US court allows Silicon Knights to sue Epic over claims of incomplete Unreal Engine 3

Thursday, 31st March 2011 14:03 GMT By Stephany Nunneley

The courts have given the go ahead in a suit filed by Silicon Knights against Epic over Unreal Engine 3 licensing. The original complaint, filed back in 2007, claims Epic “defrauded” the firm by claiming the source code for UR3 was more complete than it actually was.

According to the claim filed, Epic “failed to provide a working game engine,” which resulted in Silicon Knights ditching UR3 and using its own game engine for Too Human which the firm claimed resulted in “considerable losses.”

In it’s original court filings, the firm claimed Epic not only defrauded the Too Human developers but “a major portion of this industry,” as well by withholding the complete version of the engine and focusing more on Unreal Tournament and Gears of War development than the engine’s development tools.

Per court documents obtained from Kotaku, most claims filed by Silicon Knights were dismissed by the courts, however it is now free to pursue its claims of “fraud, negligent misrepresentation, unfair competition, breach of contract and breach of warranty,” against Epic.

“Epic had a possible motive to deceive SK into entering into the license agreement in order to fund the development costs of its own games and delay the work of SK and other competing licensees on their video games,” said the court. “There is also Epic’s admission in its counterclaim that it developed the [Unreal Engine 3] in conjunction with the development of its own game as part of its ‘synergistic model’ and not separately as it had led SK to believe.”

Epic has yet to issue a comment on the latest proceedings, but Silicon Knights president Denis Dyack told Kotaku: “When Epic first went public about our case to the press, they said that our claims were without merit. Two separate federal court judges have now disagreed with Epic, and have ruled that the case does have merit.

“Silicon Knights has always wanted to have our focus be on making great games, not litigation. This ruling will allow us to have our day in court, before a jury, and to shine the light publicly on Epic’s conduct. We are very confident the jury will see the truth behind Epic’s actions.”

Too Human was released in 2008, and while reviews for the game were not overly positive, Dyack confirmed to VG247 work on the Too Human trilogy would continue as Too Human was one of the most “innovative games on 360, period.”

More information on Silicon Knight’s claims can be found through the links, as VG247 covered the accusations rather extensively back in 2008.



  1. Shonak

    Hm, I wonder if Too Human Two will ever be released. An announcement at E3 would be Megaton for me personally. :) Although Too Human had some major flaws, it was still very enjoyable I think.

    #1 4 years ago
  2. Patrick Garratt

    I seriously doubt it.

    #2 4 years ago
  3. Robo_1

    Totally forgot about this. Be curious to see how it all pans out.

    #3 4 years ago
  4. The_Red

    Is it just me or the court is seriously late? I know these things take time but 3 freaking years!?

    #4 4 years ago
  5. Zarckan

    I fucking hate EPIC and their egotistical business practices…

    Along with their two head self cock sucking staff Mark Rein and CliffyB.


    #5 4 years ago
  6. M. K.

    Well UE3 or not, I couldn’t get warm with this game at all :/

    #6 4 years ago
  7. Erthazus

    @1,2, if i remember, Silicon Knights partnered with Microsoft Game Studios for the Too Human trilogy.

    #7 4 years ago
  8. Phoenixblight


    Yes they did but since the game flopped Microsoft Game studio said no more and I don’t balme them that game is crap.

    And Silicon Knights can try to pull this crap but it will fail somehow Bioware created Mass Effect with U3 and it came out a year earlier. The game started development in the same time as Too Human. Silicon Knights is just trying to get money because they failed with Too Human and now just stuck creating mobile games.

    Edit: My bad Too Human was actually announced in 1999 for the PS but they put on the back burner because of Eternal Darkness and Twin Snakes but Too Human was announced as a trilogy in 2005 just like Mass Effect. SO still no excuse.

    #8 4 years ago

Comments are now closed on this article.