First LittleBigPlanet reviews to go live tomorrow night

10/10

I had trouble putting the controller down last night and go to bed as a result of playing this game.

And when I finally did go to bed, it was hard to stop thinking about what things I should have tried to make.

If it’s EG it’ll be 5/10 and they’ll make a killing out of the hits on the comments thread

/prediction

Ill go for 8/10 from EG with the things morriss does’nt like being used as an excuse to mark it down.

I’m not writing it! (sadly)

Five reviews. Three 10s, two 9s.

Un-named site – IGN: 9.8/9.9
Eurogamer – 8/10

Oh they will.

Otherwise, a 10/10

Yeah it’ll have to IGN, really. They get ‘everything’, always.

Sorry morriss I meant that the things you did’nt like will most likely be the things that will put Tom off, not that you’ll be writing it :p

Tom’s not doing it, it’s Oli Welsh, so it’ll be interesting to see what his take on it is.

Oh! Very interesting.

Oli Welsh?

8/10 confirmed.

I shoud really point out why (Post above wont let me edit)

Oli Welsh is only a specialist on MMO games and I dont think I’ve seen him give a game which isn’t a MMO more then a 9/10.

Do remember, he was the one who review Metal Gear Solid 4 and the infamous 8/10.

http://www.eurogamer.net/article.php?article_id=143797

“We love you, Snake. Don’t come back.”

And yet, Welsh knows nout, why? Because MGS4 is one of the best games of all time, probably the masterpiece of gaming this decade.

Ooo, that explains it rather well yeah. It’ll be fun to see what it gets.

Let’s play nice kids, eh? It’s just an opinion and it’s just a videogame.

Well technically a professional review is abit more then just an ‘opinion’, its viewed by millions and sometimes has the power to make people buy, or not, a product…

It’s still an opinion. One with potentially a lot of influence but still nothing more than the opinion of one.

As long is the opinion is adequately backed up, then it’s ok in my book.

Hmmm.

I very much doubt that, morriss.

So I’m lying?

I love Metal Gear Solid 4 as much as the next fan, I really do. But I honestly never understood how it was more than an 8/10 game anyway, so I thought EuroGamer had that right.

MGS 4 was a masterpiece, but it was hardly different to anything that had come before, in gameplay or in plot. It was refinement more than innovation, and refinement based upon a lineage of how many games?

LittleBigPlanet on the other hand is pure innovation, but it might take a patch or two to refine that innovation into something legendary (I think Mm can do it more quickly than Hideo did, they’re almost there even). The Mm guy has detailed the controls, and there are things people are being such grumpy socks about.

I’m hoping LBP gets a 9, I think it deserves it. But I would understand if it got an 8. The thing is, for something to get a 9 or a 10, I honestly think it has to be a really legendary game, an instant classic and something that’s damned special compared to what’s come before.

If all games start getting the 9 and 10 mark, they become so much less special, and then we get the “5 equals shit, 10 is about as good as any good game this year” mindset borne of that.

So I could live with an 8 on LBP, hoping for a 9 because it really does deserve it, but expecting an 8.

Good points, well made.

Swedish site gives 9/10

“+ PLUS
Charming, beautiful and a durability that is the console life out.
“- MINUS – MINUS
BELL-RINGING not fully control all times, the dimensions confuse sometimes.”

You might want to change that “that is the console life out” to “that draws the console life out”. I think that’s what the reviewer meant, it’s the way it seems to read.

I definitely agree with that list of boons and caveats though, and I knew that control of how characters jump between the three layers would come back to bite Mm on the bum. It can be mastered–I mastered it and I’m no supreme gamer, roomie mastered it too and he is–but when I think about it honestly, I think it’s more difficult to master than it should be, and not for the right reasons. That’s a point that needs to be raised.

LBP is still my game of the year though, despite all that.

It’ll be a 10s all round. No, really. It will.

Sony’s probably booked a load of advertising with everyone for a start.

Probably? Have you seen the ‘INTER’LittleBigPla’NET’ recently?

Blerk: I’ve never actually seen Sony do that, otherwise I would’ve thought they’d have done it with MGS 4? ;p

I was a little worried given some past form from Oli – he did write a very positive preview for LBP on EG previously though.

He’ll still give it a 8/10.

We’ll find out anyways in half an hour.

9/10 :O

HOLY MOTHERFUCKING JESUS CHRIST SOPASTAR SUPERSTAR ON ICE WHO HAS GOT THE X-FACTOR LIKE BREAKING KIDS IN TORTURE IN 60 SECONDS FLAT LIKE JACK BAUER!!!!

9/10!

Comments section over there really is excellent right now.

9/10 What a flop!

…

Fools!

What do you expect though?

The fanboy wars is practiclly WWIII.

Sadly the idiocy has spread to the EG forums as well. It’s not so much fun there.

So I’m lying?

Well, it’d be nice to see you practice what you preach.

I love how gaming news has sunk so low as to report on review scores. No wonder a 9/10 is seen as a disappointment by some.

We now have a three point scale.