that is what simpleminded human beings are best at.

    And to add something more to this, @32:

    SEGA bans accounts instantly, if you post something about Shining Force 2, thats how far they go back ;)

    #39 1 year ago
  40. SplatteredHouse

    @39. Your fist comment amounted to “I’m not interested in the subject of this thread”. That’s spam. It didn’t need saying. But still, there are lots of other ones.
    Also, it’s been repeated today, that this process is leaving people’s videos in a state to where they can earn nothing from making them. I don’t know what the cause was (and there’s no point me knowing, so I’m not interested to) but if people are out money, like that, then that is clearly not nothing.

    I don’t care about Content ID. Another patchwork solution to an ingrained problem, ignored too long. I’m interested in quality content being produced and alternative entertainment niches being catered to, after the decline/failure of traditional sources to serve audiences sufficiently. If those content producers are not able to make the content, then that could be a big deal.

    @39 An especially cretinous move, on SEGA’s part. that debacle. Not even apologised directly for their actions, yet, either.

    #40 1 year ago
  41. salarta

    I’m looking forward to a new company coming up to replace YouTube as the dominant video sharing platform out of this idiocy. YouTube sucks. It’s also fast approaching a point where it’s MySpace levels of outdated in its approach to things.

    Edit: Also, I have one lone video on YouTube from years back that’s essentially a “fan music video” for FF4 using a song by Angela Aki. I haven’t received any notices.

    #41 1 year ago
  42. Ireland Michael

    Won’t happen.

    Video hosting is expensive. Users on YouTube have such large audiences that moving to a new platform for most existing channels would be financial suicide. It is the dominan platform by a huge, huge margin, and these people are not going to sacrifice their personal welfare for your petty internet brand grudge.

    And even if a new site did somehow sprout up and replace it, it would still be bound by the exact same copyright laws as YouTube anyway.

    The problem here isn’t entirely with YouTube. It’s with this music organisation abusing the system. The fair use rules (a trailer freely provided by someone else shouldn’t be subject to these kinds of copyright issues, for instance) are what need to be looked into here. Google could definitely do with improving the whole process, I won’t deny that.

    Let’s Plays are the creatively barren wasteland of the internet though, and I’d be more than happy to see them die – if people want to earn money out of someone else’s content, they should at least be obligated to put some damn effort into it.

    #42 1 year ago
  43. SplatteredHouse

    http://t.co/2Sr7UaNYkL < Address the Sess will feature this Youtube business. Lots of clued in people (indeed, affected/involved people) are likely to be amongst the guests at 4PST/7EST.

    Also, Youtube released an official statement: http://www.tubefilter.com/2013/12/11/youtube-official-statement-contentid-claims/
    Basically, they're saying it's: a)not their problem. b) business as usual.

    #43 1 year ago
  44. absolutezero

    Its only also going to affect the people that do this as a job, which usually results in the laziest possible videos.

    The best LP’s come out of SA just like they always have and always will, things that have had so much time and effort put into them that in some places to puts the actual game to shame.

    Like this :

    http://lparchive.org/Silent-Hill-Homecoming/

    At some stage in the past it became freely acceptable to upload videos of a brand new game all the way through to the end the day before they even officially release. Its perfectly understandable that the producers would get a little pissed at all of their work being up for show from start to finish.

    On the other hand the board game scene has shown that theres a massive market for play throughs, it does not dim the desire to play or indeed purchase the board game in question. It fires community.

    #44 1 year ago
  45. SplatteredHouse

    “Its only also going to affect the people that do this as a job, which usually results in the laziest possible videos.”

    Are you actually stating, that people who find they can afford the time to put the effort in, to actually craft their coverage and content, and present it at an appreciable standard – who are as interested and passionate about the subject they’re covering, as well as the presentation – are the ones usually uploading any ol’ shit?! That just flies completely in the face of what I am seeing.

    #45 1 year ago
  46. absolutezero

    pewdiepie.

    Now compare any of those, or RadBrad orrrr any of the huge prolific popular channels, Game Grumps, Yogscast etc.

    Compare those to anything from the lparchive.

    #46 1 year ago
  47. SplatteredHouse

    exception != norm. I couldn’t stand to watch his segment in the VGX show, I also had to mute the stream for that segment he featured in, in it -it sounded so awful D:

    Even so, let’s take as given, that the lparchive is a gleaming font, the executive suite,a palatial bounteous eden of gaming related content and discussion. Give it the benefit of the doubt.

    So, how much of that pristine nature is due to its reserved, niche position comparitively, compared to YT?
    How more stringent is the individual moderation and vetting at that scale, for instance. Would that be viable to maintain, if lparchive were to inherit disenfranchised Youtube refugees? The advertisers get sold space on there, and then, what if the same eyes that focus today on Youtube, move with the flood towards lparchive – would it be the same?

    #47 1 year ago
  48. absolutezero

    lparchive is actually just a library of LP’s taken from the Let’s Play sub-forum of Something Awful. Its more or less the place that came up with the original archetypal set-up for most of what we consider LPs today.

    Its also home to Retspurae the channel thats dedicated more or less to mocking horrible LP’s.

    The level of qualitty control and moderation on that forum is through the roof, its what leads to so much effort being put into what they do, its for the passion of gaming and discussing and sharing, its never really been about money. Thas not going to change, whats going to happen is that the people that do this for cash now have to find something else to do. They have an unwritten rule on that forum that a game must be released for over 3 months before an LP can be started. The videos usually follow some sort of ordered sequence instead of videos going up constantly everyday in order to grab views and thus make money. Its lets them work on things longer, it lets them get better at the games they play.

    So to answer the question, the lparchive will not change because Something Awful is not going to change.

    Seeing that pewdiepie is an exception is fair enough but he has the most subscribed channel on the youtube, I think its 16 million plus right now. He pumps out the low quality content imaginable, its just his face in the corner of the screen screaming about being raped and such shit. Its painful. He makes millions from that. Its cynical, exploitative and depressing.

    There are plenty of non-LP gaming channels that I seriously doubt will be going anywhere, videogamer.tv, totalbiscuit etc etc.

    #48 1 year ago
  49. SplatteredHouse

    Oh, right! I think I have seen that place referenced before, in past discussions. A sort of LP purist collective.
    “They have an unwritten rule on that forum that a game must be released for over 3 months before an LP can be started.”

    Which introduces another consideration from the Youtube side: Relevance. How long a piece of content is going to draw the numbers of viewers. For instance, news coverage/opinion. That might be of relevance to the day, or a short period of time after it’s published. If those content producers get their content demonetised until (examples have been put forward of on average thirty days to contest a claim – some associates/third parties drawing things out to the maximum time before acting to settle the matter) but if much later, much later, then is that a sustainable model.

    “Its lets them work on things longer, it lets them get better at the games they play.”

    Another thing, there. In that case, you are as much perhaps, watching for the presenter, as/than the game. The game serving largely as an arena for the presenter to perform within. That strikes me as significantly different to content produced (a derivative work) from the basis of a game and/or its content.

    On your last sentence, I see where you would believe that, but it’s the reason they’re not going anywhere that’s key. TB’s channel is within the Polaris group. He would probably be a Managed channel of Polaris, under YT’s definition. He has not been impacted in any way, by these actions. It’s the Affiliate channels that have now been made open to restrictions that previously applied only to Unaffiliated channels/producers, that have been getting hammered.

    #49 1 year ago
  50. modshroom128

    good, this is the best day of my life.

    now faggots like pewdiepie and dsp will be out of jobs. thank you god.

    #50 1 year ago
  51. bartveenz

    My Uncle Jonathan got an almost new white Chevrolet Camaro Coupe just by some parttime working online from home. straight from the source http://goo.gl/5dwKOi (Home more)

    #51 1 year ago
  52. mariaroze

    my friend’s mom makes $63 an hour on the computer. She has been out of work for seven months but last month her payment was $18465 just working on the computer for a few hours. Go to this web site and read more http://www.cash29.com/

    #52 1 year ago
  53. SplatteredHouse

    Watch that Address the Sess from last night for more informed talk on this. The man behind @ForkParker was a superb guest, especially. And, although they did not have representatives of the antagonists, often times, he in particular, offered some important considerations to challenge the rest of the panel. As for Youtube – from their own statement -they don’t give a crap, so long as they’re not liable. Even still. they’ve thrown their content producers to the wolves.

    #53 1 year ago
  54. Dark

    oh man , i feel sorry for joe :(

    #54 1 year ago
  55. xxxGamesMasterxxx

    Love AngryJoe. Disgusting the way YouTube is right now. They should all jump to Twitch.

    #55 1 year ago
  56. GrimRita

    Yup.Youtube need to do a better job of how it deals with such claims. This could really destroy the foundation of which youtube was built on.

    And if you piss off AngryJoe, you may as well just end it lol

    #56 1 year ago
  57. unacomn

    I’ve been using Youtube for video content hosting for a few years now. Not being affiliated with a network, I have always been the target of Content ID claims. I’ve even received copyright strikes on content like the B-Roll of WoW Cataclysm, that Blizzard made available to the press, which I used for a video preview of the game. I was unable to properly use my account for a long time because of that strike. And that was even before monetization was available in my country. I just posted it because that’s where my site hosted videos.

    I have to deal with things like these on a day to day basis. I’m getting claims from dead companies like THQ for using bits of trailers, I’m getting rejected disputes from Nintendo for a 10 minute news show that ends with 15 seconds of a Zelda trailer.

    I’ve resorted to humming video game music in certain situations, just to avoid a content strike. I’ve mimed gameplay. I’ve re-enacted cut-scenes with myself as multiple characters. And I’ve been doing this for years, all because self hosting HD content costs me more than I will ever make in this profession, and every other video distribution system either lacks many features and most of all, they lack an audience.

    The Content ID system is a sham, and every publisher that has used it, EVERY publisher that has used it to enforce its content is responsible. They signed up for that, they chose that!
    They gave a loaded gun to a derange monkey and that monkey shot me, and keeps shooting me, again and again and again.

    The only thing that has changed is that the people that supported this damned protection mafia monopoly got burned. They now know what every other youtuber has to go through every single day.

    #57 1 year ago
  58. 4G

    Another video on the issue, from Rev3Games, also featuring TotalBiscuit: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bt1ubSVMwaw

    I think this is absolutely disgusting, YouTube are taking away people’s livelihoods, just to fill their own pockets. I Say fuck YouTube, it’s time for an alternative.

    #58 1 year ago
  59. Bomba Luigi

    That “Working for Google” Spam fits in so perfect here.

    #59 1 year ago
  60. Onyx

    I run a small record label selling CDs and MP3s in a niche genre. I can speak with some experience as to what is going on here, the automated system is only a part of the problem.

    The other aspect of this is somewhat deeper and more convoluted, and it is do with with the process of how music is delivered to the large digital stores like iTunes, Amazon, Zune and so on.

    Here is a brief run down of the process:

    1) Mr Musician Creates Music
    2) Mr Musician signs up with a digital distributor, like CD Baby, IODA etc.
    3) Mr Musician uploads his music to digital distributor.
    4) Digital Distributor feeds this content into the stores like iTunes etc.
    5) Digital Distributor creates a digital finger-print that is sent to YouTube.

    What this means is that if someone now uploads a video to YouTube using Mr Musician’s music a number of things will happen:

    1) The video will get flagged for matched third part content.
    2) The video may get a “Buy Mr Musician’s music from iTunes” link.
    3) Ad revenue earned on the video will be paid to the Digital Distributor.
    4) Mr Musician will receive his cut.

    But here is the problem; if Mr Musician isn’t a musician but is instead a ‘content creator’ – by that I mean he makes MP3′s licensing existing music strange things will happen.

    Here is something that happened to me:

    1) I took a piece of music from the public domain. This was 100% free, and 100% allowable to be used anywhere in the world for any purpose, including commercial and monitization.
    2) I created a CD and MP3 using this public domain track.
    3) I uploaded this track to my digital distributor.
    4) Digital distributor sent this to iTunes etc.
    5) Digital distirbutor created a digital fingerprint of the track and sent it to YouTube.
    6) A while later, Mrs Jones created a video on YouTube using the public domain track. Her video is content flagged for using “my” music. The ownership is claimed by my digital distributor (even though they don’t own the rights to it either – they merely distribute it and have no legal rights to it at all).
    7) Both my Digital Distributor and myself now get a cut of Mrs Jones ad revenue, and she gets nothing. I have no ability to release this music to her.

    Crazy situation is that I could also upload a video to YouTube using my own track and it will also get content flagged.

    The situation is actually larger than just YouTube and Google. They are using a system that has been built up over the past few years by companies like Apple, and their distribution partners such as CD Baby, IODA (now The Orchard), IRIS, TuneCore and many, many others.

    It is a big snowball that has been rolled up to the top of a huge fucking mountain, gathering up all content in its path.

    When Ubisoft create a Soundtrack album for their game, if they use a digital distributor to send that album off to iTunes, such as IDOL – then IDOL will be the ones that flag your YouTube video and Ubisoft will never even hear about it.

    So the big snowball has gathered up everything it possibly can and now it has caused an avalanche.

    Problem is, this is bigger than YouTube, Google and iTunes. This whole system is what the entire online digital music industry has been built upon. Not many people are aware of this yet, as it has been going on quietly in the background. YouTube merely plugged the affiliates right into this same system, which has served to highlight how messed up it is.

    These digital distributors such as IDOL have been making millions and millions from this process. Think about it, all they do is take the ablum, upload it to iTunes and then they get around a 20% cut of all sales made! And they have largely done this with an invisiable hand that is being enforced by YouTube’s content matching system.

    It is allowed to continue because it serves the interests of the music industry. It is all managed for them by third parties without them having to get involved.

    But it seems the likes of Deep Silver, Ubisoft and Capcom didn’t realise the net effect of what they have signed up to. It will be interesting to see what happens next.

    #60 1 year ago
  61. Cobra951

    @61: Good God . . . The powerful keep mopping up all ways for the little guy to earn some money. The trickle-down faucet has been shut and sealed.

    Thank you for the informative read. I had no idea how nefarious the whole thing had become. I should not be surprised by now at the greed of the big boys. But this one did; shocked the hell out of me.

    #61 1 year ago
  62. docLEXfisti

    Why is there no mention of the company that started this? Why is there no mention of SONY asking this of it’s reviewers. Are you a Sony blog, or are you critical journalists?

    Wow I am really baffled …

    #62 1 year ago
  63. Pytox

    Valve FTW!

    #63 1 year ago
  64. Beta

    http://www.oddworld.com/2013/12/oddworlds-position-on-youtubes-new-content-id-system/

    Oddworld is also encouraging users to make videos and contact them if they have any trouble :)

    #64 1 year ago
  65. SplatteredHouse

    The creator of Retro City Rampage has spoken on twitter about his amazement at finding his companies video flagged because of their inclusion of original music THEY (RCR makers) own… o.o

    #65 1 year ago
  66. G1GAHURTZ

    People just need to ditch YouTube if they want to keep getting paid.

    Simple as.

    #66 1 year ago
  67. Dave Cook

    @66 the system is fucked isn’t it? What a mess.

    #67 1 year ago
  68. BlazeHedgehog

    I got about 5000 subscribers, creeping up on 6000. I only just became part of the monetization game with Fullscreen Entertainment, but that was after more than a year of trying to fight with Youtube directly to get ads on my videos. They are a remarkably stingy company, fully dedicated to covering their own asses and not causing too much of a ruckus with big-media partners that have deep pockets – even if that means going against the letter of the law.

    That being said, I have my fingers crossed that this is just growing pains. A lot of the flagging going on out there seems to be Youtube plugging in a music database that covers a very vast number of songs. Gameplay often contains background music, so that background music is matching to this song database and triggering copyright in favor of the music distributor (which is usually a completely different entity from the game developers and publishers).

    But as we’re seeing, developers are jumping to try and straighten things out; with the volume of requests coming in, one would hope that new policies would be put in place to deal with this kind of stuff – obviously not at Youtube, but through the developers, publishers, and music distributors. I imagine that a large number of developers who publish soundtracks on iTunes through Phonofile, Merlin, IDOL, etc. are going to specify certain usage clauses right out of the gate to avoid this kind of stuff in the future.

    The real frustrating part is undoubtedly Youtube’s logic; they get a kickback on ad money, so obviously they want to attribute a license to everything. While they can hide behind the guise of “We’re paying content creators what they’re owed”, what that really means is that regardless of who they’re attributing ownership to, Youtube gets a percentage. This is a move that, more than anyone else, will make Youtube themselves millions of dollars. Nobody explicitly requested ads be placed on these videos? Doesn’t matter, Youtube’s going to cut them a check and bank some of those ad dollars for themselves.

    The issue then becomes whether or not these companies refuse this free money forever. You look at the proliferation of season pass DLC, of F2P systems in retail games, the vilification of used games, and it’s pretty clear that at some point, some of these companies are going to get REAL desperate for any income source they can get.

    But I’m still hoping everything will work out in the end.

    #68 1 year ago
  69. polygem

    “capitalism is indeed organised crime and we’re all the victims”

    refused

    #69 1 year ago
  70. absolutezero

    So it seems that with most things is life its directly the music industry being utter bastards.

    #70 1 year ago
  71. DarkElfa

    @70, you make me giddy inside sometimes.

    #71 1 year ago
  72. SplatteredHouse

    https://twitter.com/AngryJoeShow/status/411368364099899392

    These Videocopilot (media provider intermediaries – almost a digital warehouse of media asset rights?) people were named in one of AngryJoe’a videos as being ones responsible for some of the claims on his videos…Apparently not. It’s quite clear that they have their own legal teams trying to sort out this dredged up mess, brought down at Google’s insistence!

    Joe contacted VCP directly, and the response: “@AngryJoeShow It’s insane. Our attorney’s tried all sorts to stop the other company and contact youtube, nothing worked!”

    They’re as much thrown off by this as the license holding content creators.

    #72 1 year ago
  73. Dragon

    Now, after this latest update, there can be no doubt that something is horrendously wrong with the current policies. The onus is on Google to correct it asap and not be evil

    #73 1 year ago
  74. Darkfield

    I can’t even.make a joke about it, it is already a very bitter, sad and tasteless joke on its own. Whoever came up with this idea should be burnt alive in public.

    #74 1 year ago
  75. Luciferous

    @74 – this is a company who just bought a company that designs military robots… This is just phase one of their plan for world domination.

    #75 1 year ago
  76. Darkfield

    ^Skynet inc!!!

    #76 1 year ago
  77. absolutezero

    They need to leave.

    If Dailymotion bothered to update its site and server back end it could bring across a hell of alot of viewers who are angry at Youtube.

    Its not going to do anything and the entire music industry digital distribution system is not going to change.

    Sure its terrible but I assume youtube may start to notice a slight difference in revenue if pewdiepie decided to move somewhere else.

    #77 1 year ago
  78. abdooltk

    FUCK FUCK FUCK to copy rights ,I bought a game and I have all rights copy to use so fuck them and i can’t Wait this game it’s amazing….

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m4gKeH8VlGI

    #78 1 year ago
  79. The_Red

    This is just shameful. Seriously, copy right is NOT a bad thing in and out of itself but the way YouTube / Google are enforcing it is just… shameful.

    #79 1 year ago
  80. salarta

    Why is it that the industry that falls the furthest in the background of multimedia is the one filled with people and corporations that act like colossal douches?

    The more they pull stuff like this, where EVEN THE ACTUAL COPYRIGHT HOLDERS have their own stuff reported because some music entity they worked through put in a claim, the less likely I am to believe there are any “victims” other than some asshole exec’s paint job on his million dollar yacht. Incidents like this really make an excellent case for copyright not even existing, if it’s going to be abused without even a single thought or care for how to implement it properly.

    #80 1 year ago
  81. Cobra951

    After reading Update 6, I think there has to be a class-action suit brewing here. Has to be. That is clearly wrongdoing, no matter how pro-establishment your stance may be.

    #81 1 year ago
  82. SplatteredHouse

    What a bunch of crap this is! https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2770411?hl=en&ref_topic=2778545

    It says here, that if you get a content ID claim, then you can appeal…To the CLAIMANT (?!? wtaf) who then determines whether or not to fire a legal notice at you or retract the ID claim. I read on MCV the full content of the letter Google sent out to Youtubers, and one of the tips links to that. And then, AT THE TIME the legal notice is sent the “uploader” receives copyright strike.

    Considering, if you were to challenge, and they upheld – well, that doesn’t matter, because unless you want to take it to a courtroom, enjoy your strike, because you’re in the wrong… o.o It’s mind-boggling to read, that people let this slide.

    Fuck all of that. What a load of nonsense. There needs to be an alternative, because I don’t know how any consumer/audience driven entity would sign up to such absurd, kangaroo court arbitration. I find it outrageous.

    #82 1 year ago

Comments are now closed on this article.

  • Geralt is very professional in the latest Witcher 3: Wild Hunt TV spot

    The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt has a new TV spot that’s short and to the point. The latest Witcher 3 trailer comes in the form of TV spot. It’s all CGI, and it looks good. If you’re more into gameplay trailers, the latest one will serve you well. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is out […]

  • Steam roguelike sale is live, offers deep discounts on a stellar collection of titles

    If you’re into challenging, procedurally-generated, and infinitely-replayable games, Steam’s current sale will hook you up. Steam is hosting a sale on roguelike games. Plenty of titles in the genre are on sale for upwards of 75% off. Highlights include Risk of Rain at 75% off, Don’t Starve at 66% off, Spelunky at 75% off, FTL: […]

  • Resident Evil: Revelations 2 finally gets online co-op in Raid Mode on Xbox One

    Resident Evil: Revelations 2 has been patched to support online play in Raid Mode on Xbox One. The Xbox One version of Resident Evil: Revelations 2 lacked online support in Raid Mode for a long time. Until today. A new patch has been released to bring that version in line with the rest of them. […]

  • A section in Killing Floor 2′s EULA about cyberbullying is riling up some fans

    Killing Floor 2 has recently got into a bit of trouble with some fans due to a clause in its EULA that gives the developer the right to revoke a user’s license without prior notice. The Killing Floor 2 EULA – just like many others found in modern games, has a section dedicated to cheating […]

  • World of Tanks: 2,000 free tanks and in-game cash to giveaway

    To celebrate the World of Tanks grand finals this weekend we’ve got some great freebies to give away to new players. We have 2,000 PC invite codes to giveaway, with each one offering new accounts a T2 Light Tank, 100 Gold and 1 Days Premium worth around €8.00. All you need to do is enter […]

  • Marvel announces partnership with Telltale, first game due in 2017

    Marvel and Telltale have entered into a partnership that will allow the developer to work on a new game series, due in 2017. Telltale has announced that it has partnered with Marvel Games, Marvel Entertainment’s video games division, for the development of a new game series. No indication was given as to what the new […]

  • Destiny: Bungie is not saying no to a player trading system

    Bungie has not completely ruled out the idea of bringing a trading system to Destiny. Destiny does not offer any way for players to trade items amongst themselves. But ever since the game’s release, players have never stopped asking Bungie to add one in. While the developer does not have a satisfying answer, it’s still […]

  • Destiny: Xur location and inventory for April 24, 25 – MIDA Multi-Tool edition

    The weekend Exotics market run by Xur: Agent of the Nine is now open for business. Destiny’s bizarre vendor, Xur, has arrived at the Tower. Xur is your man if you’re looking for Exotic armour or weapons. Not only that, but he will also let you exchange your old Exotic gear for new, upgraded versions. […]

  • Warcraft movie delayed yet again

    The Warcraft movie will no longer hit theatres in March 2016. The release date of the Warcraft movie has been pushed back by three months. The movie was expected in March 2016, but Legendary Pictures announced yesterday that it is now due on June 10, 2016. No reason was given for the delay. This is […]

  • Destiny: Iron Banner returns on April 28

    Destiny’s Iron Banner PvP event will return this Tuesday. Bungie has announced that the Iron Banner, it’s once-every-few-weeks PvP event, will make a return with next week’s weekly reset. It was initially due this week, but because of the recent Crucible changes that were implemented with patch 1.1.2, Bungie wanted to wait and see. That […]

  • Deus Ex devs take the piss out of Black Ops 3

    Deus Ex developers have been having a bit of a laugh at the expense of Call of Duty’s official Twitter account. You would be forgiven to think that yesterday’s Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 ‘Ember’ teaser was part of an ad campaign for a Deus Ex game, with all the biohacking, wearable tech, augmentation, […]

  • Bungie weekly update: Commendations begone

    Destiny’s weekly update is here to determine the fate of all those Commendations you’ve been earning in the past few months. Bungie started off this week’s update with a recap of the details revealed during the recent livestream. There wasn’t really anything on this front that they haven’t talked about already. With the exception of […]

  • This GTA 5 trainer lets you play as almost anything and it’s the best thing ever

    Want to play GTA 5 as a monkey, a cat, a fish, a deer or some other non-human thing that we eat or keep as a pet? ScriptHook has you covered. Not only can you play as critters, it change other game values, according to an explanation from PC Gamer. These values include making changes […]

  • EA Sports moves Rory McIlroy PGA TOUR release date to July

    EA Sports has announced Rory McIlroy PGA TOUR will be released in July. Originally announced for June, the golf game will now release the same week as the Open Championship at St. Andrews, on July 14. EA also provided some more color on gameplay features such as the ability to customize the game by borrowing […]

  • Jason Voorhees joins Mortal Kombat X in May, Kombat Pack owners get first dibs

    Jason Voorhees will arrive for Mortal Kombat X players in May, NetherRealm Studios announced today during the latest Kombat Kast. Jason will be shown for the first time on Monday, May 4 during a special Kombat Kast. According to EventHub which watched the livestream, the developer will also show off the character’s move and Variations. […]

  • The Witcher 3: Nvidia heads to Poland for a behind-the-scenes look – video

    A video for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt has been released, taking you behind-the-scenes with CD Projekt RED. Nvidia’s GeForce crew went to the firm’s studio in Poland to talk with the game’s executive producer John Mamais, who provides a look at the PC version of the upcoming RPG. CD Projekt, according to the video […]

  • Microsoft notes decline in Xbox unit sales for Q3 FY15 to 1.6 million

    Microsoft reported its Q3 FY15 earnings today, citing growth in Xbox Live usage as one of the contributing factors to the firm’s reported revenue. However, the firm noted a decline in units sales for its Xbox consoles during the quarter. Microsoft Q3 2014 (yoy comparison) Microsoft Q1 fiscal 2015 Microsoft Q2 fiscal 2015 The firm […]

  • Powerplay is a new feature included in the Elite: Dangerous May update

    The next update for Elite: Dangerous is coming next month and it includes a new feature called Powerplay. According to Frontier Developments, Powerplay allows players to participate in an ongoing battle that “enhances every aspect” of the game. Players can become allies with a number of galactic Powers and guide their strategy, pursue objectives in […]

  • Facebook says it’s “too early” to discuss large-scale shipments of Oculus Rift

    Facebook has said it is “too early” to discuss large-scale shipments of Oculus Rift as the VR headset is still in the development stages. Speaking during a call to investors, Facebook CFO David Wehner said the company had nothing to announce regarding the amount of stock it expected to ship. “We have not announced any […]

  • Battlefield Hardline’s first patch and rental server program hits next week

    Battlefield Hardline’s first patch has a release date for both consoles and PC. PC & Console patch and RSP for Consoles coming April 28th. Fixes include TDM spawns and more: http://t.co/BZYJeomPlr pic.twitter.com/27TCiY8hmf — Battlefield (@Battlefield) April 23, 2015 The update will include fixes to Punkbuster, Nvidia DirectX drivers, TDM spawns, contains weapon balance tweaks and […]

  • Modders can now earn money through Steam Workshop starting today with Skyrim

    Valve has introduced a new functionality within Steam Workshop which will allow mod makers to earn money for their creations, starting with Skyrim. The update will allow content such as mods, items, or maps to be sold through Steam Workshop for titles which have the feature enabled. A new “streamlined process for listing” has been […]

  • Play Skyrim for free this weekend on Steam and take 75% off while you’re at it

    Skyrim is free this weekend on Steam providing wanna-be Dragonborns who have procrastinated on wetting their blades with Stormcloak blood the perfect opportunity to give the RPG a try. Head over to Steam and download the game and play for free until April 26 at 1am PDT. The game is also 75% off if you […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 “Ember” teaser video released ahead of full reveal

    Activision has released a Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 teaser video titled “Ember” and you can watch it right here. Here’s the video blurb: “In the next 50 years, technological advancements will lead us into a world where only those who risk going too far, will find out how far we can actually go.” […]

  • Dragon Age Keep update includes more customizability and control

    Bioware has updated Dragon Age Keep after listening to community feedback. The update includes more customization and control over heroes, world states, career and more. Players can now customize hero portraits or delete Dragon Age: Inquisition heroes from the Hero section. They can also remove playthrough states from the World State Manager and keep up […]

  • Here’s a look at some Conker community creations in Project Spark

    Conker’s Bug Reunion releases today, and below is a video showing some of the community creations you will be able to download using the creation pack. Project Spark is a free download on Xbox One and Windows 8.1, and you can download the Conker Creation Pack today. It contains 350 assets in order for users […]

  • Rainbow Six: Siege video shines spotlight on the British Counter Terrorist Unit

    Ubisoft has released a Rainbow Six: Siege video which gives you a look at the British Counter Terrorist Unit which features “the best of the Army, Navy, and Air Force.” The firm said that over the next few weeks it will introduce the public to each of the units in the game. Rainbow Six Siege […]

  • Mario Kart 8 DLC and Mewtwo for Super Smash Bros. headline eShop update in North America

    Nintendo has updated the North American end of the eShop with an update and new DLC for Mario Kart 8 and the Mewtwo DLC for Super Smash Bros. Other highlights include Mario Kart DS on Wii U Virtual Console, the continuation of International StreetPass Week and more. Full update is below. Nintendo eShop Mario Kart […]

  • Square Enix host E3 2015 conference this year on June 16

    With Final Fantasy 15, Rise of the Tomb Raider and Deus Ex: Mankind Divided on the horizon, it should come as no surprise to learn that Square Enix will be hosting a dedicated E3 2015 conference this year. The presentation will take place Tuesday, June 16 at 9am PDT/12pm EDT/5pm UK. It will be broadcast […]

  • Final Fantasy 4: The After Years 3D remake releasing on Steam next month

    Final Fantasy 4: The After Years has been given a makeover and will be released on Steam of PC next month. You can now pre-order it on Steam and take 10% off for the time being. The game will be released on the digital service May 12 and will include trading cards and achievements. Thanks, […]

  • This Project Cars video shows off the racer’s multiplayer

    Project Cars developer Slightly Mad has released a new video giving you a look at the game’s multiplayer. The game is out next month, and if you would like to refresh yourself on the tracks included,  give this a look. While you are clicking links, here’s the minimum and recommended PC specifications which dropped last […]

  • Looks like Logitech is getting out of OEM mouse production business [Clarification]

    Logitech will no longer produce “low-end” mice, citing a decline in PC accessories. This story has been updated to include a clarification. According to a Reuters report, per MCV, the firm will instead focus on video accessories and streaming music, as its wireless Bluetooth speakers are now its best-selling product rage. This will help offset […]

  • Win! We have 1,000 Heroes of the Storm beta keys to give away

    Must have more MOBA? Win one of our 1,000 Heroes of the Storm beta keys and see if you’re more Blizzard than LoL. Can’t wait for June 2? Of course you can’t. We have 1,000 closed beta keys for Heroes of the Storm to give away this week, allowing you access before Blizzard’s MOBA goes […]

  • Xenoblade Chronicles X Nintendo Direct airs tomorrow, April 24

    A Nintendo Direct devoted entirely to Xenoblade Chronicles X will air this Friday, April 24. The video showcase will start at 11am PDT/2pm EDT/7pm UK. After the showcase, a new Nintendo Treehouse: Live presentation featuring the game will air. This is the second Xenoblace Chronicles X Nintendo Direct, but the first in English. The first […]

  • Blizzard will have 500 game stations set up at gamescom 2015

    Blizzard is heading to gamescom 2015 in August and it will have 500 game stations set up for attendees to get their hands on five of its titles. The developer will be set up in Hall 7 and those who stop by will be able to get hands-on with the latest content for Heroes of […]

  • PS4 price cut to £299 in UK

    Sony has dropped the price of the PS4 in the UK. For a limited time only, you can grab the console for £299.99 from Argos, Game, Tesco and Very. Go to Amazon.co.uk and you’ll get it for £289. You’ve only got until April 28, then it goes back up to £349. Go, go, go. For […]

  • Mad Max: first ever gameplay footage revealed

    Today, we get to finally take our first look at gameplay from Mad Max. Avalanche and Warner Bros. have shown off the first gameplay trailer for Mad Max today. The trailer below offers a look at melee combat, car combat, customisation and much more. Give it a watch below: There are a few new screenshots […]

  • Overlord: Fellowship of Evil has four-player co-op like we figured

    Codemasters has pulled the veil back on the next Overlord game, and its a four-player co-op game called Overlord: Fellowship of Evil. Rhianna Pratchett is back to write the story. The game may be co-op at its core, but it can still be played single-player. Each of the four playable character have strengths and weaknesses, […]

  • Update now available for Pokemon Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire, Pokemon X and Y

    Pokemon Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire along with Pokemon X and Y are being updated by Nintendo to fix a few bugs and in-game text. There’s also the possibility of a few hacks and exploits being fixed. Per Nintendo Life (via Serebii), both patches are 250-270 blocks in size, and it’s a mandatory update which […]

  • Side-scrolling cover shooter Not a Hero gets a demo

    Not a Hero, the upcoming game from OlliOlli developer Roll7, has received a demo. The demo for Not a Hero was made available today on Steam. In the game, you play as Steve, the campaign manager for BunnyLord. A time-travelling rabbit who’s running for mayor of London. Think this is an absurd premise? This trailer […]

  • You have until April 30 to export your Green Day: Rock Band tracks to Rock Band 3

    Harmonix has announced that those looking to export their song collection from Green Day: Rock Band into Rock Band 3 can only do so until the end of the month. April 30 will be the cutoff date for anyone who wants to export tracks from Green Day: Rock Band into their Rock Band 3 library, […]

  • Batman: Arkham Knight minimum, recommended, and ultra PC specs revealed

    Batman: Arkham Knight is looking like it’s going to be quite a taxing game. Nvidia has released a list of the minimum, recommended, and ultra PC requirements for Batman: Arkham Knight. Here’s the full thing: Minimum OS: Win 7 SP1, Win 8.1 (64-bit Operating System Required) Processor: Intel Core i5-750, 2.67 GHz | AMD Phenom […]

  • Bloodborne patch 1.03 is live, reduces loading times, fixes suspend/resume bugs, more

    Patch 1.03 is now live for Bloodborne. The patch reduces loading times, adds item descriptions to loading screens, and fixes other various bugs. From Software has pushed update 1.03 live to all Bloodborne owners. As promised, it reduces loading times by approximately 5 to 15 seconds. Another new addition is showing item descriptions instead of […]

  • Battlefield 4: first look at Community Map in action

    Get your first look at the map designed by the community of Battlefield 4. Battlefield 4′s community-designed map is a reality. DICE has recently updated CTE to include an early version of the map. It’s not fully textured as Westie is about to show you, but the layout is nearly finalised. Westie goes over the […]

  • Microsoft apologises for uploading misleading Witcher 3: Wild Hunt footage

    Xbox’s YouTube channel uploaded a video of The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt yesterday that was captured from the PC build. The most recent gameplay video for the The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt appeared on the Xbox YouTube channel and showed a quest from the game’s opening section. A few minutes after it had gone live, […]

  • Assassin’s Creed creator’s new game is Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey

    Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey is the game Assassin’s Creed creator Patrice Desilets has been working on. Patrice Desilets has just announced that the next game his indie studio Panache Digital Games is making is called Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey. The announcement comes from Desilets’s keynote at the Reboot Develop event in Croatia. The trailer started […]

  • Bloodborne: Cathedral Ward closed door mystery solved

    The mystery of the locked door at the bottom of the Cathedral Ward in Bloodborne has been solved. Bloodborne, like earlier From Software games, is filled with doors that don’t open the first time you try them. Some will give you “locked” messages, others “does not open from this side”. Some of these will open […]

  • Assassin’s Creed creator Patrice Desilets is revealing his next game now [UPDATE: ended]

    Patrice Desilets, one of the original creators of Assassin’s Creed is hosting a presentation where he’s expected to talk about his next project. Patrice Desilets has emerged once again. This time he’s attending development conference in Croatia. Desilets is giving a live keynote and there’s a good chance we’re going to hear about his next […]

  • Destiny House of Wolves: everything you need to know about gear upgrades & The Reef

    Bungie revealed plenty of important details in last night’s Destiny stream. Let’s go over everything. Alex wants to make sure you don’t miss any of the information revealed yesterday. Most of it affects all Destiny players too, even those who don’t intend on buying House of Wolves. During the first stream, Bungie explained the armour […]

  • Mod-friendly Galactic Civilizations 3 will leave Steam Early Access in May

    Galactic Civilizations 3 will leave Steam Early Access next month for a full release, Stardok has announced. The developer called the game the “largest and most diverse strategy sandbox to date,” as players have a variety of tools such as diplomatic treaties to resource exchanges, and United Planets resolutions to hundreds of research directions for […]

  • Ys 6: The Ark of Napishtim is out next week on PC – here’s the pre-order trailer

    Ys 6: The Ark of Napishtim will be released next week on PC, and today, we have a pre-order trailer for you. The game will be made available on April 28 for $19.99/€17.99/£13.99 on GOG, the Humble Store and Steam. Along with improvements over the original PSP version, it will contain less backtracking, controller support […]

  • Destiny: House of Wolves – full gear set up to level 34 in PvP and PvE, upgrades, more

    The Destiny: House of Wolves livestream this afternoon was chock full of information. Read onward for our full report. According to Bungie, Petra Venj, who serves the Queen, is the main story agent who leads the player through the main series of quests. Players who complete bounties will be able to level up in her […]

  • Destiny: House of Wolves – watch the livestream right here

    Bungie will host a Destiny: House of Wolves livestream at 2pm EDT today, and you can watch it right here. Watch live video from Bungie on www.twitch.tv The stream will introduce the new social space, The Reef, as well as gear upgrade paths. House of Wolves contains new Strike missions, The Prison of Elders three-player […]

  • FIFA Ultimate Team: week of April 22 team includes Barcelona, Chelsea players

    This week’s FIFA 15 Team of the Week is now available for FIFA Ultimate Team players. Each team member, as with previous weeks, is selected base on the previous weekend’s matches. Here’s the list of players now available: Starting GK: Claudio Bravo – FC Barcelona (Spain) CB: Leonardo Bonucci – Juventus (Italy) CB: Ömer Toprak […]

  • Sony’s Spring Fever Sale winds down with Shovel Knight and Call of Duty discounts

    It’s the final week of Sony’s Spring Fever Sale which means more games have been added to the mix. Shovel Knight, which launches today is one offer, and the rest are all Cal of Duty titles. The Taken movie series is on sale as well. With Shovel Knight available today on PlayStation 3, PS4 and […]

  • Drivers for Xbox controllers, voice messages, more features available in Xbox One preview

    Microsoft has announced new features coming to Xbox One and the Xbox App on Windows 10 through the preview program this month. Some of the new features have been requested by the community for both Xbox One and Xbox One SmartGlass. Here’s what to expect, straight from the horse’s mouth: Xbox on Windows 10 Game […]

  • Total War: Warhammer has been announced for PC, Mac, SteamOS

    Total War: Warhammer has been announced after previous teases from The Creative Assembly touched upon it. The game will contain “gigantic monsters, flying creatures, legendary heroes and storms of magical power.” It is also the first in a trilogy which includes two additional standalone titles and extra content packs. It will feature thousands of warriors […]

  • This video for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt features a quest from the prologue

    A new video for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt has been released, showing off the Precious Cargo quest contained in the game’s prologue. The quest tasks Geralt with helping a merchant retrieve a mysterious box from the swamps. The scene looks familiar, but we’ve seen so many videos for the game it’s hard to tell […]

  • Limited public beta for The Elder Scrolls Online kicks off tomorrow on consoles

    The limited public beta for The Elder Scrolls Online: Tamriel Unlimited will launch on PlayStation 4 and Xbox One tomorrow, and Sony has provided details on the tester for those who’ve been invited to participate. The beta test contains the full version of the game and will run from April 23-27, and will start and […]

  • Dying Light debuts in second place on Media Create charts

    Techland’s Dying Light made its debut in Japan lats week, coming in a respectable second place behind Nintendo’s Girls Mode 3: Kirakira Code. The zombie shooter sold 25,530 units on PlayStation 4, while the top earner for the week moved a little over 55,000 units on 3DS. Another western release when landed on the chart, […]

  • Lord of Magna: Maiden Heaven will release in the west this June

    Lord of Magna: Maiden Heaven has been given a release date by XSEED Games, which announced the localization back in February. The title will launch for 3DS in North America on June 2 digitally and through retail. It will be an eShop only title in Europe and Australia when it releases on June 4. A […]