Sections

Panic on the streets of Kickstarter: end of the gold rush?

Tuesday, 27 November 2012 11:07 GMT By Patrick Garratt

Britain’s indie A-listers are asking Kickstarter for millions to fund their latest games, and victory is by no means assured. Patrick Garratt asks whether or not there’s been a failure to judge the mood.

Molyneux, Braben and the Olivers have gone to Kickstarter in the space of a few weeks and asked for £1.8 million. And it appears Britain’s old-timers have misjudged the gold rush.

Fear’s risen in the British indie space in the past few weeks, and it isn’t based on the regular issue of being able to afford the next can of beans. Senior UK developers Peter Molyneux, David Braben and the Oliver twins have taken their ambitions to Kickstarter. And all’s not well.

Their goals are lofty. Braben’s asking for £1.25 million to fund a new version of yesteryear classic Elite. Molyneux wants £450,000 to create a new god game, Godus, which he hopes will hark back to the “glory days” of Bullfrog and reinvent the genre. The Olivers are looking for £350,000 for the first Dizzy game in over 20 years.

There’s been friction. Elite, particularly, has come under fire from the twitterati for being a pitch along the lines of, “Remember Elite? It was great! Give me a million quid and I’ll give you another one.” The Elite proposal caused particular ire because the original page contained no video and little information. If you compare it to Limit Theory’s Kickstarter – which is showing what appears to be a relatively mature procedural space game with a funding limit of $50,000 – it’s pretty easy to see why there was skepticism.

Godus, too, has been caught up in the moaning. Here we have Peter Molyneux, a successful man, asking the gaming populous (sorry) for a great deal of cash to get back into god sims. There’s no gameplay video, a few concept screens and some documentary-style footage of Peter and the other 22 Cans guys talking about what they want to do.

Nerves are setting in. 22 Cans has started releasing dev diary updates on Godus, first talking about Molyneux’s old games and elements the studio’s going to re-use. Braben has now shown off what is purported to be multiplayer gameplay, exhibiting two ships flying through an asteroid belt. We’ve also seen some cloud technology in a video of Braben talking about procedural generation, but it’s obvious the “game” either doesn’t exist or is too early to show.

While there was initial excitement over the Elite Kickstarter, the total seems to have largely stalled at around £600,000. The situation is more easily noticeable if you look at the Dizzy pitch: after six days, just over £16,000 has been amassed, a drop in the total’s ocean. There’s a strong chance the project won’t get funded.

Molyneux, Braben and the Olivers have gone to Kickstarter in the space of a few weeks and asked for £1.8 million. It appears Britain’s old-timers have misjudged the gold rush.

While Molyneux’s a natural showman and now “only” has £300,000 to raise in 24 days to get Godus funded, Braben is defending a sticky wicket. He needs to pull in some £650,000 in a little over a month to get Elite off the ground, and while the IP does have a fabulous legacy, David has none of Peter’s pizazz. Perhaps Elite was too long ago. Perhaps the project he brought to Kickstarter should have been more mature, like Limit Theory or Big Robot’s Sir, You Are Being Hunted. These smaller projects are seemingly further along and have lower goals (Sir was funded quickly at a target of £40,000). Molyneux will probably get there: it wouldn’t be surprising if Braben and the Olivers missed their targets.

The problem here isn’t that people don’t want a new Elite or a new Dizzy, but that they don’t want to feel as though they’re being ripped off. These are relatively large sums of money, applicable in the traditional style of development where you have a sizable team working in an office. Kickstarter has shown us that small, remote groups can put together attractive games for a fraction of the cost, and that people are prepared to pay for them, to fund the underdog. Yes, Double Fine and inXile raised $3 million a piece for a new point-and-clicker and Wasteland 2, but that was back in the spring and the concept of cutting out the publisher was fresh (also, watch Schafer’s video on the Kickstarter page: if you’re not laughing within 30 seconds there’s something wrong with your brain). Wing Commander creator Chris Roberts recently took over $2 million out of Kickstarter for Star Citizen, but it was pitched with some incredible PR assets showing hulking carriers and space combat zipping along to a heart-bursting score. Crucially, too, all these developers are American.

What happens if the big UK projects don’t get funded? It will almost certainly mean the end of any chance of another Elite game being made (it’s unlikely there’d be a Kickstarter attempt unless it was necessary). Dizzy’s been off the table for the last two decades, and what does it say of the future of 22 Cans if Godus doesn’t make it?

We’ll soon find out. Kickstarter’s role in game creation is already mature, and competition is intense. Crowd-sourcing does still apply to the reality of the larger modern indie dev – the one where ultra-conservative disc-sellers won’t go near point-and-click adventures or mid-budget space sims – but raising an amount in excess of £1 million may require more than some cloud tech and a logo.

Latest

  • The Simpsons skins come to Minecraft on PlayStation this week

    The Simpsons skin pack for Minecraft is coming to PlayStation platforms this week. Following the release of The Simpsons skin pack on Xbox platforms back in January, Microsoft has announced that it’s bringing the same pack to PlayStation systems. There are skins for the Simpsons family, principal Skinner, Willie, Dewey Largo, and more. It will […]

  • Survarium gets massive new patch to rebalance faction system

    Survarium’s latest update brings major changes to the faction system. Survarium has received a massive new patch that changes how the faction system works by increasing the amount of reputation required to gain new ranks and giving all factions beginner and maximum level items. The list of patch notes is huge, with plenty of faction-specific […]

  • Diablo 3 player reaches max level in one minute

    With the right equipment and in the right location, you can reach Diablo 3′s max level in one minute. Diablo 3 player Dat Modz has reached level 70 – the max level in the game – in sixty-six seconds. Here’s how he did it: he made sure to be in the game’s Cow Level, to […]

  • Konami no longer trading in New York Stock Exchange

    Konami has voluntarily delisted itself from the New York Stock Exchange. Konami has announced today in a press release that it has delisted itself from the NYSE stock market, effective April 24. The press release [download] says the publisher has terminated its reporting obligations, but will nonetheless continue to publish financial statements in English. The […]

  • Wolfenstein: The Old Blood is available to pre-load on Xbox One

    You can download Wolfenstein: The Old Blood starting today from Xbox Live. If you pre-ordered Wolfenstein: The Old Blood for Xbox One from the Xbox Store, then you can start pre-loading the full game now. The game’s pre-load page is now live. The size is a bit large at 37.41GB. Wolfenstein: The Old Blood is […]

  • Destiny House of Wolves: what we know about upcoming Exotic weapons and armour

    Destiny expansion House of Wolves will add a few Exotic weapons and armour pieces to the game. Let’s take a look at everything we know so far. Destiny expert Alex has cross-referenced what Bungie revealed for House of Wolves so far against what the community managed to learn from scanning the game’s database to present […]

  • Halo: The Master Chief Collection connectivity issues force cancellation of official tournament

    Connectivity issues with Halo: The Master Chief Collection have lead to the cancellation of one of the game’s eSports tournaments. Cup #1 of the second season of the Halo Championship Series is an online cup that relies on The Master Chief Collection’s party/invite system to function. 343 has had to cancel that cup over the […]

  • There are no loading screens in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

    The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt will not show you any loading screens, unless you fast travel. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is a massive game with plenty of regions, towns and buildings. But according to developer CD Projekt RED, going through this world will be seamless, without a hint of a loading screen. Speaking to […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 lets you customise characters’ genders, even in the campaign

    For the first time in a Call of Duty campaign, Black Ops 3 will let players pick the gender of their characters. Treyarch is bringing a lot of customisation options to Call of Duty: Black Ops 3. This extends to the game’s campaign, which we know will support up to four players in co-op. Customising […]

  • New Dirt game pops up on Steam Early Access for £25

    Codemasters Dirt series has moved to Steam’s Early Access and is available to buy today for £24.99. The last entries in the series were released on consoles but Dirt Rally is exclusive to PC at this stage. The game launches with 17 cars and 36 stages with more free content promised. Here’s some of the […]

  • Dying Light dev tools to add custom models, multiplayer support

    Techland will continue to add more support to Dying Light’s developer tools. A brief video highlights incoming updates including terrain creation and editing, importing custom models and multiplayer support. Dying Light developer tools were released at the start of the month and allow players to create their own maps and stories before sharing them via […]

  • How to improve Battlefield 4′s community jungle map

    There’s a lot of chatter about how to make BF4′s community jungle map better. Once suggestion is to make more of a feature out of the waterfall, according to Reddit user xpc_absol. Our man Westie considers that and runs with it, looking at how it would change objectives and interaction with the map itself – […]

  • Batman: Arkham Knight lets you play as Robin, Nightwing, Catwoman – trailer

    Not long until now until the third part of the Arkham trilogy is released – here’s a new trailer showing some interesting team-ups. Update: According to publisher Warner, the game will feature a “dual-play” mechanic that allows players to switch between Batman and his allies – Catwoman, Robin, Nightwing – during combat. It’s not quite […]

  • GTA 5 PC mods: falling whales, North Yankton unlocked and a cat rampage

    So how are those GTA 5 PC mods coming along? Quite nicely if we take a look at a batch of new mods for the game. It seems the community is having a fair bit of fun accessing restricted content and messing around with the local wildlife. Let’s start with a look at what happens […]

  • Manhunt is the best GTA 5 movie you’ll see today

    Created using the Rockstar Editor from GTA 5 on PC, this movie by AbsolutePab is pretty effin’ delicious. The three minute Manhunt action movie was created by the same guy behind this short inspired by The Purge and The Graffiti of Los Santos documentary. You should subscribe to AbsolutePab on YouTube. You really should.

  • Halo 5 Guardians getting limited edition Xbox One console

    Thinking of buying a new Xbox One? You might want to wait until October 27. Because Microsoft is planning to release a limited edition console alongside the game, as confirmed by 343 Industries studio head Josh Holmes. @juliocurt There is a limited edition console coming, yes. It hasn’t been revealed yet, but it’s pretty sweet. […]

  • Silent Hills is officially dead

    Konami’s collaboration with Del Toro is over, playable demo to disappear on Wednesday. Update 2: Konami has published a statement earlier confirming that it’s no longer working on Silent Hills. “Konami is committed to new Silent Hill titles, however the embryonic ‘Silent Hills’ project developed with Guillermo del Toro and featuring the likeness of Norman […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 Zombies will be “totally unique, mind-blowing”

    Welcome back Treyarch’s “own unique brand of mind-fuckery” to Call of Duty. Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 developer Treyarch has said Zombies mode in this year’s game will be completely different to the campaign and multiplayer games. Speaking at a briefing last week, studio head Mark Lamia said players should expect something entirely different. […]

  • Meet the specialist classes of Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 multiplayer

    Hands-on impressions of four new classes and their special abilities shaking up Call of Duty multiplayer. What’s exciting about this year’s Call of Duty is that we were able to get hands on with three different multiplayer maps and four of the new classes this early in development. Although the number of maps is still […]

  • Here’s the PC specs for Call of Duty: Black Ops 3

    The PC specs for Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 have been confirmed well ahead of the game’s November 6 release. Releasing the specs over six months before the game is due highlights how far along the game is in development. The specs are designed with low end and high end builds in mind. Get […]

  • Open beta for Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 ahead of Nov 6 release date

    Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 will offer an open beta to every player who pre-orders the game. The open beta is for the three supported formats – PC, Xbox One and PS4 – there is no version of Black Ops 3 for PS3 or Xbox 360. Solid details for the beta are yet to […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 brings back 4-player co-op campaign

    This year’s Call of Duty campaign is designed specifically for four players to experience together. Let’s get boots on the ground, soldier. Don’t call it an Exo skeleton. Call it the Direct Neural Interface. Okay, it’s a little less catchy, but the DNI biotechnology in Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 will feel familiar to […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 – watch the first official trailer here

    Here’s the first full trailer for Call of Duty: Black Ops 3, due for release on November 6. Anyone who pre-orders the game will get access to the open beta. The game will be released on PS4, Xbox One and PC. You can read hands-on impressions of the multiplayer here, check out early info on […]

  • Dota 2 International Compendium out next week, three annual championships added

    Valve has announced its adding three, yearly Dota 2 championships to its eSports roster along with the new that a new International Compendium will launch next week alongside a balance update for MOBA. The firm said it was adding three extra championships to the schedule as it recognized there was “room for improvement” on a […]

  • Dungeons 2 is now available on PC, Mac, Linux – watch the launch trailer

    Dungeons 2, the dungeon-crawling strategy sequel to Realmforge Studios’ Dungeons, has been released on Steam by publisher Kalypso. It can be yours for $39.99 on Steam and is available for Windows, Linux, Mac and SteamOS. The first game was released in 2011 and heavily influenced by Dungeon Keeper. A boxed version will arrive in North […]

  • This Mortal Kombat X “hidden character intros” video is rather humorous

    YouTuber Maximilian Dood mad has created a Mortal Kombat X video featuring “hidden” character intros centering around Scorpion and Sub-Zero. Some of the dialogue is rather funny, and we particularly liked the affectionate line uttered by Sub-Zero at one point. Just something fun for your Saturday. Enjoy.

  • Art of the Catch creator sheds more light on why he pulled the Skyrim mod off Steam

    The creator of Skyrim mod Art of the Catch has taken to Reddit to explain why he pulled the paid mod off Steam Workshop. Yesterday, it was revealed Chesko had pulled the fishing mod off Steam Workshop, after mod creator Fore stated he didn’t endorse Chesko charging for the mod because it used his his […]

  • Tripwire adds clause to Killing Floor 2 EULA banning paid mods

    Tripwire Interactive has updated its EULA for Killing Floor 2 stating that any mods players create for the game must be distributed free-of-charge. The end user agreement update, via PCgamesN, went live a couple of days after Valve announced it would allow mod creators to start charging for their creations. Bethesda is the first company […]

  • Five Nights at Freddy’s 3 recreated in LittleBigPlanet 3 is rather eerie

    LittleBigPlanet 3 players have created some really interesting content with the game’s level builder, but sometimes, the creations go beyond cute and bright and venture into the realm of creepy, as is the case with this Five Nights at Freddy’s 3 build. Created by TheLittleBigPlanetShow, the rather ominous level can be played with up to […]

  • Final Fantasy 14: Heavensward benchmark trailer shows off flying mounts, more

    Square Enix has released a rather nice benchmark video for Final Fantasy 14: Heavensward showing a battle, flying mounts and some of the new environments. Heavensward is the first expansion for Final Fantasy 14 and is slated for release on June 23 for PC, PlayStation 3 and PS4. The mac version is being handled by […]

30 Comments

  1. BinaryTweedDeej

    Disclosure: I used to work for the Olivers, and made a Dizzy-style game.

    An interesting point I saw raised on Twitter is that is there a difference between the treatment of US and UK proposals? I can’t help thinking there’s a hint of the British penchant for seeing successful people fail that is often most evident in tabloid coverage of celebrity culture.

    I do certainly think that the UK pitches have done a poor job of communicating their proposals, and have relied too heavily on nostalgia whilst skimping on specifics.

    #1 2 years ago
  2. RandomTiger

    You have to do a good pitch, its that simple. Chris Roberts clearly put a lot of effort in and created a pitch video to wow. Double Fine didn’t have anything to show but leveraged their whole history, including recent past of character and game creation and made a nice enough pitch video to show they were serious.

    You wouldn’t send just a wall of text as a serious pitch to a publisher and wouldn’t be able to sell a game just on the basis of decade old examples. So why would you expect this to work for the general public? Yer you might get lucky but leaving it to luck seems a bit risky. Do a good pitch, make the vision of your new product clear to those familiar and unfamiliar with your previous products.

    #2 2 years ago
  3. The_Red

    Excellent read. I actually just realized that their games are for UK Kickstarter and not the US one that has given so much money to Project Eternity and others like that.

    Really spot on about more matured projects showing up like Star Citizen or Limit Theory instead of a few concept art vids. Makes me wonder why Project Eternity got away with it without any real video (And just one beautiful but empty screenshot).

    #3 2 years ago
  4. BinaryTweedDeej

    @RandomTiger Fair point regarding Chris Roberts, although I’m not sure the Double Fine pitch was much more developed.

    I suspect all three Brit developers under-developed their pitches in the excitement of it all, and are sadly now faced with an uphill struggle.

    #4 2 years ago
  5. RandomTiger

    @4 It wasn’t but its was cleverly done and they got there first of course. Double Fine are a fairly safe pair of hands, they are used to making small games, they demonstrated humour in the pitch that you might expect to see in their product and an understanding of what they had to do rather than saying well we did this 20 years ago, lets do it again! They also offered the making of videos as part of the product and didn’t ask for that much money on the scale of things.

    #5 2 years ago
  6. FabioPal

    It’s easier, if I see an iPad game asking me 270k$ I’m never going to pledge for it!

    Dizzy… 20 years ago, nobody remembers it (not even me!)

    and Elite… well, Limit Theory is a good point, asking 5% of what elite requires without showing anything.

    I don’t think that there’s something about being or not being from UK, it’s just the way you show your product.

    #6 2 years ago
  7. UuBuU

    The Project Eternity kickstarter is the perfect example of how a kickstarter should be done.

    ~ Firstly they hyped it up beforehand with those teaser images, enabling them to really hit the ground running in the first few hours with a lot of generated interest

    ~ Secondly, while they didn’t have any game content to show off, their starting pitch was very strong, passionate, and well structured, with a clear outline of the kind of game they want to make. Yes, they mentioned a handful of old games they worked on, but only to strengthen their credentials and to give examples of what features to expect from the new game. It didn’t come across at all like they were milking nostalgia for money ~ which is the impression a number of other kickstarters have given me

    ~ Thirdly, they didn’t get ahead of themselves with stretch goals. They knew exactly what amount of money it would take to produce the game, and didn’t assume they’d get a significant amount more

    ~ Lastly, they had excellent communication with the community. The daily updates were exciting, and their developers frequently spoke with the fans via their forums and the kickstarter comments section

    #7 2 years ago
  8. The_Red

    @7
    Spot on. After reading your posting and analyzing other thoughts, I’ve come to realize that showing the matured / partially done isn’t all that necessary after all.

    While Double Fine did get away with humor and DF effect along, I think Project Eternity was funded much closer to the current time frame rather than the original gold rush month. They could have ended up like one of the many failed projects (Specially considering the bad buzz around their name and some unfinished products like KOTOR2).

    #8 2 years ago
  9. BinaryTweedDeej

    Interesting thoughts. So do we think it’s better to pre-hype a project before putting it on Kickstarter? Kind makes sense, get traction and then make a big splash of pledges to instill confidence.

    #9 2 years ago
  10. TheBlackHole

    Nice piece Pat.

    I’m glad this is happening. It’s good that wealthy, experienced devs begin to realise that they can’t use consumers for cheap, risk-free funding.

    Ultimately, isn’t this just indicative of what Kickstarter is all about? Consumers choosing which projects they want, and which they don’t. Why are we surprised that some larger devs have poorly judged projects ignored?

    #10 2 years ago
  11. mistermogul

    Molyneux must be worth millions of £/$ so why should we fund his effing game?

    This pisses me right off.

    If you’re reading this Peter – stop ripping people off and fund your own projects. Kickstarter is for proper indy devs, not millionaires… Stop taking the liberty asking for a risk-free ride.

    #11 2 years ago
  12. TheBlackHole

    @11 with all due respect, nobody knows how much Peter is worth.

    Yes, he’s probably very wealthy, but that doesn’t exempt him from using Kickstarter. Plenty of VC-backed development studios have received million$ in funding, as Pat states, whereas to be fair, Peter’s company is a small start up.

    Also, why is it ripping people off just because he has money. If he produces the game people expect then surely they’ve got their money’s worth?

    #12 2 years ago
  13. ManuOtaku

    ^i think with his tounge alone, one can make a fortune in a meat exchange market ;), he worths millions, i mean his tounge ;)

    #13 2 years ago
  14. dreamcastnews

    I only pledge for retro games ON retro systems, if Dizzy was being made as an iPad game and as a Megadrive or SNES cartridge I’d be all over it, if Braben’s game was to come out on Dreamcast or PS2 or something; I’d take a look but sadly these yesteryear throwbacks are aimed at gamers that have moved on with the times.

    #14 2 years ago
  15. freedoms_stain

    Personally, I’ve never actually played a game by any of these guys (yeah even Molyneux).

    Looking at the output of the Oliver twins on Wikipedia I would be more inclined to pay them to get out of the industry and stop polluting it with the low-end tie-in trash they’ve been peddling for the vast majority of their careers than give them any money to make a game. lol that their pitch video talks about all the games they’ve made for top publishers yet can’t summon a single title – don’t worry guys, I’d be ashamed of thast back catalogue too. Put that on top of a pitch to reboot a game series that isn’t as fondly remembered as they seem to believe in a genre that isn’t as popular as it used to be.

    By the sounds of it David Braben largely shot himself in the foot by making a half arsed initial pitch. I think that genre, given the size of its audience, is looking a bit saturated at the moment too.

    Then there’s Molyneux. His reputation is biting him on the arse. The serial over-promiser now wants your cash in advance… As I said, I’ve never played a Molyneux game, but I did own one. Fable 2, it came with my 360 and I traded it in still in its cellophane, why? Reputation for being disappointing, had plenty of games with reputation for being good to play. I’ve also read criticism from people who don’t believe Molyneux needs Kickstarter and is more than capable of securing publisher backing to do whatever he wants, so there’s that too.

    #15 2 years ago
  16. DSB

    I thought that was gonna be an epitaph going on the headline.

    I definitely think that Kickstarter needs some more results to keep the momentum going, but I’m not surprised that any of those projects are faring less than great.

    Molyneux may be “okay” when he’s making weird games for other peoples money, but would I fund him personally? Well, maybe I would for a Populous game.

    I think Defense Grid 2 is an even better example. I would think that most anyone who has played Defense Grid recognize it as a really good tower defence game, but the Kickstarter had some really weird goals, like “We’ll only make a proper sequel if we get 200%”, for a project that was already asking for a lot of money.

    And somehow they just didn’t promote it very well. Most of the people I knew, who loved Defense Grid, had no idea that there was a Kickstarter happening.

    I think that’s the quintessential job one. People can’t contribute unless they know about the project. For Molyneux that’s a question of reaching all the old Populous users (who won’t just be on gaming sites these days) and for Braben it’s going to be even harder.

    #16 2 years ago
  17. RandomTiger

    A slowdown is much better than a crash with folk throwing too much money around without asking enough questions.

    #17 2 years ago
  18. mistermogul

    @12 – If I went to VC or Angels looking for investment and had millions in the bank what do you think the investors would ask me? “Why don’t you fund this yourself?”. PM is asking gamers themselves to take the risk for his own project.

    I agree I shouldn’t have jumped to conclusions as I have no idea what PM may be worth and “ripping off” was the wrong wording. My point was simply why not invest in your own game if you believe in it so much?

    By going to kickstarter he is giving himself a risk-free ride. Does he not believe in his own game? Can you imagine any of the dragons on Dragons Den giving him money if he has millions of his own?

    #18 2 years ago
  19. TheBlackHole

    @18

    Most developers are not cash-positive. They rely on VC’s to fund their games because they don’t have the money to. Then they being themselves back into the positive with revenue they generate from sales, or if they sell poorly (e.g. 007 Legends) then the company goes under because they are in insurmountable debt.

    Kickstarter is a way of funding a game based on the developer’s vision, not one changed by VC/someone else’s money, which is inevitably true of most games. It also guarantees that they won’t go bankrupt.

    On KS there is no interference. If anything, we might actually get to find out if games are better when publishers aren’t involved in the development process, or whether that leash actually keeps things focused and on-track.

    #19 2 years ago
  20. Stardog

    Another issue is the £ sign. As far as I know American visitors will also see the £ sign.

    #20 2 years ago
  21. DSB

    @20 Exactly, and they do. I think the British wing suffers for that. Once you actually pledge you see the approximate dollar value, but first impressions matter.

    I think something like Kickstarter benefits from the ease of use. Between being impressed and making a pledge you have maybe 3 clicks, but that’s provided that you understand the price.

    I don’t get why they don’t just add the approximate dollar value to the front.

    #21 2 years ago
  22. mistermogul

    @19 – I agree. Most devs are not cash positive. I am talking about Peter Molyneux here, not “most devs”.

    I just happen to think with all his deals in the past – selling out to Activision and Microsoft for example – that he probably has the money to fund his own projects and not have to ask gamers to risk their own capital.

    I agree Kickstarter is a great place where proper indy devs with little or no money can get funding and I’m all for that but when people who probably already have £millions start asking for funding, I’m not sure they are good ethics – in this case Peter Molyneux.

    #22 2 years ago
  23. TheBlackHole

    So a company with hundreds of employees who are probably not cash positive (Codemasters, Obsidian, Blitz etc) can ask for backing on KS because they don’t have any money (as a company, not as individuals), but one guy with a small company (who may also have some personal wealth) has to use his own cash because we know he might have some?

    Sorry, I don’t buy that. It’s not a prerequisite of Kickstarter that you have to be poor to use it. It’s about supporting good ideas that people believe in.

    #23 2 years ago
  24. viralshag

    I just can’t get behind PM on this one. I have this feeling of playing a game a year down the line, being disappointed and PM just shrugging his shoulders and saying something like “the industry just isn’t ready for this sort of game.”

    If Curiosity was supposed to be part of the pitch, that just turns me off even more.

    #24 2 years ago
  25. Old MacDonald

    20: It’s not just the £-sign. You have to input credit card details again, for instance, the first time you pledge for a british project. Not a bit deal, but I’ve seen first hand someone wanting to pledge to a project (this was Sui Generis), then not bothering when he realized he had to go get his wallet. He’d do it later, maybe. AFAIK, he hasn’t pledged yet.

    #25 2 years ago
  26. DSB

    @25 Yeah, the Amazon login wasn’t bad, but you can hardly blame them if they want to cut out the middleman.

    I don’t know of any magical way of creating that input without some kind of manual effort though.

    #26 2 years ago
  27. BinaryTweedDeej

    I’m really getting worried at an apparent belief that games should only be made by indies, and those indies should work for virtually nothing rather than ask for finance. That games should not be made by talented individuals working for salaries with job security.

    There’s a reason why studios cost more to run than indie outfits – quality of life. All this insistence on cheap projects is effectively suggesting that game developers should risk their livelihoods and the happiness of their families for the sake of their games. Is that really how we want developers to live?

    #27 2 years ago
  28. DSB

    @27 No one’s forcing them to do anything, they’re just doing what they love, in a way that they prefer. I think that’s cool.

    Which is to say nothing for the fact that artists and craftsmen have chosen that kind of life for thousands of years.

    Some people just prefer that kind of independence over working on the assembly line.

    #28 2 years ago
  29. BinaryTweedDeej

    @28 For example, I’ve got an idea. It’s groundbreaking, never-been-done before stuff. I’ve been pondering sticking it on Kickstarter to see if I could make a go of it.

    However, I have a mortgage, kids, and a full-time job. There is no way on Earth I can create a production-grade game in my spare time. 2 hours a day is simply not enough. I can’t work for next-to-nothing because I have too many bills, and it’s not fair on my family to expect them to be broke because I have a dream.

    So are we saying that I can’t have a family *and* pursue this idea? If so, that’s a shame for me, and a shame for gaming as great ideas aren’t the preserve of responsibility-free indies living with their parents.

    #29 2 years ago
  30. bugmenot

    It’s ridiculous and embarrassing how many people can’t tell the difference between

    The Kickstarter fad is over!

    and

    Sorry, not very many people are interested in YOUR game.

    #30 2 years ago

Comments are now closed on this article.

  • Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare Double XP and Elite Bonus weekend has kicked off

    Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare players can earn Double XP along with Elite Bonus on all platforms. There is even Double XP and Double Weapon XP on offer for Black Ops 2. The dry run is over. Prep for the Sunday reveal of #BlackOps3 begins now. 2XP/2XweapXP is live. pic.twitter.com/rn6SVtVJbY — Treyarch Studios (@Treyarch) April […]

  • Atlus makes “minor edits” to Dungeon Travelers 2 in order to avoid AO rating

    Atlus has announced it has made “minor edits” to four in-game images contained in Dungeon Travelers 2 to avoid an AO rating by the ESRB. According to a press release from the company, localization sometimes require changes to content in order for it to be “understood en masse,” which is why it worked closely with […]

  • Battlefield Hardline is 40% off through Origin this weekend

    The standard edition of Battlefield Hardline on PC is 40% off this weekend through EA’s Origin service. The Digital Deluxe Edition is also 40% off and includes various Battlepacks unavailable in the standard version. You can also pick up the Battlefield Hardline Ultimate edition for 23% off, which comes with all four planned expansions through […]

  • Submerged is an exploration-adventure game coming to multiple platforms

    Submerged is the latest title in development from Uppercut Games, and the exploration-adventure game is coming to PlayStation 4 and other platforms this year. The game takes place in a flooded city which Miku and her wounded brother Taku have reached by boat. Miku needs to find a safe place for her brother to rest […]

  • These screenshots for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt show superb attention to detail

    Some gorgeous new screenshots for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt have surfaced, and a couple are wallpaper worthy. Especially the one with the horse, but as you’re well aware, I’m horse crazed. The images below in the gallery have been scaled to fit properly, but if you head over to NeoGAF you can bask in […]

  • Namco kicks off Humble Store partnership with Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin

    Namco Bandai has started offering its PC titles on Humble Store, and this includes the recently released Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin. Other titles include Dragon Ball Xenoverse, and Project Cars. “In Japan, the Bandai Namco Group companies are known for supporting different charity programs and we are very happy to be […]

  • World of Tanks: 2,000 Bonus codes to give away

    Already have a World of Tanks account? We’ve got 2,000 codes for players to top up their Gold and Premium days. This weekend sees the World of Tanks Grand Finals take place in Poland, and we’ve got a bunch of game codes to give away to celebrate. Each Bonus PC code offers 150 Gold and […]

  • Mad Max contains Top Dog camps with boss fights

    Mad Max will have bases which vary in difficulty, some of which are considered a “finale” for a particular region and feature a boss fight. Speaking in the latest issue of GamesMaster via GamesRadar, the game’s producer John Fuller said this allows players to tailor their experience by deciding how much of a challenge they […]

  • Just Cause 3 gameplay trailer reveal coming next week

    Mark your calendars for Tuesday, April 28, because you won’t want to miss the gameplay reveal of Just Cause 3. Avalanche tweeted the date along with a teaser, as seen below. The box art has also made an appearance. Keep an eye on the game’s YouTube page, and we’ll be sure to post the video […]

  • First paid Skyrim Steam Workshop mod has been pulled

    Valve’s new incentive which allows modders to charge for their creations hasn’t been live for 24 hours yet, and already, one mod has been pulled. The mod in question was Chesko’s Fishing Mod for Skyrim, which the creator pulled after a community member questioned whether Chesko had permission from the creator of the character-idle animations […]

  • Resident Evil HD Remaster has sold over one million copies worldwide

    The HD remaster of Resident Evil has sold over one million copies worldwide since its January 20 release, Capcom has announced. The company attributed the sales milestone to producing a “great product” along with excellent word of mouth and praise from fans. In February, Capcom said Resident Evil HD Remaster was its fastest-selling digital title […]

  • The Crew: the Raid Car Pack and Raid Live Update now available for download

    The Crew players can now download the Raid Car Pack which is the last of four themes car packs. The Raid Live Update is also available, and it contains six new tuning specs. The car pack contains three new cars: the 2012 Cadillac Escalade, the off-road 2011 Volkswagen Touareg NF and the McLaren F1 supercar. […]

  • Geralt is very professional in the latest Witcher 3: Wild Hunt TV spot

    The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt has a new TV spot that’s short and to the point. The latest Witcher 3 trailer comes in the form of TV spot. It’s all CGI, and it looks good. If you’re more into gameplay trailers, the latest one will serve you well. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is out […]

  • Steam roguelike sale is live, offers deep discounts on a stellar collection of titles

    If you’re into challenging, procedurally-generated, and infinitely-replayable games, Steam’s current sale will hook you up. Steam is hosting a sale on roguelike games. Plenty of titles in the genre are on sale for upwards of 75% off. Highlights include Risk of Rain at 75% off, Don’t Starve at 66% off, Spelunky at 75% off, FTL: […]

  • Resident Evil: Revelations 2 finally gets online co-op in Raid Mode on Xbox One

    Resident Evil: Revelations 2 has been patched to support online play in Raid Mode on Xbox One. The Xbox One version of Resident Evil: Revelations 2 lacked online support in Raid Mode for a long time. Until today. A new patch has been released to bring that version in line with the rest of them. […]

  • A section in Killing Floor 2′s EULA about cyberbullying is riling up some fans

    Killing Floor 2 has recently got into a bit of trouble with some fans due to a clause in its EULA that gives the developer the right to revoke a user’s license without prior notice. The Killing Floor 2 EULA – just like many others found in modern games, has a section dedicated to cheating […]

  • World of Tanks: 2,000 free tanks and in-game cash to giveaway

    To celebrate the World of Tanks grand finals this weekend we’ve got some great freebies to give away to new players. We have 2,000 PC invite codes to giveaway, with each one offering new accounts a T2 Light Tank, 100 Gold and 1 Days Premium worth around €8.00. All you need to do is enter […]

  • Marvel announces partnership with Telltale, first game due in 2017

    Marvel and Telltale have entered into a partnership that will allow the developer to work on a new game series, due in 2017. Telltale has announced that it has partnered with Marvel Games, Marvel Entertainment’s video games division, for the development of a new game series. No indication was given as to what the new […]

  • Destiny: Bungie is not saying no to a player trading system

    Bungie has not completely ruled out the idea of bringing a trading system to Destiny. Destiny does not offer any way for players to trade items amongst themselves. But ever since the game’s release, players have never stopped asking Bungie to add one in. While the developer does not have a satisfying answer, it’s still […]

  • Destiny: Xur location and inventory for April 24, 25 – MIDA Multi-Tool edition

    The weekend Exotics market run by Xur: Agent of the Nine is now open for business. Destiny’s bizarre vendor, Xur, has arrived at the Tower. Xur is your man if you’re looking for Exotic armour or weapons. Not only that, but he will also let you exchange your old Exotic gear for new, upgraded versions. […]

  • Warcraft movie delayed yet again

    The Warcraft movie will no longer hit theatres in March 2016. The release date of the Warcraft movie has been pushed back by three months. The movie was expected in March 2016, but Legendary Pictures announced yesterday that it is now due on June 10, 2016. No reason was given for the delay. This is […]

  • Destiny: Iron Banner returns on April 28

    Destiny’s Iron Banner PvP event will return this Tuesday. Bungie has announced that the Iron Banner, it’s once-every-few-weeks PvP event, will make a return with next week’s weekly reset. It was initially due this week, but because of the recent Crucible changes that were implemented with patch 1.1.2, Bungie wanted to wait and see. That […]

  • Deus Ex devs take the piss out of Black Ops 3

    Deus Ex developers have been having a bit of a laugh at the expense of Call of Duty’s official Twitter account. You would be forgiven to think that yesterday’s Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 ‘Ember’ teaser was part of an ad campaign for a Deus Ex game, with all the biohacking, wearable tech, augmentation, […]

  • Bungie weekly update: Commendations begone

    Destiny’s weekly update is here to determine the fate of all those Commendations you’ve been earning in the past few months. Bungie started off this week’s update with a recap of the details revealed during the recent livestream. There wasn’t really anything on this front that they haven’t talked about already. With the exception of […]

  • This GTA 5 trainer lets you play as almost anything and it’s the best thing ever

    Want to play GTA 5 as a monkey, a cat, a fish, a deer or some other non-human thing that we eat or keep as a pet? ScriptHook has you covered. Not only can you play as critters, it change other game values, according to an explanation from PC Gamer. These values include making changes […]

  • EA Sports moves Rory McIlroy PGA TOUR release date to July

    EA Sports has announced Rory McIlroy PGA TOUR will be released in July. Originally announced for June, the golf game will now release the same week as the Open Championship at St. Andrews, on July 14. EA also provided some more color on gameplay features such as the ability to customize the game by borrowing […]

  • Jason Voorhees joins Mortal Kombat X in May, Kombat Pack owners get first dibs

    Jason Voorhees will arrive for Mortal Kombat X players in May, NetherRealm Studios announced today during the latest Kombat Kast. Jason will be shown for the first time on Monday, May 4 during a special Kombat Kast. According to EventHub which watched the livestream, the developer will also show off the character’s move and Variations. […]

  • The Witcher 3: Nvidia heads to Poland for a behind-the-scenes look – video

    A video for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt has been released, taking you behind-the-scenes with CD Projekt RED. Nvidia’s GeForce crew went to the firm’s studio in Poland to talk with the game’s executive producer John Mamais, who provides a look at the PC version of the upcoming RPG. CD Projekt, according to the video […]

  • Microsoft notes decline in Xbox unit sales for Q3 FY15 to 1.6 million

    Microsoft reported its Q3 FY15 earnings today, citing growth in Xbox Live usage as one of the contributing factors to the firm’s reported revenue. However, the firm noted a decline in units sales for its Xbox consoles during the quarter. Microsoft Q3 2014 (yoy comparison) Microsoft Q1 fiscal 2015 Microsoft Q2 fiscal 2015 The firm […]

  • Powerplay is a new feature included in the Elite: Dangerous May update

    The next update for Elite: Dangerous is coming next month and it includes a new feature called Powerplay. According to Frontier Developments, Powerplay allows players to participate in an ongoing battle that “enhances every aspect” of the game. Players can become allies with a number of galactic Powers and guide their strategy, pursue objectives in […]

  • Facebook says it’s “too early” to discuss large-scale shipments of Oculus Rift

    Facebook has said it is “too early” to discuss large-scale shipments of Oculus Rift as the VR headset is still in the development stages. Speaking during a call to investors, Facebook CFO David Wehner said the company had nothing to announce regarding the amount of stock it expected to ship. “We have not announced any […]

  • Battlefield Hardline’s first patch and rental server program hits next week

    Battlefield Hardline’s first patch has a release date for both consoles and PC. PC & Console patch and RSP for Consoles coming April 28th. Fixes include TDM spawns and more: http://t.co/BZYJeomPlr pic.twitter.com/27TCiY8hmf — Battlefield (@Battlefield) April 23, 2015 The update will include fixes to Punkbuster, Nvidia DirectX drivers, TDM spawns, contains weapon balance tweaks and […]

  • Modders can now earn money through Steam Workshop starting today with Skyrim

    Valve has introduced a new functionality within Steam Workshop which will allow mod makers to earn money for their creations, starting with Skyrim. The update will allow content such as mods, items, or maps to be sold through Steam Workshop for titles which have the feature enabled. A new “streamlined process for listing” has been […]

  • Play Skyrim for free this weekend on Steam and take 75% off while you’re at it

    Skyrim is free this weekend on Steam providing wanna-be Dragonborns who have procrastinated on wetting their blades with Stormcloak blood the perfect opportunity to give the RPG a try. Head over to Steam and download the game and play for free until April 26 at 1am PDT. The game is also 75% off if you […]

  • Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 “Ember” teaser video released ahead of full reveal

    Activision has released a Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 teaser video titled “Ember” and you can watch it right here. Here’s the video blurb: “In the next 50 years, technological advancements will lead us into a world where only those who risk going too far, will find out how far we can actually go.” […]

  • Dragon Age Keep update includes more customizability and control

    Bioware has updated Dragon Age Keep after listening to community feedback. The update includes more customization and control over heroes, world states, career and more. Players can now customize hero portraits or delete Dragon Age: Inquisition heroes from the Hero section. They can also remove playthrough states from the World State Manager and keep up […]

  • Here’s a look at some Conker community creations in Project Spark

    Conker’s Bug Reunion releases today, and below is a video showing some of the community creations you will be able to download using the creation pack. Project Spark is a free download on Xbox One and Windows 8.1, and you can download the Conker Creation Pack today. It contains 350 assets in order for users […]

  • Rainbow Six: Siege video shines spotlight on the British Counter Terrorist Unit

    Ubisoft has released a Rainbow Six: Siege video which gives you a look at the British Counter Terrorist Unit which features “the best of the Army, Navy, and Air Force.” The firm said that over the next few weeks it will introduce the public to each of the units in the game. Rainbow Six Siege […]

  • Mario Kart 8 DLC and Mewtwo for Super Smash Bros. headline eShop update in North America

    Nintendo has updated the North American end of the eShop with an update and new DLC for Mario Kart 8 and the Mewtwo DLC for Super Smash Bros. Other highlights include Mario Kart DS on Wii U Virtual Console, the continuation of International StreetPass Week and more. Full update is below. Nintendo eShop Mario Kart […]

  • Square Enix host E3 2015 conference this year on June 16

    With Final Fantasy 15, Rise of the Tomb Raider and Deus Ex: Mankind Divided on the horizon, it should come as no surprise to learn that Square Enix will be hosting a dedicated E3 2015 conference this year. The presentation will take place Tuesday, June 16 at 9am PDT/12pm EDT/5pm UK. It will be broadcast […]

  • Final Fantasy 4: The After Years 3D remake releasing on Steam next month

    Final Fantasy 4: The After Years has been given a makeover and will be released on Steam of PC next month. You can now pre-order it on Steam and take 10% off for the time being. The game will be released on the digital service May 12 and will include trading cards and achievements. Thanks, […]

  • This Project Cars video shows off the racer’s multiplayer

    Project Cars developer Slightly Mad has released a new video giving you a look at the game’s multiplayer. The game is out next month, and if you would like to refresh yourself on the tracks included,  give this a look. While you are clicking links, here’s the minimum and recommended PC specifications which dropped last […]

  • Looks like Logitech is getting out of OEM mouse production business [Clarification]

    Logitech will no longer produce “low-end” mice, citing a decline in PC accessories. This story has been updated to include a clarification. According to a Reuters report, per MCV, the firm will instead focus on video accessories and streaming music, as its wireless Bluetooth speakers are now its best-selling product rage. This will help offset […]

  • Win! We have 1,000 Heroes of the Storm beta keys to give away

    Must have more MOBA? Win one of our 1,000 Heroes of the Storm beta keys and see if you’re more Blizzard than LoL. Can’t wait for June 2? Of course you can’t. We have 1,000 closed beta keys for Heroes of the Storm to give away this week, allowing you access before Blizzard’s MOBA goes […]

  • Xenoblade Chronicles X Nintendo Direct airs tomorrow, April 24

    A Nintendo Direct devoted entirely to Xenoblade Chronicles X will air this Friday, April 24. The video showcase will start at 11am PDT/2pm EDT/7pm UK. After the showcase, a new Nintendo Treehouse: Live presentation featuring the game will air. This is the second Xenoblace Chronicles X Nintendo Direct, but the first in English. The first […]

  • Blizzard will have 500 game stations set up at gamescom 2015

    Blizzard is heading to gamescom 2015 in August and it will have 500 game stations set up for attendees to get their hands on five of its titles. The developer will be set up in Hall 7 and those who stop by will be able to get hands-on with the latest content for Heroes of […]

  • PS4 price cut to £299 in UK

    Sony has dropped the price of the PS4 in the UK. For a limited time only, you can grab the console for £299.99 from Argos, Game, Tesco and Very. Go to Amazon.co.uk and you’ll get it for £289. You’ve only got until April 28, then it goes back up to £349. Go, go, go. For […]

  • Mad Max: first ever gameplay footage revealed

    Today, we get to finally take our first look at gameplay from Mad Max. Avalanche and Warner Bros. have shown off the first gameplay trailer for Mad Max today. The trailer below offers a look at melee combat, car combat, customisation and much more. Give it a watch below: There are a few new screenshots […]

  • Overlord: Fellowship of Evil has four-player co-op like we figured

    Codemasters has pulled the veil back on the next Overlord game, and its a four-player co-op game called Overlord: Fellowship of Evil. Rhianna Pratchett is back to write the story. The game may be co-op at its core, but it can still be played single-player. Each of the four playable character have strengths and weaknesses, […]

  • Update now available for Pokemon Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire, Pokemon X and Y

    Pokemon Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire along with Pokemon X and Y are being updated by Nintendo to fix a few bugs and in-game text. There’s also the possibility of a few hacks and exploits being fixed. Per Nintendo Life (via Serebii), both patches are 250-270 blocks in size, and it’s a mandatory update which […]

  • Side-scrolling cover shooter Not a Hero gets a demo

    Not a Hero, the upcoming game from OlliOlli developer Roll7, has received a demo. The demo for Not a Hero was made available today on Steam. In the game, you play as Steve, the campaign manager for BunnyLord. A time-travelling rabbit who’s running for mayor of London. Think this is an absurd premise? This trailer […]

  • You have until April 30 to export your Green Day: Rock Band tracks to Rock Band 3

    Harmonix has announced that those looking to export their song collection from Green Day: Rock Band into Rock Band 3 can only do so until the end of the month. April 30 will be the cutoff date for anyone who wants to export tracks from Green Day: Rock Band into their Rock Band 3 library, […]

  • Batman: Arkham Knight minimum, recommended, and ultra PC specs revealed

    Batman: Arkham Knight is looking like it’s going to be quite a taxing game. Nvidia has released a list of the minimum, recommended, and ultra PC requirements for Batman: Arkham Knight. Here’s the full thing: Minimum OS: Win 7 SP1, Win 8.1 (64-bit Operating System Required) Processor: Intel Core i5-750, 2.67 GHz | AMD Phenom […]

  • Bloodborne patch 1.03 is live, reduces loading times, fixes suspend/resume bugs, more

    Patch 1.03 is now live for Bloodborne. The patch reduces loading times, adds item descriptions to loading screens, and fixes other various bugs. From Software has pushed update 1.03 live to all Bloodborne owners. As promised, it reduces loading times by approximately 5 to 15 seconds. Another new addition is showing item descriptions instead of […]

  • Battlefield 4: first look at Community Map in action

    Get your first look at the map designed by the community of Battlefield 4. Battlefield 4′s community-designed map is a reality. DICE has recently updated CTE to include an early version of the map. It’s not fully textured as Westie is about to show you, but the layout is nearly finalised. Westie goes over the […]

  • Microsoft apologises for uploading misleading Witcher 3: Wild Hunt footage

    Xbox’s YouTube channel uploaded a video of The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt yesterday that was captured from the PC build. The most recent gameplay video for the The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt appeared on the Xbox YouTube channel and showed a quest from the game’s opening section. A few minutes after it had gone live, […]

  • Assassin’s Creed creator’s new game is Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey

    Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey is the game Assassin’s Creed creator Patrice Desilets has been working on. Patrice Desilets has just announced that the next game his indie studio Panache Digital Games is making is called Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey. The announcement comes from Desilets’s keynote at the Reboot Develop event in Croatia. The trailer started […]

  • Bloodborne: Cathedral Ward closed door mystery solved

    The mystery of the locked door at the bottom of the Cathedral Ward in Bloodborne has been solved. Bloodborne, like earlier From Software games, is filled with doors that don’t open the first time you try them. Some will give you “locked” messages, others “does not open from this side”. Some of these will open […]

  • Assassin’s Creed creator Patrice Desilets is revealing his next game now [UPDATE: ended]

    Patrice Desilets, one of the original creators of Assassin’s Creed is hosting a presentation where he’s expected to talk about his next project. Patrice Desilets has emerged once again. This time he’s attending development conference in Croatia. Desilets is giving a live keynote and there’s a good chance we’re going to hear about his next […]

  • Destiny House of Wolves: everything you need to know about gear upgrades & The Reef

    Bungie revealed plenty of important details in last night’s Destiny stream. Let’s go over everything. Alex wants to make sure you don’t miss any of the information revealed yesterday. Most of it affects all Destiny players too, even those who don’t intend on buying House of Wolves. During the first stream, Bungie explained the armour […]